Hello everyone! Here is the final part of this story. I have read your comments and agree my grammar isn’t the best. I greatly apologize. I get very into these stories as I type them out. They are truthful and definitely bring back memories that turn me on. Again I apologize and will try to do better!
A few things to lay out. Matt and Cassie are “transplants”. They are from the Midwest and moved to the west coast to preach at the church my wife (and I guess I go to). They are a young couple in their early 20s and we’re married at 19. Our senior Pastor’s wife, Katie, is in her 40s. She believes a woman should be obedient to men whom they have a relationship with. Shortly after Cassie and I were caught, Katie asked Cassie and Matt to attend marriage consoling with her. Our senior pastor, Mark (I am hiding all names and I can’t remember what name I used prior so I apologize for the discrepancy) had no idea about any of this. This will come out later in the story. Mine, Cassie’s, and Matt’s relationship lasted about 9 months and this is the end. on to the story!
I have been hooking up with wives about twice a week when I get a call from Matt. He explains him and Cassie have been attending consouling and would like me to attend. I decline stating that their relationship problems aren’t my problems. Now I considered blocking him but he begged me to come by Friday evening and hear them out. I, reluctantly, agree and Friday comes. I head to the church and walk into their house. I knock and Matt opens the door. He hugs me and thanks me for coming. I ask where Cassie was and where we were having consoling. He says “in the bedroom”. Literally, the way he said it made my hair stand up. What the hell kind of shit is this, I think to myself. I walk over and open the door.
On the floor, in front of the bed Cassie is on her knees, naked, looking up at me. Braiding her hair, half naked, was Katie. Katie looks at me and says “Thank you for coming Shaun”. I stumble over my words and start to back up to leave the room. “Um ya I can’t do this. So sorry miss Katie.” She finishes the last braid and walks over to me and takes my hand. “Shh Shaun. It’s ok” she whispers. “God says a woman must obey her man and it appears here that you are her man, so let’s make sure Cassie obeys you”. She says with a grin. I start to get flustered and blurt out “I can’t miss. I..” she shushes me and unbuckles my belt, unbuttons my pants and slides them off.
My cock starts to grow as I feel Katie’s hand lightly stroke me over my boxers. “Ah look, a real man’s cock. Larger penis’ get closer to a woman’s womb and insure proper breeding. God punished some men with smaller cocks which means they cannot breed their wives and in turn they can’t be men for their women.” Katie says. She slips off my boxers and my cock presents itself. “Matt, come over here and take your pants off” Katie calls out. Matt walks over and strips off his pants. His cock is hard but it’s noticeably smaller. He has about a 4 inch cock while mine is 10. “Matt, let’s get this over with. Your brain is fogged with sin and lust. Stroke your cock to completely remove that sin.” She instructs Matt.
Matt jerks off and soon says he is gonna cum. Katie motions to cum on her face and Matt explodes onto her face. She smiles with her cum drenched face. “Good boy. Now that sun isn’t fogging your mind you can think clearly. Shaun is going to breed your wife today. Shaun is the man here.” She says as she turns to Cassie, “Cassie suck Shaun’s cock. Get him ready for you” Katie grabs my hand and pulls me close to Cassie. Cass takes my cock into her hands and starts stroking me. She then takes my cock into her mouth.
As Cassie is working my cock with her tongue and lips, Katie kneels behind me. She reaches through my legs and grabs my balls and gently massages them. I feel her other hand spread my ass and she starts eating my ass. The feeling was amazing. I started letting out a few groans. Between Cassie’s and Katie’s tongues I leaned my head back trying not to collapse. Soon this came to an end and Katie stands up. “Shaun lay on the bed it’s time”. Cassie stops sucking and I fall on the bed. Cassie wastes no time getting on top of me. She grasps my cock and easily slips it inside her.
She rides me gently at first. Kissing me, telling me that her pussy was mine and she craves me. Her bouncing got more intense and I felt a massive build up. She holds my head up with her hand and looks me in the eyes and whispers “I want to see the moment you impregnate me”. I don’t know what that did to me but I couldn’t hold it and came deep inside of her. Easily one of the strongest orgasms I had. She pulls off of me and cum rushes out of her used pussy. She lays on the bed spread out while Katie takes some pictures.
After a couple of minutes I regain some clarity and walk out to drink some water. After a couple of more minutes pass. I walk to grab my stuff and leave. Katie is on the bed fully naked. She looks like a wife you would see in a 50s pin up poster. Shave everywhere except for her long bush. Her breasts are average but her aerials are very large. I grab my pants and she calls out “oh Shaun, I believe I deserve the same treatment.” I start to give some excuses and she stops me. “Shaun, come here, Fuck me”. Instantly my cock becomes hard and I walk over to the bed. She is laying next to Cassie who looks like she is still on that cock high. I grab Katie’s legs and full her onto my cock. As my cock slides into her wet pussy she lets out a loud moan. Usually I fuck slowly then ramp up but I couldn’t help myself. I pounded Katie into a new planet. It was like I turned into an animal. I couldn’t tell how many times she came but when I came she didn’t move. She looked like she was asleep. Cum gushes out of her pussy as I push her away from me like a used toy. Cassie immediately rolls over and starts eating Katie’s pussy, audibly slurping up my cum. I get dressed and leave while Cassie’s keeps cleaning.
I didn’t hear anything for a week. Until a board member from our church messaged my wife calling her a whore and said we are not invited to church again. My wife is extremely pissed. I guess Katie used the pictures to preach cuckolding to women seeking marriage counseling. Well katies husband found out and found out that I wasn’t the first guy she’s done this with. He left her and the church and Cassie and Matt left very shortly afterwards. I have no clue what happened to Katie. Cassie and Matt moved back to their home towns then went to a proper college and have higher paying jobs and 3 kids. No none of them are mine.
As for my wife and I. We look back on this and laugh. That concludes the pastor cuckold story. Hope y’all enjoyed.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/1132kr7/mf_i_made_a_youth_pastor_a_cuck_part_4_of_4
Damn, that was a messed up church scene
Never happened