— Interrupting —
After my [33M] wife, Erin [29F], and I decided to open up our relationship, it didn’t take as long as we thought to find potential fuck buddies nearby. Lou was a married man in his early 50s who also had an open marriage and kind of a hippie vibe. Kate was a single mom and young professional with an ass that wouldn’t quit. And after we vetted each others’ picks, we were excited to find out they were both free at the same time.
I dropped Erin off at Lou’s in an old neighborhood, and ten minutes later I was in Kate’s apartment downtown, making out as our clothes came off. But right when Kate took her bra off, I suddenly got cold feet. I panicked, worrying that this was a bad decision and Erin and I were ruining our marriage. Kate was upset, but ultimately very understanding, having gone through a bad breakup less than a year ago, and I rushed out the door and back to Lou’s.
I ran up the steps and pounded my fist on the door, shouting for Erin. My heart sat in my throat as I heard Erin moaning just inside and suddenly stop. A moment later the door opened and Erin was standing behind the screen door.