[MFF] My first threesome with my girlfriend and a girl I’d cheated with

*I received a barrage of messages after posting my previous story, asking for this one. Honestly, some of your responses turned me the fuck on, so I had to write this down now (and promptly rub one out after). If you’d like to read the original, click here:* [*fucking my roommate’s gf while my gf slept upstairs*](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ry1qo6/mf_hot_tub_fun_with_my_roommates_girlfriend/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)

As you can tell from the title, it wasn’t an ideal situation from a moral standpoint. Cheating is wrong, and I’m an asshole for it. If you haven’t read/don’t feel like reading the previous post, here’s the TL;DR. I fucked my roommate/close friend’s girlfriend after we hung out in the hot tub, while he and MY girlfriend were sleeping in their rooms upstairs. It was the only time we hooked up and I thought it’d never happen again. But man, did I fantasize about that ass on a regular basis.

Another long one, so buckle up! Skip down if you just want the good stuff, I won’t be offended ;)

***Important Characters***

Me – 21, 5’10, 160 pounds, slightly bigger dick than average. By that point, president of my fraternity and well-known man whore. I was a party animal and spent every waking hour drinking, smoking, or fucking. There were some girls that wanted to fuck me purely because I was the president of a frat and hosted 3 or 4 parties a week. My house became known across campus as a scene for debauchery and drugs. Man, those were the days.

My girlfriend Remi – 21, 5′, 90 pounds, athletic, C cup tits, cute round ass. I could lift this girl up with one arm as she squealed in delight, her gorgeous smile flashing in the sun. She had luscious brunette hair that she’d constantly dye different colors, making it feel like I got to fuck someone new every other week. She worked out constantly, especially because she knew how much I loved a tight ass and wanted to please me in every way. She also knew I was constantly surrounded by flirty, horny girls looking to lock down a boyfriend. She was an absolute angel (yet fucked like a demon) and I loved everything about her, physically or otherwise. I was only the second guy she’d ever fucked, and she was addicted to my cock. I’m talking mouth watering, eyes pleading, begging, almost crying to have my cock in some part of her, any time we were together. I’d play games with her where I’d withhold sex for a couple days, then jump her out of nowhere and fuck her until she broke. I knew how to push her buttons in all the right ways to make her melt. We started dating after I had finished seeing the 3 girls from one of my previous posts (another interesting read, if you have the time). Despite trying to remain single and play the field, I was addicted to her being addicted to my cock, if that makes sense. So when she gave me the ultimatum of “date me or I’m gone,” I caved. Best thing that’s ever happened to me, in hindsight.

My ex-friend’s ex-girlfriend Brooke – 22, 5’5, 100 pounds, total hippie, but super toned. I mean downright model status, without even trying. The only workouts she ever did were getting fucked and walking all over campus to party. Flat abs, long legs, beautiful eyes and hair that was just begging to be pulled. I gushed about her ass in my last post, but no amount of words will ever do it justice. She just had the tightest, cutest ass I’ve ever seen. You’d smack that shit and it would jiggle, but stay right in place like perfect little mounds of glory. She easily could have been an OF star, camgirl, or Insta model, but was more into painting and designing glassware. She and Adam (my ex-friend, we stopped hanging out when he and Brooke split up; Brooke and Remi were still super close and hung out, so he stopped talking to me) had broken up and she was taking full advantage of her newfound freedom. Keep in mind, she had only had one boyfriend in high school, and then went straight to Adam when she came to college. So I was only the third guy to ever fuck her, which was an absolute pleasure because I got to show her things that her previous lovers had failed at. She also had a tendency to get drunk and hook up with other girls; usually not sex, just making out and maybe some nipple/pussy/ass play. Fucking hot all around.

***The Halloween Party***

By this point, Brooke and Adam had been broken up for a few months, and she had spent the time pulling a different guy every night. The one thing she never did, she said, was have a threesome. She couldn’t find the right people to have it with – all guys wanted her, of course, but most girlfriends were too jealous (rightfully so, she was a 10/10 bombshell) and wouldn’t let it happen. Not Remi, though.

