It’s getting cold which made me remember a night my then girlfriend had her sister stay at our apartment because the sisters place lost electricity. My and let’s call her April had a one bedroom apartment and most of our stuff was set up in our bedroom. We had a couch and a queen bed. Besides the dresser and tv that was about it in our place.
Were I lived had a huge ice storm and left a lot of places without power. April’s sisters place lost there’s. So without me knowing it April had her stay with us. We all got under blankets and started watching movies. Me and April in the bed her sister on the couch. After awhile the sister fell asleep and April starts rubbing my dick through my pants. I’m thinking I might get a sneaky hand job. So off with the pants.
I guess I missed her taking of her underwear because she’s rubbing my half hard dick on her pussy. I figure I should be doing something also and start fingering her. One at first of course till I get to four. At that point she started moaning but not to load. I finally look at the sister and she is still asleep so all good.
I use April’s wetness to finger her ass. She likes fingers and the occasional small toy but not my dick in there. I’m waiting for her to cum. She hasn’t been stroking my hard on for a bit just holding it. Then I feel the shaking start. At that I speed up a bit on the butt play.
She is still shaking when her sister moves but doesn’t look awake. That’s when April asks me to put it in. She normally doesn’t let me finger her ass while I fuck her but I figure why not try. I still have 2 fingers in her while I slowly feed my dick into a very wet pussy. I think having her sister in the room made her more wet it was all over her leg even. She also didn’t say anything about my fingers.
With my fingers in her ass it made her pussy feel tighter. I don’t know if it really was but in my head it was. I’d get almost all of my dick in then pull it all the way out. She says she hates it when I do that and wants me to jam it in and fuck her but she cums faster if I tease her.
The problem with the slow teasing is I can’t do it for a long time I want to plunge in and out with some force. So after a bit that’s what I start doing. I also stop playing with her ass because the position doesn’t allow me to jackhammer her and finger her.
It doesn’t take long before April starts cumming. It was a good one her whole body shook from it. After that her sister moves around on the couch. April just whispers to keep fucking her. I tell her we have to wait to make sure her sister is asleep. I didn’t tell her but I also needed a break I was getting close.
Her sister, which was 20 at the time, had her back to us so she couldn’t see what we were doing but April wasn’t muffling her noises very well. After a minute or two I slid back into April. But she wants to switch were we are facing each other. She flips over and guides my dick back in. I’m hold onto her hips and feeling her pubic hair against my shaved crotch when I notice she has a finger in her ass.
She knows how hot I think that is and I start pushing my dick in hard. You can hear our crotches hit together. I forget about the sister and just have fun. I even took the blanket off so I could see her fingering herself. It didn’t register at the time but I swear the sister was watching.
I tell April I’m getting close and she just moves down and starts sucking my cock. I’m getting my cock sucked so I didn’t even look at the sister I was watching April. She didn’t like swallowing but this time I had to pull away after shooting my cum. She just kept sucking like it was a bottomless pit of cum.
Afterwards we went to sleep and I didn’t even think about checking on the sister. The next day I cleaned up the drinks and pizza boxes and noticed a wet spot on the couch. The sister insists she spilled her drink. She even said that after me and April broke up and I fucked the sister.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/siw00m/fucking_my_gf_while_her_sister_was_in_the_room
She knew