Surprising my [F] boyfriend [M] with my first buttplug

Aaron and I have been together since high school, but now we’re 21/M and 22/F, respectively. Even though we’ve only been with each other, I think we’re pretty adventurous sexually (playing around with a whip and some exhibitionism might be stories for another time). He’s 5’10”, freckled, with strong broad shoulders and a cute butt. I’m 5’3”, olive skin with larger than average boobs and an ass that I’m proud of thanks to some long hours in the gym.

We’ve had anal before, but we don’t do it very often, because of the prep work involved. I often will find a finger or two in my butt during sex though, and I love his tongue in my asshole while we shower together. We had been talking for a while about buying a butt plug for me, but never actually done it, so I took advantage of a certain 2-day free shipping service and bought an adorable steel plug with a blue jewel that looks incredible nestled between my ass cheeks.

I live around 2 hours from Aaron, and we had plans for me to spend the night with him on Friday. A few days before hand, we were on the phone, and I told him I couldn’t wait to fuck him, and that I had a surprise for him. He told me he was hard, and begged to know what I was hiding. Don’t worry, I didn’t tell.

Friday morning I woke up to a picture of his dick, hard, very thick (and a few cm longer than average from what I can tell). He was excited about his surprise present, and said he might have to punish me later for being such a tease. I was alone at the office at the time, so I took the opportunity to send a few seconds of video, showing me pulling down my top and bra, and quickly pinching a nipple.

I asked him if he liked knowing I was his horny public slut, and I think he must’ve because throughout the day I received more pictures from him, and instructions for me. He told me how to pose for him, and how to touch myself. He said I was to stay wet for him all day, but I didn’t have any trouble at all with that task!

Finally it was time for my drive over. I stopped a few minutes from his house to freshen up and insert my well-lubed plug. Oh my gosh it was tight!! I’m glad I decided not to do the whole drive with it in because I could barely breathe. We were worked up from the day of sexting, and within a few seconds of my entry his tongue was in my mouth. I pulled away, gently pushed him onto the bed, and told him to close his eyes if he wanted his surprise.

“Ok, you can open them” I was now completely naked, facing away from him and bent over so my hands were clasping my ankles. I heard him gasp, then felt his hands toying with my plug. It sent tingles straight to my clit to feel him pushing the little cylinder in and out of my tight ass.

Without warning I felt a smack. It wasn’t his hand, but his rock-hard cock, slapping against my ass. “You slut, you teased me all day and now you deserve to be punished” he growled.

“Oh yes, please fuck me!” I was begging, my vagina dripping already.

He spanked me for real now, with an open palm, fast and hard and making me struggle to stay upright. “Stay still.” He commanded “Where do you want my cock?”.

He was sliding his shaft between my pussy lips now, coating it with my juices. I was begging to be fucked anywhere – I asked for his dick in my ass.

Then he pulled out the plug and replaced it with his cock. He was gentle at first, stretching out my asshole with his big dick and reaching around to circle my clit with his fingers. As I relaxed, he started to pump harder into me, grasping handfuls of my ass to pull me into him, balls slapping against my slit as he fucked me.

“Rub yourself,” he told me.

“Please cum inside me Aaron!” I rubbed faster, I was so close, “please fill up my ass with that hard cock, I want to feel you cum in me!” I was cumming, trying my best not to topple over and ruin his rhythm. He grabbed me tighter and I felt his cock throb, and begin to shoot pulses inside of me.

We collapsed, and I asked him if he had enjoyed his surprise. With a playful smack on my ass, he said he certainly had.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bffwjy/surprising_my_f_boyfriend_m_with_my_first_buttplug

1 comment

Comments are closed.