A professional soccer player [M23] and I came on his girlfriend’s [F20s] face and he didn’t know I knew who he was [MFM]

I actually posted this story a while back in a different forum, but that place is dead so I’m going to add some more detail and post it here for you all!

So, here’s the story. I was living in an unnamed North American city (I don’t want to give too many details so I don’t give him away) back when Craigslist personals was still a thing, and one night I was bored and horny and scrolling through the personals section. As I was looking through, I saw that someone had posted that he wanted a guy to come over and cum on his girlfriend with him. No sex, just cumming. I still remember the title of the ad — “[neighborhood] splash”, referring to the fact that we were going to “splash” onto his girlfriend. The neighborhood was an up and coming neighborhood with a lot of young people, so the whole idea caught my interest.

I sent him a message describing myself, etc., and he wrote me back pretty quickly. Basically he wanted another guy to come to his condo (one of those condos in a remodeled warehouse type of thing), watch him and his girlfriend have sex, then when they were ready he wanted me to jerk off onto her and he would either do the same thing or cum inside of her. Sounds like a good plan to me, as I got hornier and more interested. He described themselves but didn’t want to send a picture, for what would later become an obvious reason.

Craigslist had this weird glitch where occasionally it would show the other person’s actual email address where it was supposed to show the random craigslist made up address. So I happened to notice this guy’s email address as he and I are writing back and forth and it was a pretty distinctive email address that showed both what his first name was and that he was clearly into soccer. Curiosity got the best of me and I did a little Google searching. After not too much searching, I found the name of a pro European player who was spending a year playing for this North American team. By now, I was pretty sure it was going to be him.

This guy eventually invited me over, so I drove over and went to their place. He opens the door, and and sure enough, it’s him. I’m not even into soccer, so I wouldn’t have known him, but I recognized him immediately from the pictures I found online. He let me in almost immediately and his girlfriend comes out of the bedroom. As you might expect, holy shit she was gorgeous. She was very sweet (nicer than him — you could tell he was pretty arrogant, but he was cool with me), and she was also very flirty. He seemed to have a sort of weird dynamic where he obviously like the idea of her being watched and used by another guy, but he wasn’t as interested in her flirting with me. She still did it pretty openly, though, perhaps to sort of goad and tease him, as brats can do!

We chatted for a little bit, but by now it was pretty late and he definitely wanted to fuck. So he invited me to watch them fuck, and I sat on a chair in a corner near their bed as they started kissing and he removed her clothes then his own. He got her on her knees and she sucked his cock, quite well, then he pretty quickly took her and sort of tossed her onto the bed on her stomach. He came up from behind her and started to fuck her from behind, and she turned her head and just looked straight at me as he fucked her.

I was stroking my cock by now, and the whole time he was fucking her she alternated between watching my cock and looking into my eyes. Eventually he flipped her over onto her back and started fucking her that way, hard. Her breasts bounced absolutely wonderfully in the light from one lamp in the far corner. He motioned for me to come over and touch her, so I did. I came over there and stood right in front of her face, hard as a rock, and played with her breasts and her nipples and squeezed her neck as he fucked her. She reached out and squeezed my balls, which he was OK with, but when she started to pull my shaft toward her mouth he said “don’t suck his cock.” That was fine by me, though, and I alternately stroked my own cock and played with her breasts and choked her lightly as she played with my balls.

Eventually it became clear he was getting ready to cum, so I got a little closer to her face and started focusing on stroking my cock just right so we’d both be able to cum on her at about the same time. I was stroking and staring into her eyes as she squeezed my balls, then he pulled out of her and came up to her face on the opposite side and aimed for her face (and at an upward angle away from me, thankfully). I decided to give him first honors, so I kept myself right on the edge, at a 9/10, then he started swearing in [his language] and as soon as I saw one of his sprays of cum I let loose. She was then getting it from both sides, and I felt my cock just pulsing over and over with pleasure as I came onto her and he did the same.

I played with her tits gently and slowly a little as he and I both stood there above her, then he went and sat in a chair and I went back to my own chair after feeling her breasts just a little more. We both at there on opposite ends and she lied there, keeping our cum on her except for the little bit that she absentmindedly played with. We chatted briefly, but by then it was almost sunrise, so I excused myself and let them get to sleep. It was one of the most surreal sexual experiences I’ve ever had.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/10v1iqn/a_professional_soccer_player_m23_and_i_came_on