My [F]irst Attempt at a Couple [MF] [MF] [FF] Swap

I butchered the tags, but you’ll see why, its not a straight forward story. This is a true story, it happened when I was in my early 20’s, but names and some small details have been changed to protect the innocent ;)

I met Jason through a mutual friend. My buddy Chris thought we would hit it off. I’m not one to typically agree to a blind date kind of scenario, but Chris was a pretty good friend and I trusted him.

We did hit it off. He was shorter than me, I’m 5’11, but he wasn’t insecure about it. He was handsome, strong and chisled, with rough working hands that felt amazing on my soft skin. He could fuck for hours and cum over and over, and he shot cum out like a fire hose, a new experience for me that I loved. A pretty good play thing indeed.

We had a good time together and talked openly about our fantasies. After a few months, he told me he’d always wanted to see two women together and swap with his buddy. I disclosed that I would definitely be down for that and he looked truly shocked, but quickly started planning.

He calls the buddy he’d been scheming with and sets it up. We have dinner with them first to make sure there is a vibe. Buddy was good looking and not annoying, fuckable at least. Buddy’s girlfriend, Talia, was a 10, OMFG hot. She was petite, maybe 5’1 and 100 lbs, but curvy. Long brown hair with cute little perky tits. I don’t know how dude had bagged such a beautiful women, but I was intrigued.

We started out with parallel play, both kissing and groping our guys, but next to each other on the bed. Clothes start to come off. Talia had the most perfect brown nipples, I absolutely love small breasts with big pointy puffy nipples. I start blowing her bf and mine goes to eat her out. I swap positions with Buddy and then Talia and I are next to each other while being eaten out and I start touching her breasts, teasing her nipples. The guys emerge from our pussies and Buddy pushes Talia’s face into mine to kiss. I lean in to kiss her and she… freaks the fuck out. She jumps off the bed and starts cursing at her boyfriend.

“I TOLD YOU! I TOLD YOU I DIDN’T FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH GIRL ON GIRL YET!”, she grabs her clothes and storms out. I immediately push her bf off me and start grilling the guys as they babble excuses and explanations. I was pissed, she was not on board with the girl/girl play and her bf had just hoped she’d get there “in the moment”. Jason had told me that she was super into me and was looking forward to being with a woman. He admitted he too had hoped Talia would change her mind in the moment. They had lied to both of us.

I get dressed and tell them to stay the fuck away from us and I go to find Talia. She’s outside smoking a Camel, the same flavor I smoked at the time. I cautiously approach and immediately apologize.

“Jason lied to me, he said you were super into me and I should have talked to you beforehand and not just believed him. I’m so sorry for making you uncomfortable”.

She nods and tells me she really appreciates that, but doesn’t blame me. She confides that her bf is an asshole and she was already thinking about calling it quits before this.

I pull out my cigarettes and complement her good taste to ease the tension. She laughs, we start chatting about the dumb guys, our lives, a whole variety of subjects. Pretty soon we are giggling and having a great time together. She looks at me and says “I hope you don’t think I don’t find you attractive, you are beautiful, I’ve just never been with a woman and I told my bf I wasn’t sure about it and just wanted to stick to a swap for now. It’s about him, not you”. I tell her not to worry about it. About an hour had passed, I could hear the guys had turned on the TV, but were staying away after the tongue lashing.

“You know what we should do?” I say with a sly smile “let’s take my car and go out together, ditch the guys without a word and teach them a lesson.” She laughs and agrees immediately. We decide to go to a nearby bar and have a drink together. We discover we both have an affinity for vodka and dancing.

Two guys approach us and try the come up from behind and grind move. Talia tells the guy behind me to “get the fuck off my girlfriend” and I follow suit. They retreat and she grabs me close to her, stands on her tippy toes to reach my face and kisses me. She pulls away red and flushed, “I’m sorry!”. I laugh and ask what she’s apologizing for. “I should have asked you first, especially after that fit I threw”. I told her again that she did nothing wrong and to not worry about it, then gave her permission to do anything she wants to me with a wink.

We spend the next few hours dancing and having a great time, kissing and groping and telling the vast sea of horny men to leave us alone. When the bar closes we get into my car and I ask her what she wants to do. She looks pensive for a moment and asks if she could maybe come over to my place. I had told her earlier about the adorable cottage I lived in with no roommates, just my tabby cat.

