This story doesn’t involve my wonderful wife. Eventually, I’ll write another one about a recent experience we had recently, but for now this story is about the girl who I lost my virginity to (and took her virginity), Sarah, and another ex-girlfriend whose virginity I also took, Molly.
Sarah and I dated in high school and especially at the end of our relationship senior year, we had a good sex life from my perspective. Looking back, I was incredibly selfish, but I was young and dumb. In fact, many of our conversations after we broke up while I was in college were of the, “guess what I like now?” and “I wish I could show you what I’ve learned” type conversations.
Molly and I dated for few months in college. Even though I was the first guy that she had sex with, she didn’t have an aversion to sex, just hadn’t found a guy that she thought was worth it. Luckily, she thought I was that guy and we had a fair bit of fun.
Sarah and Molly were fairly opposites. Sarah was shorter, curvier, with breasts to die for. I’d guess they were 36DD at the time of this story. Her ass was also pretty great, but the main attraction was her boobs. Sarah was pretty introverted, but boisterous around people she was comfortable with. Molly was extremely extroverted, tall and thin and athletic, but not much to grab on to other than her hips which were great. Her smile and perfect golden brown hair are what pulls you in.
Sarah and I continue to live in the same town as we grew up throughout college so the summer between junior and senior year of college we were both back in town. At this point Molly and I had been over for quite a while. Sarah texted me somewhat randomly and we made plans to hang out some… I wasn’t really expecting sex, but I wouldn’t have said no either. Sometime later, Molly texted me out of the blue and mentioned that she was in my hometown visiting some local attractions and asked if I wanted to hang out some. Folks, this right here is why you try to end relationships as amicably as possible! I quickly adjusted plans with Sarah so that we would all go out to a bar and grab some drinks and food and see where the night takes us.
In the interest of getting to the good stuff, I’ll fast forward. We meet up, get drinks at one bar, move to another for food, then move to another sort of bar/club combination. At some point, I get up to use the restroom and I come back to Molly and Sarah sitting very close next to each other giggling and looking at me. I gave them a look and they settle down and we have a few more drinks over a while. I forget who said what, but at some point we decide we are over the loud music and the people and decide to go back to my place.
We get back to my place, I throw something on the TV, grab everyone some water, and we all grab seats in the living room. I’m sitting next to Sarah on the loveseat (how appropriate!) and Molly is in a chair. I have to admit, I wasn’t expecting anything to happen at this point, nor was I really encouraging anything to happen, but I guess the girls had other intentions. Sarah puts her hand on my leg, which I wasn’t sure was intentional or not, but she moves her hand to the inside of my legs and starts going further up my thigh.
I make eye contact with Molly and then kind of motion downward with my eyes to Sarah’s hand. Molly acknowledges with a wink. My lizard brain kicks into gear and suddenly my mind is racing. I wrap my arm around Sarah’s shoulders and rest my hand on one of her big, perky tits. I look at her and she looks at me and we sort of attack each other’s faces while making out. Her hand reaches my dick which is damn near all the way hard at this point and she starts rubbing it through my shorts. I glance over at Molly who is still in the chair, but staring at us with one hand rubbing her tit and pinching at her nipple and other hand rubbing her pussy through her jeans. I go back to making out with Sarah, until I feel another set of hands on my legs gently pushing them apart.
Molly has left her chair and is kneeled on the floor in front of me and is now between my legs undoing the button and zipper on my shorts. She pulls my dick out through the hole in my boxers and half pulls my pants down. And then she starts going to town with her mouth on my dick. Sarah and I break our make out session as she stands up and takes off her top and bra and I get a great look at those wonderful titties falling out of her bra. She walks behind Molly who is still going to town and gathers her hair in her hand and is gently easing her on. Molly makes some room for Sarah between my legs and they take turns sucking my dick. Sarah kind of nudges Molly out of the way and she brings her great tits up to my cock and starts to tit fuck me. Hell… fucking yes. Molly uses this opportunity to stand up and stretch a bit and take off all of her clothes. She very purposely bends over to show off her pussy which is definitely enough to take my eyes off my dick occasionally peaking out between Sarah’s tits.