Remi always had a thing for other girls. That year at a Halloween party, she got absolutely wasted and ended up pulling me to a side room. Figuring we were about to shake the walls of my buddy’s house with the force of our fucking, I was shocked to see another girl standing there. Her name was Mary, and she was a blonde stunner with pornstar blowjob lips dressed in a skimpy nurse outfit. Legs for days. She looked incredibly nervous and also pretty drunk, an odd combination for sure. Remi looked me and asked, *”do you want to see me kiss her?”* Uhh…duh? I practically shoved her into Mary, who jumped a little in surprise. They began to make out with plenty of tongue, Remi grabbing her ass and squeezing it tightly. Mary’s hands began to explore Remi’s tits through her costume, eagerly grabbing and pulling on her nipples. This only lasted a few seconds though, before Mary pulled away embarrassed.

*”My…my boyfriend is in the next room and doesn’t know what I’m doing. We should stop. I’m drunk.”*

Fuck. Of course she had a boyfriend. I wasn’t sure that we were definitely going to have a threesome – Remi had expressed a desire to have a lesbian experience with me watching first, before having any scenario where I got involved. But my cock was already trying to bust a seam in my costume, and I was in the middle of pulling it out. Even if they didn’t want me involved, I’d have no problem jacking off to this beautiful sight. Guess it wasn’t happening tonight.

As she left the room, Remi sighed in exasperation.

*”Ugh that would have been hot. I know how much you love the thought of me and another girl.”*

*”That was still plenty hot, thanks for the attempt”* I laughed. *”Let’s hope next time you can make it happen and then maybe…y’know…the time after that?”*

She knew what I was hinting at; I hadn’t exactly been subtle in voicing my desire to have a threesome since we started dating. I figured she’d shut me down like she had before, especially considering this situation had fizzled out so quickly. Instead, what she said next is burned into my brain:

*”Well…I think I’m ready honestly. But who should we pick?”*

I tried not to jump for joy. I had one answer and one answer only. Amy, Sasha, and Shana were all gone from my life at that point. But I knew that I couldn’t say it right away, because it would look suspicious. Remi had no idea that Brooke and I had fucked each other silly before, and despite noticing how clearly attractive Brooke was, she never suspected me of being into her. Maybe it was because we were all such close friends and she figured I’d never fuck my friend’s girlfriend or think of her in that way. Man, was she wrong.

*”I’m not sure, who would you be comfortable with?”* I said.

*”Hmm…there are a few people I can think of that would be down, it’s just a question of whether you’d find them attractive too.”*

*”Baby, if you find them attractive, I guarantee they are. Look at you, you’re a fucking goddess.*” Her tits were still slightly exposed from Mary’s eager hands and they had never looked better. I couldn’t wait to shower them with cum when we got home, especially with this talk happening.

She blushed, saying, *”thanks haha…well in that case I think it would come down to Stacy, Yasmina, Laura, or…Brooke?”*

She had brought it up. All on her own. I struggled not to react when she said Brooke’s name, as I could see her eyes searching my face as she listed each name to gauge if I had a more-than-necessary reaction to them. She was a little jealous at times, and rightfully so. I was a slut before we started dating and it was hard to find a party where there wasn’t some girl I had fucked before. She constantly compared herself to these girls, which actually became a kinky bedroom game for us. More of that at a later time, though.

Stacy was a cute, quiet brunette with gorgeous tits. She was a solid 8/10 and would probably make Remi feel less self-conscious. She also had a history of daddy issues and well…I knew that would be fun. Remi had daddy issues too and that has always been my #1 kink. The only thing that made me hesitate about her was that she often went crazy out of nowhere due to being fed a daily cocktail of antidepressants/other drugs, and I didn’t think Remi and I wanted more drama in our relationship.

Yasmina was a tan, short, ball of energy. She was constantly partying and finding new ways to dress slutty. Her parents even threatened to cut her off once because they saw the pictures she was posting on social media. That made her rebel even more, posting what were basically nudes every day. I think a lot of them got removed due to violating platform NSFW/porn rules. She could be a lot of fun too, and I knew she had a thing for me. Maybe too much of a thing, which could be troublesome. So, not her.

Laura was a redheaded fireball that didn’t take shit from anyone. She was commanding, almost menacing, towards men. I bet she would make a great dominatrix. She had great tits and a great ass, but was a little too intense for me. Her voice was also annoying as hell and I didn’t think I could listen to her, even if she was moaning my name.

