Chapter 9 – [M]y New [F]ucktoy – Thursday Night

I was asked by a few fellow redditors that I add chapters and a similar title to my stories. I could not figure out how to edit previous titles, but I added Chapters in the main sections. Here is the list and links to this series of experiences:

[Chapter 1 – My New Fucktoy](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nbsom8/my_new_fucktoy_long/)

[Chapter 2 – My New Fucktoy – Day 2](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nc7bpn/my_new_fucktoy_day_2_long/)

[Chapter 3 – My Not so New Fucktoy – Family Dinner](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ne0idr/my_not_so_new_fucktoy_family_dinner/)

[Chapter 4 – My New Fucktoy – The SIL Saga Continues](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nfmdgs/my_new_fucktoy_the_sil_saga_continues/)

[Chapter 5 – My Fucktoy – Opportunity Hits](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ngzr95/my_fucktoy_opportunity_hits/)

[Chapter 6 – My Little Fucktoy – Preparations](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nk6j8u/my_little_fucktoy_preparations/)

[Chapter 7 – My Little Fucktoy – Sharing is Caring](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nnz44l/my_little_fucktoy_sharing_is_caring_mmff/)

[Chapter 8 – My Little Fucktoy – Unannounced Visit](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/nq49t2/my_little_fucktoy_unannounced_visit/)

Chapter 9

Ellie, being back in town, was excited to join me for family dinner. Good to see someone was excited, as I totally was not. I knew Ellie would behave, but I was not so sure about Cindy. When we arrived, Cindy was her usual self: Cold, but sticky sweet. In other words, fake as shit. My mom immediately took over the conversation, gushing over seeing Ellie again after such a long time. I kept stealing glances at Cindy, who for the most part, was completely ignoring me.

About thirty minutes in, Cindy got up to get the table set for dinner. Ellie offered to help, but I told her to continue catching up and that I would bite the bullet and assist. She gave me a mischievous grin, knowing I was likely going to find a way to get Cindy all hot and bothered. Once we were alone inside the house, I walked up close to Cindy, pulling her ponytail as I did. She let out a quick breath as her cheeks flushed a bright pink. “Jake, we can’t. What if someone walks in?” she questioned. I lightly traced her neckline, slowly moving my hand to her covered breast. Squeezing gently, I laughed and replied, “that didn’t stop you from dripping all over my hand a few weeks ago.”

I kept my hand cupped to her breast, gently massaging through her sundress. Sighing in pleasure, she fought it, continuing “it’s different now. I cannot. Not with her here. Letting go of her ponytail, I slid my hand down her back, watching out the window as I slipped under her dress, grabbing her ass. She was back to wearing panties, although these seemed to be sexier than the usual. “Who Ellie? Afraid she may see us and get turned on?” My hand continued its journey, finding her hot lips through the silky fabric of her panties.

“No Jake, I actually like Ellie and do not want to upset her.” I laughed at the absurdity: “You weren’t concerned about her or your husband the multiple times you were fucking me. Or did you forget about that or the strangers who fucked you? I watched you smother your face in another woman’s pussy. Don’t go getting all high and mighty now.” As I talked, I managed to slide a finger under the fabric, sliding against the heat and wetness she was trying hard to ignore. My finger slid home, pushing into her tight hole. She gasped and let out a moan.

Continuing to watch out the window, I continued fingering her while commenting: “Pretend all you want Cindy, but you are and always will be my little fucktoy. You are a stupid slut with no control, so do not sit here and whine we cannot. After dinner, I am going cum in your tight little ass and you are going to love it, understood?” She pushed against my finger, moaning, and shaking her head affirmatively. After a few minutes, I pulled my hands away, before grabbing the plates, ready to head back outside. Turning back, I left Cindy with a thought: “I’m not planning on being gentle later. Time is limited, so I’m going to fuck your ass hard and quick. May want to loosen up beforehand.”

“Fuck You, Jake.”

I smiled “See, now we’re back to normal.” With that, I walked outside, leaving her to wet, waiting, and pouting. Just outside the door, I ran into Ellie. She was smirking and came close, grabbing the plates from me. “Took you long enough to get a few plates. Thought maybe you got lost in something.” I laughed while bringing my drying fingers to Ellie’s lips, quickly giving her a taste while making sure Cindy was not coming and my parents were not looking. Paul happened to be coming in as we did: “Gross guys, get a life.” I responded, “Pussy juices, what can I say?” Smirking, I turned back and walked into the house with him. Cindy was not in the kitchen, so Paul and I grabbed a few more items for dinner. “Don’t do that sick shit in front of mom and dad” he chided me, still annoyed I had my fingers in Ellie’s mouth.

“Yes Mr. Repression, I’ll be the perfect little fucking Catholic like you and Cindy.”

The rest of dinner was uneventful, with my brother going on and on about how great he was, how his girls walked on water, etc. My mom continued to bring up how nice it was for Ellis to be back and continually asked why we do not just get married over the summer, etc. Cindy, unusually quiet, remained flush for most of the dinner. At one point, Ellie got up, asking me to come “help her out with getting more wine,” despite the other bottle still half full. This should be interesting, I thought.

