This happened to me when I was in college. Nothing like it has happened since. This is the first time I’ve ever willingly told the whole story.
I was coming home from a normal day of working as a lifeguard at my university’s pool. It had been a particularly shitty shift, so when I got home, I loaded up a bowl, and promptly began to chat with my roommate about whatever stupid shit happened to be on our minds.
Once I was good and high, my friend (let’s call her Lucy), texts me “hey can you take a picture of your work uniform for the parks service, my friend [Sarah] is going to work for them and wants to know what she needs to get.”
I walk back to my closet, open the door, and boom, Lucy and Sarah jump out and tell boo. Being hella stoned I scream a high pitched scream and fall over into my bed. Lucy and Sarah bust up laughing and Lucy comes over and starts to tickle me. Once I calm down I notice two things: they had taken by bottle of vodka into the closet and had clearly been drinking, and Sarah, who I had never met before, was HOT.
A brief description of us.
Me: 6’1″, broad shouldered, brunette, lithe and muscular, 7.5″ when hard, solid 8/10
Lucy: 5’6″ probably 130lbs, Dirty blonde, well tatted, size C boobs, solid 7/10
Sarah: 5’8″, 120ish, platinum blonde, perfectly proportioned hourglass, B cups, solid 9/10
They’re clearly a bit buzzed by this point and they coerce me into drinking a few shots. We’re all pretty drunk so we go about riding our bikes around, day drinking and being general nuisances until we get rained out and all returned to my room, even drunker than before. Sarah goes off to the bathroom. Lucy gives me a thirsty look, I flash back my most devilish grin (something I’m known for) and in no time we jump across my bed and start making out. I grab her ass, breasts, and caress between the two, stopping every so often to focus on one or the other.
We’re getting very worked up when all the sudden the door knob turns, so we jump under my covers and lie down.
Sarah stumbles in and says, “oh did I interrupt something here”
“N-no”, I stammer out.
“Very well [hiccup]”, she says as she climbs in under the covers with us.
At this point, I’m spooning Lucy, which Sarah is spooning me. Being the naughty bastard I’m, I begin teasing Lucy with a vengeance, caressing her, playing with her ass, I slowly moved my had up to her breasts as I feel her writhing against me as I play with her nipple. As I pinch her, it becomes to much and she lets out a gasping moan.
There was no mistaking this, Sarah purred, “I knew there was something going on”, as she slid her hand over my hip to grab my cock from over my pants. She slowly caressed me as I reached my fingers into Lucie’s pants, who is by now moaning and putty in my fingers. Sarah leans over me and bites the side of my neck and I go from a half chub to hard as rock in a second. This envigorates the fuck out of me so I rip my hand out of Lucy’s pants, grab Sarah and push her under me, grabbing her neck and ripping her top open. She lets out the sluttiest moan I’ve ever heard as I choke her, sucking and biting her nipples with a passion.
I can tell Lucy is getting jealous because she rips my pants off from behind and begins playing with my cock. I flip over, lucy starts sucking my dick, taking me all the way down and Sarah takes off everything but her panties. Lucy is inhaling my cock and playing with her clit while I reach over to play with Sarah sopping pussy over her panties. I have one hand on Lucy’s head, one hand in Sarah’s panties, and I’m making out with Sarah ferociously, stopping to bit her lip and neck as I desire.
She moans, we take a break from kissing to look each other in the eyes and she whispers’ “I want you to fuck me”, “I want you to fuck me hard”,”lucy, let me fuck him”
With that she sits up, straddles me and slowly begins riding me. Lucy’s playing with her pussy while Sarah transitions between that slow phase or cowgirl to a more intense, fast pace, passionate grinding. I grab Lucy and position her over my face, eating her out while Sarah rides me and plays with lucie’s nipples.
Quicker than I expected, Sarah begins to speed up, her moans getting louder till she has a shuddering orgasm all over my cock.
Lucy’s turn.
I flip her on my back, shove my cock into her already soaking pussy and begin thrusting into her with abandon. She orgasms.
We switch positions again. After a few different configurations, I’m fucking Sarah on her back with her legs spread with as she holds her big toes.
I’m pumping into her, kissing her, pulling back to look into her green eyes when I feel a familiar sensation beginning to build in my loins. I can tell she senses it too, as I’m moaning louder.
Normally I pull out, but as the orgasm approaches me, Sarah wraps he legs around me, pulling me into her and moans, “yeeeeesss, baby, cum for me. I want you to cum in this tight pussy, I want to feel it.”
This pushes me over the edge as I begin pumping ropes deep into her, filling her up as my thrusts subside. I pulled out, a thin line of cum dripping out of her, and the three of us made out for a little longer before eventually drifting off to sleep.
6 am the next morning I wake with a pounding hangover in my head as someone’s alarm goes off.
Sarah sits up, “fuck, I gotta get back to my boyfriend’s house.”
The shame and grief begins kicking in. I waited a few days before confronting Lucy about it.
In essence, Sarah had been in a long-term relationship with her bf, knew that he was the boy she wanted to marry, but confided with Lucy that she wished she had had more time to have casual sex and one night stands while in college. Lucy told her that she knew a guy that would fuck her and not tell anyone. Sarah was too shy to make a move on me, so Lucy made the split second desicion to seduce me and bring her in when I was hot and bothered.
This angered me because none of this was discussed by us beforehand. It turns out that I knew Sarah’s boyfriend…fairly well, he was in a few of my classes. A wave of shame and anger fell over me for a few weeks as I felt like I had been used like a dirty slut by both of them, Sarah most of all because not only had she planned it, but she had inadvertantly found a way to seduce me (something she had been trying to do for a while, to no avail) by getting me drunk and honeypotting me with a hotter friend. The worst part is the knowledge that even if I had know about Sarah’s boyfriend; I probably would have still done it none-the-less.
What’s worse is that my roommate who’s room bordered mine heard the moans and put two and two together. It was hooking up with Sarah was a taboo in the house (which is why I had sidestepped her previous advances), she had emotionally led on two of my roommates in the past, and when they found out they were cold to me for a while, but we eventually worked it out. Luckily the news never left the house. I had developed the reputation of being a bit of a fuckboy at the time and if this had gotten out I would have probably seemed like a full-blown fuckman to anyone who heard about it. I still wonder though, about a year later, every interaction I had with Sarah’s boyfriend was very terse and cold. As far as I know they’re engaged now.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/o5yu0a/my_second_threesome_a_mixture_of_pride_and_of
Wow, very intense and real. Thanks for including the aftermath too