And then…Brooke. The hippie goddess of tight asses and wall-shaking orgasms. Read the original post if you want more details about her. Needless to say, she was a total nympho and I’d had the pleasure of caressing her curves and making her cum multiple times during our hot tub adventure. She and Remi were my dream threesome, something you’d see in a porno. Think Kimmy Granger and Joseline Kelly, or something along those lines. She and Remi also clearly liked each other as more than friends; I had once found them cuddling in Remi’s bed in their underwear. They had apparently gone to a campus event together, come back, and decided to take a nap. But it was so hot in Remi’s place that they had stripped to get more comfortable, now Brooke had to go home to Adam (they were still dating at the time). My mind couldn’t help going wild and they definitely noticed a bulge start to form in my pants. I quickly excused myself and waited for Brooke to leave. After she did, Remi apologized for not texting me back and that nothing had happened between her and Brooke in terms of sex. Whatever, who was I to complain if my girlfriend wanted to sleep half-naked with this gorgeous slut? Anyways, back to the Halloween party, where Remi and I were debating who to involve in our first threesome.

*”Well, I’d be fine with any of them, but Stacy is kinda crazy and Laura honestly scares me a bit. Yasmina is cool, but I know you’ve had problems with her in the past about me”* I said.

*”Yeah…you’re right. I thought Stacy might be the best choice, but I don’t want her to call me at 2am crying the next day. Laura can be a bitch about guys and Yasmina would probably try to steal you after”* she laughed. *”So…what about Brooke then?”*

*”Brooke could work, I know you two have had eyes for each other before.”* I had seen them getting closer than friends probably should at various parties, and they loved to take naps together. That is, when I wasn’t covering Remi in my load and preventing her from sleeping.

*”You’re damn right I have, I’m glad you noticed. Well then…do you find her hot?”* Fuck. This is one of those questions that basically doesn’t have a right answer. If I say yes, then she might get jealous. If I say no, she’ll know I’m lying because, well, it’s Brooke. She saw Brooke’s phone blowing up all day with texts from guys and knew what she was all about. I had to choose my words carefully.

*”**She’s cute, think we’d all have good chemistry?”* I thought that was a clever way of saying yes without making it seem like I was too eager. Remi bought it.

*”Yeah I think so, remember we had that drunk night at homecoming where we all stayed up cuddling on a blanket together? I honestly thought about making it happen then, but we weren’t dating yet and I thought it might be too much. Plus you were a little intimidating to be with at first, with all of those girls constantly bothering you.”* How the hell had I forgotten that night? I mean I know how, I was probably blackout on Crown Royal. But it all came flooding back; the cool breeze rushing through the air, the smell of both of their perfumes wafting over me. The way the stars seemed brighter and the beer tasted better than usual. The dirty thoughts I had about what could happen between the 3 of us, and the lack of courage I had to make it happen. I didn’t want to ruin our friendship, and what was a sweet friendly moment could have easily turned into the basis of many fights and broken relationships. So instead, we all fell asleep as the sounds of the night enveloped us. The only sound I wanted to hear, though, was Brooke and Remi screaming my name.

*”Oh shit right, I forgot about that honestly. Too much whiskey that night, but damn was that fun. I was thinking about trying to make it happen too, but I didn’t want to pressure you or make things weird.”*

*”I appreciate that babe, but now it’s time to let me know how you feel. I want to hear that you want it, otherwise it won’t feel right.”*

I was trapped again. I had to toe the line between expressing believable enthusiasm and not sounding like I had been thirsting after Brooke since I got my first boner.

*”Well…she’s pretty fine and so are you. The thought of the two of you taking turns getting fucked by me, and then getting to drench both of your pretty faces in cum after? Dream come true, no other way to say it.*” Subtlety was not my specialty, and it never will be.

*”Fuck…that’s hot. You sure you won’t want her more than me afterwards?”* She looked apprehensive as she said this, I knew it would come up.

*”Of course not baby”* I reassured her, *”she’s a cool chick, but you’re my everything. The only future I see for myself is one with you by my side.”* I knew how to lay on the romance and get her going, before we turned into primal animals desperately clawing at each other.

*”Okay, it’s a date then. I’ll talk to Brooke and set it up, I know she’ll be into it. Pretty sure I’ve seen her check you out, especially on that day that Adam pulled down your pants as a joke and your dick came out. She didn’t hide her admiration, that’s for sure.”* Damn, she noticed that? Duh. Guys, females always notice things that we think they don’t. We’re idiots, and I’m not sure why they tolerate us.

