I just realized this subreddit exists… Been holding onto a few of these for a while now.
I would say this is my first threesome, but really it is the first one that doesn’t break the rules of this site…
This happened when I was 18 years old. I had been casually dating a beautiful blond girl named Julia for a couple of months. I say casual because there was never anything making us official and really we barely did anything that resembled more than friends. We kissed a few times, but that was much less than I was used to at that time. Even the conversation was stale. Really, in hindsight I should have ended it and moved on, but then I wouldn’t have this wonderful story.
Like I was saying, I was on the fence about ending things with Julia. She was such a sweet girl that I was really having trouble following through on that. That was until I met Jessica.
Jessica was this amazingly sexy figure skater that always had practice before my hockey team. I used to show up early just to watch her skate. We would flirt with each other through looks, but neither of us stepped up and made a move. That was until one evening when I was out with my friends. It was summer at this point and I hadn’t seen Jessica for months. In those same few months is when Julia entered the picture.
This time I wasn’t missing my chance. I knew things were going to end with Julia, so I figured that as long as I am respectful it would be okay. It’s really amazing how the 18 year old mind twists things around to justify it.
I went up to Jessica and used the corniest line I could think of. So corny that even repeating it isn’t something I want to do. I knew it was cheesy as fuck, but it was a good ice breaker. It got her talking to me and that was all that was important. We hit it off immediately and I learned that our attraction was mutual. What I had assumed were her giving me flirty looks were in fact her giving me flirty looks. She told me that she was hoping I would make the move, but then it was too late and the sports season ended.
That night we left together and went to my brothers house which I was house-sitting while he was working out of town. Our of respect for Julia, we kept it strictly platonic. I did tell Jessica about Julia for the sake of transparency. I made it clear I was going to end it the next time I spoke to her, which was supposed to be after that weekend when she was back in town. The next night I was heading out camping with friends, so I invited Jessica along as well.
Jessica and a few car loads of her friends agreed to come with us. This made for a great night from the usual sausage party our camping nights usually were. Things were going great…
Jessica tells me that another car load of her friends is coming out as well. She said one of her friends would be sharing a tent with her because she didn’t have one. Whatever, I was trying my hardest not to do anything out of respect for Julia, so this just made it a little easier on me.
A couple of hours go by and a car pulls up. A bunch of girls get out and start walking towards the firepit. They were just silhouettes at this point, but as they got closer there was a familiar voice. Jessica and I were sitting together when it came to me… “Holy fuck, it’s Julia”.
I full on went into panic mode. Fortunately I was honest with Jessica from the beginning so I told her that’s the girl I am seeing and about to end it with. Jessica’s face dropped, that’s her friend who is sharing her tent. That’s when I realized we never said her name to each other.
Jessica was amazingly cool. She said that I should take Julia aside and talk to her. Give her a heads up away from everyone. It turns out Julia had planned on surprising me by showing up that night. I originally invited her, but she was heading out of town for the weekend, or so she said.
Julia made her way into the firepit and by this point Jessica was already up and over to greet her. Julia asks her where this new guy she is seeing is so she can meet him, not realizing it was me. Then she sees me, and says this is [listentomerightnow] I’ve been telling you about.
The few people in the general area who were there all night and heard were all cringing a bit our of pure awkwardness for how this was going to go down. Before Jessica could respond, Julia ran over to me and gave me a huge hug and kiss. AWKWARD!!!
Julia ran back to her car to get her stuff when Jessica said “do it now before this gets any worse”. I ran over and grabbed Julia at the car. I asked her to come for a walk to my tent which was a few sites away.
We laid in my tent and I told her that I was really sorry. I told her that I wasn’t expecting her to show up, but that I didn’t think things were working between us. She teared up and immediately asked me what she did wrong. I reassured her that it wasn’t her, and that she was beautiful and sweet and that I was to blame. She kept pushing, and stupidly I gave her a reason hoping it would end the conversation so I could break the next bit of bad news. I told her that we just weren’t compatible romantically. I wanted what she wasn’t ready to give and I didn’t want to push her for it. I was an idiot, I know.