We went through the house and down to my brother’s basement. They had the wine in an unfinished section that usually stayed cool. Ellie was all over me, kissing me, hands all over. After less than a minute of heavy making out, she dropped into a squat, pulling at my belt as she worked my shorts to my knees. “Christ!” was all I could say as she eagerly took my hard cock into her mouth, sucking like there was no tomorrow. Reaching out, she grabbed my balls, squeezing as she used her puffy lips to suck me expertly. She continued close to five minutes before we heard footsteps above us. That brought Ellie back to reality. Standing, she helped me pull my shorts up, careful to stuff my cock back in my underwear as she did.

“Wow” was all I could say. She smiled, gave me a quick kiss, and whispered: “I’m so horny just thinking about you dominating Cindy, sorry.” With that, she grabbed a bottle of wine and walked away, leaving me to try to find a way to hide my rather hard cock. Settled in for dessert, I was still trying to figure out how I’d get Cindy alone without making it seem obvious. Seeing her phone in her hand, I came up with an idea. Grabbing my phone, I remarked “Damn, I have a work call. Paul, mind if I take it upstairs in your office? Probably be twenty minutes.” He half acknowledged me as Ellie, next to me, bit her lower lip, likely wondering what I was going to do to Cindy.

Settled in, I texted Cindy: “Up, now. Say you spilled something and need to change.”

No reply, so I sat there waiting, feet on my desk, thinking about how, less than thirty minutes earlier, Ellie was all over my dick, sucking it like a popsicle. The door opened and Cindy came in without a word. She closed the door quietly behind her, before walking over and bending over my lap, arms comfortably on the desk. A couple quick slaps against her ass before lifting her skirt to find she went and used the plug as I suggested earlier.

I pushed her out of the way so I could get up, causing her to give me an annoyed look. Grabbing her, I pushed her back on the deck and lifted her dress out of the way. A deep thrust into her sopping wet pussy resulted in the expected moan. As promised, I did not hold back. I slammed my cock in and out of her while slowly removing the plug from her ass. After a minute, feeling my cock was wet enough from her natural lube, I pulled out, stretched her ass cheeks, lined up my cock, and slowly pushed in.

“oh god, oh god” was all she said as she took my cock deeply into her ass. She was moaning and breathing heavy, all while pushing back against me. “Such a fucking slut, taking my cock all the way up your fucking ass while your husband, your in-laws, and my fiancé sit there sipping wine. And I used to think you were a stuck-up bitch. Now I know better: you’re just a horny bitch with a cock stuck up your ass!” Knowing we did not have a lot of time, I started pounding her ass. I wanted to verbally berate her more, but I was also afraid of making too much noise. Without a view outside, I couldn’t be certain no one was around. So instead, I concentrated on fucking her tight, hot asshole.

The room was filled with the sounds of slapping skin, moaning, and grunting. “Reach back and rub your clit” I demanded. She tightened immediately against my cock as she started touching herself. I slammed into her faster, still fully lubed from her wetness. Because she was in a slightly different position, she was hitting up against the desk, adding to the overall sound of our fucking. I was lost in thought as I enjoyed her tight ass, thinking about the last few weeks, dominating Cindy, being dominated by Ellie, and everything in general. I was getting close.

Cindy tightened further as she came, closing her tight ass around my hard cock. Two more strokes and I unloaded in her ass, my cock hanging halfway out. Knowing we likely spent too much time already, despite the entire quick session lasting under ten minutes, I grabbed the plug and slid it back in, trapping my cum inside her as I removed my cock. Cindy stood, smoothing her desk, and tried to fix her hair. “What was your excuse for coming up?” I asked. She replied “Advil. I didn’t want to change. I like this dress.”

“Ha, well, get your fucking ass down there before anyone suspects. I’ll stay up and come down later.” With a slap and a push, I guided her to the door, getting the final word: “You’re starting to become a really good assfuck Cindy. I may have to just start fucking your ass every time!” She gave me the usual look, hatred mixed with lust, before slamming the door on her way out.

Two minutes later, my phone vibrated with a text from Ellie: “How do they not know? She totally looks freshly fucked and they are all sitting here like she has not even returned. She keeps glancing at me and doesn’t think I can see.” I responded “Well, maybe if she lifted her dress and showed everyone the plug holding my cum in her ass, they would all figure it out.” “Hot, LOL. Jealous. Not really, but you’re going to fuck the shit out of me tonight.”

I will refrain from going down the rabbit hole of the phrase “fuck the shit out of you,” especially used even remotely close to anal sex, but I got the basic message: Ellie was turned on and was going to use my cock for her pleasure tonight. After a few more minutes, I hit their bathroom, cleaned up, and headed back to the table. “It’s getting late, so I think Ellie and I are going to head out. Not sure if we will be at dinner next week, but I will let you know mom.”

We said goodbyes, Paul basically ignoring us as usual, buried in his phone. As Ellie hugged Cindy, I noticed her hand drop, grazing Cindy’s ass, seemingly innocent. I am pretty sure Cindy shuttered. Ellie, being a hugger, then hugged my mom and dad, ignoring Paul (per usual). We left and barely made it home before Ellie was all over me.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ntri2p/chapter_9_my_new_fucktoy_thursday_night

One comment on “Chapter 9 – [M]y New [F]ucktoy – Thursday Night

  1. any chance we could get a pic of cindy with the butt plug in her ass

Comments are closed.