Following my previous post, this is about the second time I had a threesome.
So after out first experience (see [https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/zqz5oy/my_first_threesome_mfm/](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/zqz5oy/my_first_threesome_mfm/)), we really enjoyed it, and I got confident that a guy can be respectful, and will not abuse of the boundaries that we set. I didn’t know I would enjoy so much watching her wrap her mouth around a cock in front of me. She told me she liked it, but that his dick is a bit too thick to suck comfortably: she prefers my size (longer and more average thickness). He texted us, saying that he enjoyed it a loooot, and that he would love to do it again, even if it continues to stay oral only. We talked about it, and agreed that it was best to focus back on our relationship: we could do it again but not too soon.
A few months pass, and we decide we want it again. On my side i want her to have the most handsome guy, and I feel like his long hair was not the most masculine thing, so for me I would rather search for someone new. On her side, she loved his long hair, but she also agrees to search for another guy, mostly hoping that he would be easier to suck his dick.
We fire up our previous Tinder profile, searching for someone to have a threesome with. same rules: only oral sex (no kissing, no penetration). We talk to a few guys, but some of them really try to take advantage of us and don’t want me involved: they try to propose “a first date alone to get to know eachother, then possibly a threesome”. We knew this is only to get to fuck her alone, and then dich us. So we continue to search.
Finally we find someone that seem nice. After chatting for a few days, we decide to meet him in the same bar closeby, this time knowing that we would take him him if we get a good feeling. A few drinks later, we click and propose to continue drinking from home.
We all go to my apartment, and open a few more beers. He knew from our online chat what he was getting into, and me and my gf had already our first experience so it was a bit easier. Last time she was the one initiating it, and at first I thought it would be the same, but time passes, and we are still just chatting, and I want to get things sexual.
She is sitting in the couch next to him, me on a chair next to her. So I decide to make the move: I get up next to her, take her hand to invite her to get up. They both get up (he understood what I was going for) so we are each on either of her side, and I start putting my hand on her hips, getting one hand down to her ass over her skirt. He follows my lead and does the same.
All of a sudden, she snaps and asks us to stop: this was too much, she felt like she was trapped between two tall guys, and felt like she was not in control. We stopped of course, and talked for a few more minutes, but it was too much for her. We called the night off and that was it: he went back home, probably with a huge boner and only a though of my hottie to jerk to before going to bed.
Talking about it, we realized that she needs the first move to come from her, as she needs to feel ready to handle two men at once. At least we knew for next time.
The next time was what I really call my “second threesome” because this time it actually happened. We went through the same process: Tinder, filter out the losers, finding someone we both agree on, chat a bit, then meet at a bar. He was really nice, we had a good feeling with him, maybe better than the other two. We invited him over, and we continued to drink at home. This time we were clear by text: the one making the first step would be my gf.
So here we are already buzzed by the beers, and at some point she was ready and made the first step. She faked something like “It’s too warm in here, I should remove my top”, and continued by removing her clothes: she was now in her matching thong and bra: very sexy. She asked if he enjoys the show, and if she was up to his expectations. Of course being the hottest girl I knew, the answer was obvious: he was so turned on by her show.
As he was sat down, she turned around and had her ass right in front of his face: he looked at me and told me “wow man she is absolutely stunning !! the most sexy ass ever”. She then asked him to take his dick out, and came between his legs to start giving him a blowjob. I quickly followed by taking out my dick out too. She sucked us both, and gave us handjobs for a very long time.
We continued it by moving to the bedroom, where she continued to play with our dicks, it was to hot. At some point we were changing position: she was laying down on the bed, i was on her side licking her boobs, and he moved around to face her pussy. He knew he was not allowed to penetrate her, and was very respectful, but surely he was wanting it so bad !! We were laying there together, the mood was really good, and he asked: “I know you guys said no penetration, I have to say you are extremely sexy, and I would absolutely love if you would come back on this rule… But I understand if you said no, we agreed that this was a no go.”
The question was targeted to her (while including me), and she took a second to think, then turned to me and said: “For me I agree, we could try it, so it’s up to you. And of course if you feel uncomfortable we can stop anytime.”. The thought of sharing her pussy to another guy was a little bit scary, I didn’t know if i was ready for this, but since we have a good feeling with him, I think he can be the right one to do this with. She was virgin before me so this was a big step, but I took a little time to think and replied “Ok, we can try, and if I don’t feel right I will ask you to stop.”.
This is the big moment of my life: I am letting a guy insert his dick inside of my gf’s pussy, which had never felt another dick than mine. I was a bit nervous, but I also liked it. He put on a condom, and got between her legs, and started to insert his dick. I had her boob in my mouth, and I felt her body pushed back up the bed because he was sliding inside of her. She was looking at me as she was expressing her first time with someone else, and I could see the pleasure on her face when he got inside of her. She was trying to tone it down (probably to avoid me feeling like he’s better than me), but I could tell how good it felt. My dick got instantly rock hard !!
He continued to slide in and out of her, while I was sucking on her boob, and I felt her boob giggling in my mouth from his fucking, it felt amazing !! Soon after, he came in the condom while being inside of her, leaving her unsatisfied by the short time that it took him to cum. After all, he had a long tease to get him edged, so that makes sense.
He was not up for a second round, and it was getting late, so he got dressed and left us to reconnect alone. We said goodbye without putting clothes back on, and as soon as he was out the door, we ran back to the bed, and had the most intense sex (so far).
From then on, it was clear we liked it, and this is going to happen again !
Stay tuned to hear about the next threesome :) This was the beginning of 5 years of threesomes. DM is open
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/10uu2pf/my_first_time_fully_sharing_my_gf_in_a_mfm