She was lightly sobbing at this point and I felt like a serious piece of shit. I then had to break the next piece of bad news, which I was hoping I wouldn’t have to do. I told her that Jessica and I had been hitting it off, but that I didn’t do anything with Jessica out of respect for her. She didn’t give a fuck if I did anything with her, she was upset that I met someone else. She let me know that Jessica and her were friends since they were little kids. I made sure to point out that Jessica had no idea it was her until she showed up just now.
Julia was a lot more emotional than I had imagined or experienced and I didn’t know what to do. In hindsight I did mostly the opposite of what I should have. In trying to console her, I was giving her a false hope that we still had a chance. Minutes turned into hours, and Julia was still pleading to give her another chance. She even began offering to give me a blow job and have sex.
Then Jessica popped in. She crawled into the tent and said that she was sorry and didn’t know. I assumed I just lost both of them, but Jessica made it clear that we were still going to make a go of it. The three of us laid there for another hour talking. I was in the middle of the two of them on this small air mattress. It was cozy to say the least.
Then in front of Jessica, Julia says “Is this all because I wouldn’t suck your dick. I’ll do it now.”
Caught off guard, I quickly said “no, that’s not it at all”. That didn’t stop her from grabbing me over top of my shorts. I grabbed her hand and pushed it away. She was persistent. I turned towards Jessica in case she had a way out of this. She gave me a smile as if to say “haha sucks to be you”.
Fuck that I thought, I rolled to the outside of Jessica pushing her in the middle. Julia still tried reaching over Jessica to grope me. It was actually a very desperate moment for her.
Finally, I grabbed Julia’s hand and jokingly put it on Jessica’s boob. I was in a very awkward and uncomfortable situation and I didn’t really have the knowledge to get out of it gracefully. To my surprise, Julia kept her hand on Jessica’s boob. Jessica turned her head towards me and started kissing me.
Julia grabbed Jessica’s hand and put it on her boobs. I reached in and grabbed Jessica’s other breast. This position went on for a few minutes before Jessica reached, with her free hand, down and started rubbing my cock through my shorts. That was the exact moment I knew what was going to go down.
I moved my hand down to Jessica’s shorts and started rubbing her pussy through the silky shorts she was wearing. She slowly grinded her hips while I rubbed her. Jessica turned towards Julia and they started kissing. While I was rubbing her shorts with my hand, I began grinding my cock off of her tight little figure skating ass. I could feel her firm ass cheeks gripping my cock as I grinded it on her.
I knew Jessica and Julia were kissing and their hands were moving around, but I couldn’t figure out exactly what they were doing. I was too busy touching Jessica to care either.
I slid my hand underneath the silky shorts she was wearing. I could feel that she was freshly shaved. She felt my hand going down so she opened her legs a little wider. She was soaked already. The back of my hand was getting wet from her shorts bottoms that I was rubbing into her.
I decided to pull her shorts down to her knee’s. She kicked them off the rest of the way on her own. She rolled back so that she was on her back. Her legs opened wider. Julia was kissing her face and had lifted Jessicas shirt to play with her tits.
I was also kissing Jessica at that moment, which is what caused Julia to lean in and begin kissing me. At first it was a three-way kiss, but that wasn’t as graceful as it should have been. Julia and I began kissing, only taking breaks to lick Jessica’s nipples which had hardened and stuck out a lot more than I was expecting. I mean afterall I did see her on ice in nothing more than a bikini with leggings.
I was flicking Jessica’s nipple with my tongue when Julia leans in and began rubbing my cock over my shorts. The difference this time was that I was hard and she grabbed a handful and stroked it. I could barely tell I was wearing shorts the way she worked it with them on.
After a few minutes of that, Jessica rolled over putting Julia in the middle. Jessica didn’t waste any time, she stripped her remaining clothes and did the same to Julia. At this point I was the only one wearing clothes.
