This happened a few years ago for her 25th birthday party in New York City. We had been going out a few years by then and we decided to go out to NYC for her 25th birthday. A few months before we had talked quite openly about sex and she had confessed to have had a threesome previously, once with another girl and her ex and another time with her ex and another dude. She confessed to have found both experiences really hot, especially being with 2 guys.
Fast forward to NYC. This was the first time we were out of town since we had had our “sex talk.” I booked an apartment in Queens overlooking Manhattan. The view from the large windows of the living room was stunning. We had just settled in the apartment and were ready to go out to town. We were staring out the window and I decided to fuck her as we looked onto Manhattan. I lifted her skirt pulled her panties down and felt her wet pussy (she is almost always wet and ready). I sank my cock in her and pounded her hard as we both looked out the window. Her love for rough sex, the long flight across the country and the fact that we had not fucked that morning due to the early departure of the flight made for an intense sex session. A few minutes later she received the first creampie of the night and cleaned my cock with her tongue. After I rested in the sofa while she cleaned herself up and we were ready to hit the city.
After having dinner in a fancy restaurant followed by drinks for her bday celebration we decided to stop in a neighborhood bar for one last drink. As usual the drinks were making her especially horny. The bar was packed it was a summer night and the AC was not really working too well. We were forced to share a table with other guests. The only table free had 2 guys in it. We sat down and chatted amongst ourselves after asking if it was OK to join the table. Thirty minutes later, I hit the john, predictively when I return the 2 guys are chatting with her, I joined the conversation, it was the usual banter where you are from?; what are you doing?; how do you like NYC? etc. One of the guys appears to be more interested with his phone while the other was more interested in her. Time goes by, my gf and one of the guys are enjoying a good chat, I tried to keep up a conversation with the other dude but it was really not happening so I joined the conversation with my gf and this stranger. He seemed like a nice guy, personable and well dressed, I can see why my horny gf would find him interesting. Finally, the boring friend decides to leave, leaving his friend with still ¾ of a pint left so he stays with us and we continued to talk. He hit the john and it is then when in my drunkenness I asked my gf if she found him attractive and if she did, to hand him her panties.
As soon as he returns from the john my gf excuses herself to the toilet. I talked to the guy trying to get a feel about him, I asked him if he had a gf. He did but it was a long distance affair. She was in college out of state. My gf returned not making eye contact with me. I decided to go to the bathroom again to give her some space. When I return, they were both chatting candidly like they were before. As soon as I sat down she grabs my hand and directs it to her crotch. I can feel her wet pussy, no panties. We continue to chat normally, closing time arrives and the most natural thing to do is to offer a drink at our place.
In the elevator up to the apartment it was only us three and we all quiet down. I set the example of making out with her as I stick my hand under her dress and finger her wet snatch. When we are done she moves over to our new friend, he follows my example and fingers her roughly, making her moan. Once in the apartment while the gf goes to the restroom I look for some booze and I fortunately find an open bottle of bourbon and I pour some in 3 glasses. There is only one couch that looks out to the window. Me and the stranger enjoy our drink talking about the great view. Finally the gf arrives. She is no longer wearing her high heels and her pale red painted toes stand out.
“Why don’t you make the view better for us and strip for us!” I call out as I turn the already dim lights off, the stranger’s phone starts to blare out some tunes. She is drunk she is not very coordinated but after a few moves she removes her dress exposing her bare pussy and her black lace bra that matches her long black hair and contrasts with her pale white skin. She removes her bra, after a few more moves. By now both I and the stranger have our cocks out, I beckon her to come to us and she crawls towards us as I point to our friend. She goes down on him as start grabbing her tits and ass. I can smell her juices and as I move my hands up her inner thigh I can feel how far her juices dripped down her right thigh, I test the left and it also has streaks of her grool. I don’t recall her ever being this wet. I want to fuck her, I start to strip as she removes the stranger’s clothes. I penetrate her as she goes back to suck him off, she feels really good. Minutes into it the stranger is looking at me, I know he wants to fuck her too. I give her a few deep, hard strokes, she moans, I pull out and nod at him.
He stands up from the sofa. “Do you have any condoms, I don’t have any.” Silence. We don’t have any me and gf have been doing it raw since we first met.
“No but I’ve been on the pill since I was 16 and this is the first time we are doing this” She volunteers as she sits on the sofa and spreads her long delicate legs as her feet rest on the seat.
“Fuck it” with that he moves towards her and slowly sinks his cock in her. I notice how his cock is thinner than mine but seems a little longer. He starts gentle and I notice how she wraps her legs around him. They make out while he is fucking her, I can see how she is creaming his cock and I wonder if the same thing happens when I am fucking her. I am rock hard, it’s a strange feeling since it is the first time I am sharing her with another man. I can also hear her moans, she is defiantly coming, enjoying a new cock (that I know of) after 3 years together.
“I’m going to nut in you” he starts to pound her hard as she tries to push him closer to her with her legs I see his balls contracting as he empties his cum into her. The both cry out, my heart is pounding out of my chest. He finally pulls out and see his cum drip on to the leather couch and on to the wooden floors, it luminesces in the dark room. He stands up and walks to the bathroom as juices drip off the tip of his penis. “I haven’t fucked or fapped in over a week! I try to save it for my gf but that was worth it!” Meanwhile I notice how my gf sinks her fingers into her cunt and then tastes the mixture of his and her juices. I wonder if he prefers his taste to mine. I am transfixed staring at her now lying limp on the sofa. I am not sure if she has passed out from the pleasure or the alcohol or both. Suddenly, watching a week’s worth of a stranger’s cum drip out my gf’s cunt makes my primal urges erupt. I walk to the edge of the sofa grab her limp legs and push her knees next to her ears. I sink my cock into her. Sloppy seconds. The thought turns me on and I start pounding her hard. “Make me yours again” I hear her whisper.
My balls are hurting from slapping against her yet I continue to pound her for a few more minutes, I can hear coming again as I feel her tighten up. I fuck her deep bottoming out and I wonder if he reached any deeper. I can feel my balls contract and I start ejaculating inside of her as I start groaning like an animal. I pull out and spread her legs open and look at her third creampie of the night leak out of her snatch. The stranger is gone, I didn’t even see him grab his clothing. That night and the following morning I filled her up 3 more times. I have since shared her a few more times.