I simply said okay, and we walked back into the main room of the house where the party was still raging. I saw Mary and her boyfriend chatting in the corner, she gave us an embarrassed glance and quickly turned away. Unfortunately, nothing ever happened with Mary, and I think she and her boyfriend are now engaged but practice an open relationship. Lucky fucker.

The party finally died down and I took Remi back to her place. My house was filled with my drunk frat brothers and I didn’t want to have to deal with all of them listening to me fuck Remi’s brains out, then hoot and holler when we finished, as was tradition. Remi didn’t mind it (I think she secretly loved the thought of a bunch of guys imagining her, sprawled out on my bed, getting fucked into submission), but I wanted some peace and quiet. We got to her apartment door, and before I knew it, my pants were on the ground and my cock was buried deep in her throat. As she began to gag and pull away, I held her there. Her hair was blue this week, my favorite color. I still couldn’t believe it; she was hungrier for my cock than ever, and it was after we had just discussed another girl and our potential threesome. She made moans of pleasure as she sucked, so I lifted her shirt and began to fondle her tits. This was pure bliss and I savored every moment of it until I felt my cum begin to rise. I whispered that I was close and she took the opportunity to massage my balls and up her pace. I couldn’t take anymore and finally unloaded in her mouth, feeling my shaft twitch and contract as I flooded her throat. She couldn’t swallow it all and pulled off, the final two pulses of cum splattering on her tits. I had fulfilled my earlier desire of soaking her tits in cum and also managed to give her a nice nighttime meal.

I started rubbing her tits, but she stood up and pulled my pants back up for me, giving me a sloppy kiss. She said she was tired and wanted to crash, despite me wanting to go for round two and return the favor. We laid down in her bed, watching some TV as she passed out slowly. I lit a joint from her nearby stash, watching the moonlight seep through the trees outside her window. I couldn’t stop thinking about Brooke, and the fact that Remi was intentionally leaving me in the dark regarding the details was driving me wild. I eventually got up and rubbed one out, imagining it was Brooke and Remi’s hands stroking me to completion. I crawled back into bed, listening to Remi’s soft, steady breathing and wondering how I got so lucky.

**The Threesome**

I waited anxiously over the next few weeks, wondering when it would happen. Remi and I continued to fuck like rabbits every chance we got, and she brought Brooke up mid-sex multiple times, unprovoked. Whenever she said Brooke’s name, I could feel my cock somehow harden even more, and I think Remi noticed too. Our orgasms were more intense than usual. She knew how excited I was, and took great pleasure at being the one in control for once. She’d tease me to completion before backing off, saying that I should “save myself for Brooke.” She reveled in the discovery that she had finally found a way to make ME beg.

Those weeks were agonizing, and I knew that Thanksgiving break was approaching soon, with finals afterwards. Surely we’d be too busy/distracted after Thanksgiving, so it had to happen soon if I wanted to start the new year as a man who’d had a threesome. We saw Brooke plenty of times, and I wasn’t sure if Remi had brought it up to her. I thought I noticed them giggling together while looking at me at a party, but I tried not to read too much into anything.

Finally, a few days before break started, I got the text. *”Come over”* it read. Nothing else. I had almost lost hope at that point so I figured she was just in a short mood or whatever, but when I knocked and the door opened, I immediately started getting hard. There was Remi in her white panties, with no bra and a few bite marks on her neck. Her tits looked so fuckable and I could feel my cock begging to be released from my pants. I stepped forward and inside was Brooke. She was wearing tight black yoga pants and only had a bra on, with similar red marks all over her neck and near her cleavage. I gave them both a look of lust and appreciation, which they returned.

*”Holy shit…you both look fucking stunning.”*

These two had obviously been having some fun without me, not that I minded at all. The thought of the two of them pawing at each other and moaning in ecstasy, fantasizing about me coming over to fill them both with cum, made my mind turn to mush. They must have laughed together, sending that text and giggling when I showed up so quickly, already at half-mast.

*”Let’s get you more comfortable…”* murmured Remi, kissing my neck gently. She slid my pants down; thank God I had worn sweatpants and not jeans, I couldn’t take another second of being confined like that. My dick popped out as she pulled and Brooke gasped in excitement. I knew she remembered what it looked like and from the look on her face, she was eager to experience it again.