I finally got to see Julia’s pretty large breasts. They were probably a large C or small D, but on her tiny frame they looked massive. Jessica on the other hand was a large B or small C. A decent handful as a good description, but Julia’s were for two hands.
Julia wasn’t fully shaved, but she was freshly trimmed. Thank goodness the moon was full this night and our eyes had adjusted to the moonlight. I could see her fully naked body, minus the one breast which Jessica was kissing.
I reached down and began to touch Julia between her legs. I worked my way down, and like Jessica, she was already very wet. So wet that when I pulled my finger out, there was a long string of grool attached for almost a foot before it separated.
I moved down towards both girls legs. I first began kissing Jessica’s stomach and worked my way down to her pussy. I kissed all around the outside and barely touched her labia as I moved from side to side. She was already moaning and quivering just from that. Before taking it further, I moved over to Julia and did the same. Her reaction was more moaning with a slight and slow pelvic thrust. You could feel that she wanted me to push hard into her, but I didn’t.
I went back to Jessica and gently licked her clit. I moved it around with my tongue in a circular motion. While doing that I used a finger to rub it around the opening to her pussy. Each circle I moved it in slightly deeper. Her moaning got louder. I could see that Jessica was fingering Julia at the same time. They were also kissing very sloppily. Very wet.
Finally I got a full finger inside of Jessica. I continued circling my finger while it was inside. I made sure to put pressure on every part that I could touch. I knew the bulge at the top was where it felt really good. At least according to my last girlfriend. I rubbed a finger all over it. Reaching behind it and then curling the finger as I pulled it out. Jessica was going nuts. Her hips were thrusting hard and she had her one free hand on the back of my head trying to grind her pussy into my face as hard as she could. I stopped.
Back to Julia where I repeated the same thing. Jessica began touching herself while licking Julia’s nipples. Julia smelled like cherries while Jessica smelled like coconut.
I could feel that Julia was tighter than Jessica. With only one finger inside I couldn’t do as wide of circles as I was doing for Jessica. She could have been flexing for all I know, it is just one of the memories that came back to me as I write this.
Jessica rolled up and straddled Julia. She leaned down and began kissing Julia with loud slurping noises. It was a messy kiss. I took my free hand and began fingering Jessica while continuing to lick Julia’s pussy.
I leaned up and unbuttoned my shorts. I pulled them down enough so that my cock was sticking out. I touched it off of Jessica’s pussy and she arched her back even more. She wanted to take it all. I put it between her labia and grinded it on her pussy without entering. Every time the head was close to her pussy opening, she was angle her hips to try to get it to slip inside of her. She came close once, getting the whole head in before I pulled back.
I then did the same thing to Julia who was laying on her back. I rubbed my cock through her wet pussy, coming close several times to putting it in, but stopping myself each time. I switched back and forth a few times before Jessica made me lay on my back.
Both girls got up and stripped my remaining clothes. As soon as I was naked it was almost as if there was a race to be the first to suck my dick. Jessica won. She began licking a circle around the top. She then did what I have come to know as the corkscrew. She spun her head in circles with each circle getting deeper and deeper onto my cock.
Julia was kissing me, but I had her move up and straddle my face where I continued eating her wet pussy. I could feel her dripping down my face as I licked away. Jessica continued trying to ram my entire cock in her throat. She would hit the back of her throat and keep it there while moving her tongue around.
Eventually, after ramming my cock into her throat, it happened to slip further. It was the first time I’ve had someone fully deep throat me. I could feel it sliding in and out of her throat. She did gag a few times, but managed to not have any real trouble. When she went all of the way in, she would use her tongue to lick my balls. I returned the favor and grabbed the back of her head and pushed my hips into her face, holding her there for a few seconds before releasing.
