The night after Josie and I masturbated to Amy’s dirty masturbation video, I talked to Amy on the phone. Amy nervously said, “What did you think of the tape?”
I said, “What tape?”
Amy said, “Jack, I love the blackmail thing, but let’s just talk about this for real for a minute.”
I said, “Okay, I fucking loved that tape…so hot. I hope you don’t mind that I included Josie in the blackmail thing.”
Amy said, “I don’t mind…it turned me on that I knew she was going to watch it too.”
I said, “She and I masturbated next to each other while we watched it.”
Amy said, “that’s so fucking hot. Um…I have to be honest that I watched it a few times and I masturbated before I put it in the mail…giggle.”
I said, “Amy that was just ridiculously hot. You’re basically the hottest girl ever – not sure how I got you.”
Amy said, “Thanks…giggle…I guess you’re just lucky. Um, what did you think of me…giggle…fingering my ass? I can’t believe Josie asked me to do that. ”