I had decided to buy a butt plug, so that I could pleasure myself whenever I felt the need for a good fucking. I got so caught up in the idea that I bought my first one online and, of course, got greedy and ordered the biggest size. When it arrived, imagine my surprise when I opened the packaging and saw just how big it was. It was a tapered black pug that was three inches in diameter at its widest. Holy shit, there was no way I’d be able to take this thing.
I gave it a try a few times, lying on my back in bed and sliding the lubed plug into myself as far as I could get it, which was only about half way. I could turn on the vibrator at that point and push it into my prostate, which was enough to make me hard and cum, but it wasn’t the full penetration I wanted. I would need to buy a smaller plug.
One day at work, I found myself extremely aroused all day. I don’t know what it was, but I couldn’t wait to get home. I was going to try and use that monster plug on myself one last time. When I got home that day, I rushed into my apartment and stripped down naked. I got the plug and some lube and went into my living room to try something different. I lubed up the plug and placed it on the floor, squatting down over it. Carefully, I squatted down on to the plug and felt it begin to enter my ass. I squatted a little further and it stretched my ass out further. Still further and it was further into my ass than I’d ever gotten it before. I was squatting up and down on it now and it kept penetrating into me further and further. I had the plug almost all the way into me and my ass was stretched further than it had ever been. I couldn’t believe it. I turned on the vibrator in it and when I felt it run through my prostate, my rock hard cock came nearly immediately. I was nearly out of breath from the sensation and slid it slowly out of my ass, lying on the floor. My ass was gaping the rest of the day, it felt like.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/c9512v/my_first_butt_plug
Love the gaping part.