*”Like what you see?”* asked Remi.

*”Damn Rem, you’ve been keeping that all to yourself?”* giggled Brooke. I groaned with impatience, my cock quivering slightly as I felt myself stiffen completely. *”Oh damn it got even bigger!”*

She obviously knew how big it was to begin with, but had to feign ignorance to keep Remi from noticing. Not that Remi needed much distracting, as she was busy stripping her clothes off in excitement. She fumbled with the clasp of her bra, and I could see that her hands were shaking. Hearing her best friend talk about me like that was obviously driving her insane. After what seemed like an eternity, she was finally fully naked. I pulled her close and shoved my tongue into her mouth, sucking her lips and cupping her tight little cheeks from behind.

*”Oh fuck daddy…make us yours. I want to give you everything tonight.”* Great, I was already having trouble stopping myself from cumming, and then she says this. We were in for the ride of a lifetime, I could tell that much.

As I gave her ass a squeeze, she moaned gently and began to massage my cock with her hand. I moved one hand down to feel her warm, moist pussy that felt like electricity was running through it, she was shaking so much. I needed to make sure that I paid plenty of attention to Remi before doing anything with Brooke, otherwise she might get jealous. I inserted two of my fingers into her slit, coaxing her to cum while I sucked on her tits.

*”Fuck baby…you’re so wet and tight. Cum for me now, you filthy little slut. Cum for me now if you ever want to be fucked again, otherwise I’ll find someone else who will.”* Maybe a little too far? But Remi didn’t care, in fact she started breathing more heavily and before I could react, she let out an ear-piercing scream and started convulsing. She came all over my hand, juices flowing down my arm and dripping onto her rug. Damn, guess she liked it.

Brooke didn’t enjoy being ignored, however, and proceeded to do the same as Remi. Out of the corner of my eye, I watched her rip her clothes off with a hungry look in her eye, eager to experience my cock after the last time had left her dripping and ravished. Remi shoved me towards the bedroom, saying,

*”Get on the bed baby, let us take care of you…”*

As much as I wanted both of their pretty little mouths pleasuring my shaft NOW, I needed to see them have some fun first. The potential threesome with Mary was cut far too short, and they had all their fun before I got there. For me, part of the pleasure is in watching them get each other off too, and explore each other’s bodies.

*”Wait…can you two play with each other a little first? I feel like I got gypped since you guys had fun without me.”* I was basically begging, and they could see it. They both grinned, clearly enjoying having me under their spell. I would have done anything they asked at that point, but thankfully they put me out of my misery and started making out. Seeing Remi’s delicate hands groping Brooke’s incredible ass proved to almost be too much, and I had to look away for a second to avoid cumming.

*”I think the two of you need to finger each other. Remi, tell Brooke how much you always wished you could fuck her. You know you’ve fantasized about her, because you’re a little whore and can’t get enough.”* These girls loved being commanded, degraded, and dominated. I was all too happy to oblige.

*”Ughhh fuckkk…Brooke you’re incredible, I need to taste your pussy.”* God damn, Remi was just GOING for it. I stroked myself as I watched Remi eat Brooke out, as Brooke began to moan and massage her tits with wet fingers. As Brooke climaxed, she looked me up and down and grinned, clearly happy to see me naked again. Not to mention, she had my bombshell of a girlfriend’s tongue deep inside her. I returned the smile, trying to keep my eye on Remi so she wouldn’t notice us staring at each other.

*”Your turn, Brooke. Get down there and make my girl your slave. I want her to beg for your tongue, don’t let her cum until she’s proven she can show proper respect to you.”*

*”Yes daddy…”* Brooke whimpered. Oh shit, was Remi going to be okay with Brooke calling me daddy? I looked at Remi, whose eyes were closed and face was already straining as she rubbed her pussy. Nope, she loved it. Have I mentioned how amazing this girl is?

Brooke started slowly, teasing Remi with her tongue. She flicked her clit a few times, grinning when Remi’s body jerked in response. Brooke’s tongue game was second to none, whether it be on men or women. Brooke brought Remi close to climax, her muffled moans drowned out by Remi’s screaming. As Remi was about to cum, I commanded Brooke to stop.