I… need a break otherwise, I am going to cum real early in this whole experience, so I gently push Sarah off and suggest that we move to my bedroom. We all stroll down the hall to the bedroom and Sarah and I use this opportunity to remove our remaining clothes. I lay down on the bed and motion for Molly to sit on my face. While Sarah and Molly, both had pretty awesome pussies, both innies with plump outer lips and tiny, perfect, pink inner lips, Molly’s was sweeter and I wanted it… on my tongue, rubbing on my face. She sits facing me and I start going to town. Sarah meanwhile, sits on my cock and starts easing herself down before somewhat quickly transitioning into full on bouncing. I’ve got two out of three of the best pussies I have ever seen (my wife rounds out the trifecta), with one of them on my mouth and the other on my cock.
Folks… I didn’t last long. I pulled my tongue away from Molly’s cunt and told Sarah I was about to cum. She switched from bouncing to just saying deep on my dick and grinding back and forth on me. I came deeeeeep inside her. She hopped off as my dick was going limp. I asked both Sarah and Molly to lay next to each other their backs and the I got between them and started to finger them with each hand. At this point in my life, I had learned the “come hither” motion and was using it to the best extent possible on both of them. It was awkward and my arms were getting tired, but I was doing my best to make it work. The feeling of my cum in Sarah juxtaposed with the natural wetness of Molly was amazing. Both girls were moaning and breathing really hard. Seeing Molly’s smaller tits jiggle and Sarah’s bigger ones bounce as I fingered both of them was amazing. After a little bit of this, Sarah is getting really vocal. She suddenly moans, “Oh fuuuuuck” as I feel her body go limp and she has a really big squirt. I think I made her squirt one other time when were together, but it was small if I did and we were never able to replicate it. This time, there was no question. In that moment, I really questioned whether or not I picked the right pussy to sit on my face. I turned my attention completely to Molly and picked up the pace as best as possible. After a little bit more effort, she too got across the finish line and while she didn’t squirt, she gave my fingers the most lovely coating of sweet white grool.
We rested for a bit, grabbed some water, Sarah went to the bathroom to get the rest of my cum out of her as best she could. After a bit, with these two lovely ladies laying next to me, I started to get hard again. I think rolled Molly over and got her bending over. Sarah came up next to me and stroked me a bit to make sure I was completely hard and then she helped guide my cock into Molly’s pussy. Honestly… Sarah was a champ and I didn’t see this coming from her at all. After I am pumping inside Molly, Sarah is doing a variety of things like spreading Molly’s ass cheeks, telling me to really fuck her, grabbing my balls some, pinching Molly’s nipples, etc. Literally a little bit of everything. I run my hand between her legs and try to rub her clit some. She is dripping wet. I make sure to do this for a little bit, then I take that hand and rub Molly’s asshole with Sarah’s juices. I put some pressure on her ass but don’t push in, just rubbing. Molly is moaning and breathing hard and is close to cumming. Sarah starts to say a whole bunch of dirty things to both her and me. Stuff like, “yeah, Molly, take his dick” and “fuck her cunt hard” (I don’t know that I have ever heard her say cunt before that). I pick up the pace and Molly cums hard. I was just about there, so I pull out and kind of turn to Sarah, but she spreads Molly’s ass cheeks and guides me back into her pussy. All of this gets me over the edge again and cum in Molly’s pussy.
Molly collapses onto the bed and panting. I am in a post nut daze. This is where Sarah does something I didn’t see coming. I mean this whole night I didn’t see coming, but this… Sarah nudges Molly to roll over and puts her head between her legs. She starts going down on Molly and using her fingers. I couldn’t quite see exactly what was going on because she was way up in there, but I hear slurping and licking and all sorts of juices. She is actually licking my cum out of Molly’s pussy. Fucking hot…
We go back to laying next to each other on the bed and end up falling asleep. There wasn’t too much happening the next morning and nothing else happened, so unfortunately this has a pretty boring ending, but the night was anything but to me.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/t64jgn/a_great_experience_with_two_exes_fmf
Were they happy with everything afterwards?
The perfect night!