Talia had a nervous energy during the drive and I did my best to put her at ease. When we get to my house, I tell her we should talk. I ask her point blank whether she wants to just come in as a friend or if she wants more.

She bites her lip “I think I want more”. I explain that I am not going to put any pressure on her and that she does not need to feel like she owes me anything. She nods “I know, but I want to, I’m mostly scared because I have no idea how two women have sex”.

I promise her I will show her and take it slow if she is sure that’s what she wants. She nods, still visibly nervous.

She excuses herself to the bathroom and I pour us each a double vodka on the rocks, head to my room and light some candles. I slip out of my clothes, leaving on my matching lacey black bra and hip huggers. She emerges from the bathroom with her hair tied up in a bun and wearing a pink and black polka dot bra with matching cheeky briefs. I hadn’t gotten a good look earlier because clothes had flown off so quickly and it was pretty dark. She was breathtaking. Olive skin, athletic build with a bubble butt, and six pack. She was a soccer player and gymnist and in amazing shape. I was into rock climbing and yoga and was in incredible shape myself; tall and lean, with tiny waist, big hips and ass, and natural 32DDDs. I let my long strawberry blonde hair cascade freely down my back and she caressed it and twirled it in her free hand as she sipped her drink.

We drank, dance, and swayed before laying down in bed and kissing. She was soft and sweet smelling. I love the experience of sex with women for a lot of reasons, but at the top of my list is that it’s never rushed like it can be with men. We float together for what seems like eternity just kissing each other and touching before Talia unhooks my bra and then her own. She kisses my large pale breasts, doing her best to grasp them in her small little hands. I let her suck my sensitive nipples as I quiver and feel my pussy start to throb. I flip her onto her back when i can’t take it anymore and reciprocate. I could practically fit her entire pefect little breast into my mouth. I explore the rest of her body, reaching under her and grabbing her firm ass in my hands. I slowly pull her undies away and toss them to the floor. I kiss her thighs, her stomach, inching closer to her pussy. She opens her legs wide beckoning me in. I make her wait, tracing my tongue around her outer lips, barely touching her. She moans and arches her back, pushing her pussy towards me desperately. I gently circle my tongue over and over, feeling her clit get hard as I do, slowly at first and then faster. I feel her wetness and take the full length of my tongue and lick her juices up, penetrating her with flicks of my tongue, before taking her clit into my mouth and sucking. She starts writhing under me and grabs at the bed to hold herself together. I keep at it, steady and rhythmic and she soon howls as she cums for me. I focus my attention on her pussy while she spasms and I suck her juices up.

At this point, I’m already wet and turned on so I grab my double dildo and ask if she wants to give it a go. She looks insulted. “Its your turn first”. I had just assumed she’d be uncomfortable as it was her first time, but she wanted to reciprocate. She mimics my moves and does a damn good job. I grab the back of her head and thrust my pussy into her as she enthusiastically licks, slurps and swirls. She puts two of her tiny fingers inside me and finds my g spot while she sucks my clit. I reach climax pretty quickly and pull her up after to taste myself on her lips. She’s on top of me grinding her wet pussy against me and we are lost again just kissing and grinding and moaning.

We pause to sip our beverages and then she grabs the double dildo. “How does this work?” I explain a few different positions and she decides she wants to face each other with our legs scissored. I suck her side of the dildo to get it nice and wet and slowly penetrate her as she gasps in pleasure, then position one leg under her and the other leg over her and I let the other end penetrate my eager pussy with a gutteral moan. She picks up the rhythm quickly and takes her half into her tiny body so our clits are grinding against each other as we thrust, holding each other with our breasts heaving in rhythm. I can’t even say how long we went on like that. We both kept orgasming, waves that went on for minutes, hours, years. It was one of the best nights I’ve ever had and we fucked until dawn before passing out together, curled up and spooning and laughing with sheer glee.

Talia indeed broke up with her bf after that and I told Jason to fuck off too after he claimed I “cheated on him” when we never had even discussed exclusivity. He was just pissed we ditched them. I kept fucking her for a few years on and off. We were more FWB than anything and eventually lost touch after she met a guy who she got serious with and married. She reached out a good decade later about a threesome/couple swap, but that is a story for another day.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/10rz02a/my_first_attempt_at_a_couple_mf_mf_ff_swap