*”She doesn’t get to cum yet. She hasn’t earned it.”* The look in Remi’s eyes was a mixture of hatred and pure desire, I finally had control again and she couldn’t do a thing.

*”Please daddy, I’ll be a good girl”* she pleaded. Nope, not enough. I just stared at her, stroking my cock, waiting for her to say the right thing. Brooke loved watching us, eyes flitting between my pulsing rod and Remi’s delicious pussy.

*”Please I’ll do anything daddy, anything. You can fuck Brooke first if you want, you can only fuck her and not me, just please let me cum…”* Yeah, that’d do it. I told Brooke she could proceed, and Remi proceeded to have one of the loudest and most violent orgasms I’ve ever witnessed. Her fingers and toes curled, back arching into an impossible angle. Her soft tits heaving, she let out an enormous sigh of satisfaction, settling back down onto the bed.

Now, I know Remi had only said those things so she could be released from her torture. I wasn’t going to risk fucking Brooke first, despite aching to be inside of her again after months without it. It was time for them to give me head like good little girls.

*”Both of you, come here and do your jobs. My cock has been lonely while you two sluts played with each other. Makes sense that you whores would be together, now put those useless mouths to work.”* I loved watching them both look up at me, eyes begging to taste my tip. Brooke looked especially happy, winking at me. Fuck. The last thing I needed was for Brooke to blow our cover and stop this from progressing. She knew it was driving me wild, and I think it was making her crazy too. It took everything we had not to just jump each other and start humping like we had on the table at the lake house.

They both got on their knees and began to kiss. I slid my cock in between their lips as they sandwiched me, and let me tell you that is a feeling unlike any other. I let them take turns kissing and rubbing my cock, struggling to keep myself from cumming. I pulled Remi off for a second and then began to face fuck her.

*”Mmm…Brooke, lick my balls and play with Remi’s tits…Rem, go slower and rub Brooke’s pussy…”*

I continued like this and they obeyed my every command, eager to please me. Remi began to gag, tears welling in her eyes and rolling down her cheeks. Brooke took a break from massaging my balls to lick the tears off Remi’s face, licking her lips after she was finished. She clearly wanted a turn.

*”Think it’s Brooke’s turn to have a taste, don’t you think Rem?”* Remi simply nodded in reply, still gasping for air after I had choked her with my cock.

I pulled Brooke’s head towards my crotch, and she immediately shoved her mouth around my head. She sucked and licked it like I knew she could, I’m not sure how Remi didn’t notice that Brooke was obviously familiar with my cock and what I liked, but she was busy fingering herself and staring into my eyes.

I tried to maintain eye contact, but I had to see what Brooke looked like. There she was, fingering herself while her perky tits bounced up and down. Her amazing ass sticking out behind her, jiggling with anticipation.

*”Fuck that feels so good…Rem get over here and play with Brooke while she does her job.”* Remi slid over and started eating Brooke out from behind, which made Brooke lose control completely. She almost bit down on my dick as she let out a groan and began to cum. This set Remi off, who started fingering herself aggressively and came herself just a few seconds later. I pulled out of Brooke’s mouth, I couldn’t last any longer. I had to fuck them both. I had to feel Brooke’s ass push against me again, while Remi watched.

*”Both of you, on the bed. Face down, ass up, wait like good little sluts and you might earn having your filthy little holes fucked.”* They both yelped as I spanked their asses, appreciating how they both bounced and shook. I shoved them down onto the bed and they prepared themselves, spreading their cheeks wide.

*”Rem…you first. You’re gonna cum for me in under 10 seconds, otherwise Brooke gets to cum first.”* She whimpered a feeble affirmation, and I slid myself inside her. No matter how many times I fucked Remi, her pussy was always so tight and inviting. This girl could milk me dry in 5 minutes or less and knew every way to set me off. But it was my turn to make her cum, and as her orgasm built, I pulled out. She turned around with that same look of anger and lust. I simply shushed her and put myself back in. I repeated this process over and over, pumping her full of cock until she was about to burst, then pulling out. She wailed and begged and pleaded to let her finish, she was basically stuttering and slurring her words.

*”P-p-please d-d-daddy…I n-n-need to c-c-cummmm….”*

*”Fine, I guess you earned it. But I bet Brooke will cum faster for me.”* I rammed my cock back into her and pushed as deep as I could go.