Julia must have noticed my attention slipping from licking her pussy because she got off of me and went down to join Jessica. Both girls began passing my cock back and forth. Each time trying a moment of a different technique. Julia wasn’t able to get it down her throat like Jessica, but she tried. The best part was when both girls began licking my cock simultaneously, kissing once they reached the top, then repeating it all the way down.
Jessica stopped sucking my cock and began licking Julia’s pussy while Julia continued sucking me. I couldn’t see their technique, but Julia’s blowjob was mind blowing. She really went for it, giving it everything she had. All of that while Jessica licked and fingered her from behind.
I couldn’t take anymore, so I reached down and grabbed Julia. I pulled her up on me and she straddled my cock. She reached around back and grabbed it, rubbing it through her pussy a few times before slowly lowering herself onto it. Honestly, it took everything I had in me not to explode right there.
Jessica moved up and straddled my face like Julia did earlier. Both girls faced each other while one rode me and the other was getting licked by me. They fondled each others breasts and kissed. Julia grinded hard, never lifting herself off of me. She tried to get me as deep inside of her as she could. It was almost as if she was making up for not being able to deep throat.
Jessica was riding my face hard. All I really needed to do was stick out my tongue and her hips did everything else. Still, I had a hold of her hips trying to slow her down so I could do some of the work. It seemed like being restrained was making her go harder.
Jessica asks to switch with Julia. Julia slowly slides off of my cock leaving it white with her grool. Jessica bends over while still straddling my face and shoves my cock down her throat, cleaning it off completely. She turns around and slides onto it. Jessica was riding up and down. She was moving much more than Julia was, and the sound of our bodies slapping together was almost comical.
Julia laid beside me kissing me. Every few minutes she would lean down and grab my cock from under Jessica and pull it out. She would suck it hard and fast before directing it back inside of Jessica. That was so fucking hot.
After Jessica got off, I rolled over onto Julia. I thrusted myself into her. It felt like I was trying to thrust through her. This kind of left Jessica out, so I leaned up. Jessica then straddled Julia’s face while Julia licked her. I continued pounding away on Julia’s tight pussy.
Jessica eventually turned around and straddled Julia, just like earlier. This time I was inside of Julia, so I pulled out and pushed back inside of Jessica. I could feel Jessica rubbing her own clit while pushing her shaved pussy back into my cock. As she pushed harder I could tell she was going to cum.
Jessica came in a loud moan and a strong quiver that nearly pulled me right out of her. Once the quivering ended, I pushed myself back inside Julia. Jessica stayed straddled over Julia for a minute, so I put a finger in her. She was a little too sensitive for that, so she turned around and began guiding my cock with her hand. It was inside Julia, then in Jessica’s mouth. All the while Jessica was rubbing Julia’s clit, or licking it when her mouth was free. After a few minutes I could hear Julia’s moans getting louder until I could feel her already tight pussy squeezing my cock in a rapid succession until she finally began shaking. Both girls had finished.
Jessica looks up at me and tells me that it is my turn. She spins around and says I can come inside of her because she is on the pill. I kept switching between Jessica and Julia until I got close, then I began blowing my load into Julia before quickly switching back to Jessica to finish it off. Once I was done, both girls sucked my dick again, which effectively just cleaned it off.
We all laid down in the now soaked air mattress. I was in the middle with a girl cuddling into either side. We fell asleep almost immediately, or at least I did, waking up several hours later in the same position.
The morning seemed very awkward, especially between Jessica and Julia. Julia didn’t push the relationship any further that morning, but did continue to push me for the next few weeks. Jessica on the other hand was amazing about it all and we actually dated for a few months before I moved away to another city nearly 9 hours away. We decided not to do long distance.
The three of us did hook up once more at a party a few months after Jessica and I had broken up. I was back for a weekend and feelings still remained. After that hookup, Julia moved to the city as me and we gave it a try, but in the end it didn’t work. I believe it was the lacking emotional connection we had. She might think it was because I was hung up on Jessica, which I can’t say was untrue either.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5kues1/the_fortunate_coincident_mff
Grool…really?!