This was the final straw and she let out another scream, back arching and contorting as she struggled to keep me inside her. I had been fingering Brooke, making sure she wasn’t forgotten amongst Remi’s throes of passion. I pulled out of Remi who was left shaking on the bed, completely broken. I could have told her I wanted to fuck her sister and she probably would have said yes. She was mine.

*”Brooke, your turn. Let’s see if you can cum faster than your friend, if you do you’ll get a nice reward.”* Remi cried in protest, but I slapped her across the face.

*”You didn’t listen, now you have to watch me fuck your friend. I’m not touching you until she cums twice.”* I was being a fucking asshole, and she loved every part of it. Brooke was basically jumping up and down to get fucked, so I moved over to her.

As I inserted myself, Brooke looked back at me. I glanced at Remi, whose eyes were closed as she caught her breath. I gave Brooke a long, passionate kiss, something Remi had said she was a little uncomfortable about. I had to taste my girlfriend’s pussy on her tongue, just once.

Without another word, I plunged my throbbing cock into Brooke’s pussy. She cried out in ecstasy, clearly she had been waiting months for this and was as desperate as I was to fuck again. I pulled her by the hair so her face was near mine, leaned in, and whispered,

*”Didn’t think I’d forget how you liked it, did you? Last time was nothing compared to now, I’m going to turn you two into my own personal fuckmeat.”* She fucking lost it. Remi opened her eyes as Brooke began to scream with pleasure, and got to watch me pound her best friend into pulp. I fucked her so hard I thought I might break her, spanking her ass cheeks red as Remi looked on helplessly. Remi wanted to be fucked again, but she knew she had to be patient. Good girl.

*”Fuck daddy, you’re bigger than I imagined.”* Well, that was a lie, considering I’d have my cock buried inside of her for almost an hour the last time.

*”Damn baby…you feel so fucking good. Rem, get over here and learn how to cum in under 10 seconds when your daddy commands it.”* Remi let out a moan and moved closer.

*”You have 9 seconds, Brooke. 9 seconds to cum, or I’m kicking you out and finishing this with Rem.”* I loved playing them against each other like that, each one of them desperate not to be excluded and be left unsatisfied. Brooke simply nodded in response, too busy trying to keep from cumming before I even started pumping her.

I slapped her ass one more time, grabbed her by the neck, and fucked the life out of her. I counted down,

*”9…8…7…6…5…4-“* as we reached 4, she buried her face in the sheets and screamed, her entire being shaking to the core. I felt the force of her orgasm run down her spine, through her legs, and back up again. I traced my fingers down her back and cupped her ass, which caused her to let loose another wave of orgasmic pleasure.

*”Good girl. See how it’s done, Rem? She came twice, just like I told her. Think you can do that for me now?”*

*”Y-yes daddy…I promise I’ll get it right this time.”*

I was fucking losing it internally. This was a porno, on steroids, with an eighth of molly and 25 Sasha Greys throating my cock. Things you see on porn sites, but think will never happen in real life. These two beauties were my sex puppets, dancing along to the tune of my cock. I was in fratboy heaven, two of the hottest girls I knew were letting me use their holes as my personal cum receptacles.

I moved back over to Remi, pulled her towards Brooke, and commanded her to eat Brooke’s pussy while we fucked. Remi obeyed and snaked her tongue inside Brooke’s puffy slit.

*”If Brooke cums before you do, it’s over between us. Brooke and I will keep fucking, and you’ll have to sleep in the living room.”* I knew this would set them both off, and before they could respond, I slipped inside of Remi. It couldn’t have been more than a few seconds before I felt Remi’s pussy tighten and start to convulse. She didn’t make a sound this time, burying her head into Brooke’s pussy with increased ardor. Brooke, on the other hand, moaned like the fucking slut she is in a way that only she could, and released a flood of juices all over Remi’s face.

I knew I wouldn’t last much longer either.

*”Both of you, get on your knees. Daddy is going to cover your faces in cum after you suck me off, then you’re going to lick it off of each other.”* They slowly made their way to the floor, faces flushed with pleasure, looking almost incoherent. I knew they were both used and done for the moment, despite knowing I could go for round 2.

I pulled both of their heads towards my crotch and alternated between throating each of them. They each felt different, but equally amazing. Brooke’s throat hugged my cock as she slithered her tongue down to my balls. Remi gagged each time, but stayed put. Good thing she did, otherwise I probably would have told her she had misbehaved and I was going to let Brooke enjoy all of my cum.

Finally, I had enough. I pulled out of Brooke’s mouth and began stroking my shaft quickly, intensifying the pace as I felt my balls tighten.

*”Fuuuuuuuuuuck”* I yelled as I unleashed a torrent of cum across their faces. It must have been 9 or 10 separate thick strings of cum, covering them to the point where you couldn’t even see their eyes or mouths. I glanced to my left and saw the bathroom, where Remi’s electric toothbrushes were sitting.

*”Now lick it off.”* They eagerly lapped up the cum as it dripped off of their faces onto their tits, thighs, and hands. They kept going until they were almost clean, at which point I said,

*”If I find even a single drop left, you’re both sleeping with vibrating toothbrushes shoved up your pussy. On. All night long.”*

Both of them looked up at me with a little bit of fear in their eyes. I knew they couldn’t take any more and would probably pass out from the pleasure. I went to the bathroom, grabbed the toothbrushes, and came back with them turned on. The sight of them vibrating made them both whimper a bit.

*”Y-yes sir…we’ll clean each other up we promise.”*

*”Good girls. I’m not sleeping with you cum-soaked whores unless you’ve been properly washed.”*

They continued licking each other all over, finding every drop of cum that had been left behind. Then they both collapsed on the floor, barely moving. I laid down next to them, the three of us processing what had just happened. That was by far the most animalistic, degrading sex that either of them had been a part of, and I think they were both a little shocked at how much they had enjoyed it (and each other).

To avoid any awkwardness, we all immediately got dressed and sparked a joint. We passed it back and forth, not saying a word. I kept glancing at Remi, making sure she was okay with how it went down. I think it was a little rougher and more exciting than either of us had thought, especially with how I had basically threatened to fuck another girl instead of her. Brooke was incredible, but she wasn’t worth losing Remi over. She finally looked up and sighed, a smile stretching across her beautiful face. Brooke laughed, and that broke the tension.

We spent the rest of the night talking, joking, and replaying what had happened. Brooke and I stole a couple glances at each other, and I knew we were both thinking about how lucky we were to have made it happen again. I excused myself at some point to go to the bathroom, during which I closed my eyes and jerked off to the mental image of those two wonderful girls drenched in my load. It didn’t take long for me to bust, and I cleaned myself up afterwards. Damn, I wish we had that round 2, but I felt like asking for it now would be pushing it. After a while, we all passed out in bed together. I woke up the next morning to both of them gone; Brooke had left early in the morning, while Remi was up making coffee.

I came up and hugged Remi from behind, kissing her neck.

*”Thank you so much for last night baby, it was everything I wanted and more. You’re the perfect girlfriend. Seriously.”*

*”You’re welcome baby, you looked so fucking hot when you were grabbing her hair from behind. I had a perfect night too.”* I kissed her passionately, thanking her profusely.

*”So…is this a regular thing or should I consider this a once-in-a-lifetime special present?”* I knew what the answer was, but I had to ask.

*”Probably a one-time thing. But who knows, we’re still young.”* Fuck yeah. Remi wasn’t usually the sharing type, or so I thought. I’ll share that story at a later date if requested ;)

We spent the rest of the day together, enjoying our time before she went back to her family for Thanksgiving and I went to mine in a few days. We saw Brooke one more time at a friend’s house, and we all shared a collective grin, our friends oblivious to the electricity in the air.

The year ended and Brooke moved out of the country. She and Remi chat occasionally, but we haven’t seen each other in a long time. I didn’t want to spoil it earlier, but Remi and I are now happily married. How could I not marry the girl that gave me my greatest desire, and then some? Do I look back on my flings with Brooke with a mixture of pleasure and regret? Sure. What I did was definitely fucked up. I wish I could say this whole story was fake, but it will always be part of me. I hooked up with a coworker once years ago, drunk at a company event (happy to share that story as well), but otherwise I have been completely faithful to Remi. Thanks for sticking around, hope you’re sticky now ;) if you made it through the whole thing, consider me very impressed!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ryoojp/mff_my_first_threesome_with_my_girlfriend_and_a

5 comments

  1. Kudos for getting this out in an extremely timely manner. Great writing even better story. Heck of a lucky guy

Comments are closed.