So this is a while back. For context on this, the prelude was a big group of my college peoples going out to see the JJ Abrams Star Trek reboot at the dollar theater.
It was a large group, and afterwards we went over to somebody’s place to have drinks and hang out. Ended up being a group of four left after a bit. Myself, the couple that lived there (Ashley and Her Dude, whose name escapes me at the time), and Dee.
Ashley was somebody who quite enjoyed playing outside her relationship (she had propositioned one of my exes and myself a few months before this for a foursome, which I had deferred to said ex.) But she was well known in our friends circle for sexual shennanigans.
We end up playing some card game. One of those drinking games where you tell secrets, or that sort of thing. Ashley keeps adjusting the rules to make it dirtier and dirtier, and partway through this, I realize that I, through no real work of my own, am about to be the single guy in a foursome. Dunno how I got that lucky, but I remember taking a drink and thinking to myself “Ok, you’re lucky, don’t fuck this up”
Cards are drawn, clothes start coming off. Its worth it to describe Ashley and Dee at this point. Ashley was a dancer, with this fit and slender thing going on. Tops a B cup, with great legs. Fake redhead, but she was pale enough that it worked. The kind of face that looked best when she was making a sly dirty joke.
Dee was on the other end of the hot spectrum. Latina, with frankly absurdly big tits. But big and perky in the way that 20/21 year old tits can be. The kind of body that wouldn’t stop, but that she’d have to definitely be careful as she got older (and far as I can see from Facebook pictures, she has. So good on Dee, right?) Long dark curly hair. The one weird thing about Dee was that she was a devout Christian. But she was a *horny* devout Christian. I knew of one other instance where she was in a situation like this, where a couple took her home. We always said that Dee needed to find a nice boy to just perv on so she’d be OK.
So I end up sitting there, a rum and coke in one hand, and wearing nothing, between two gorgeous girls, also wearing nothing, and with one of the girl’s boyfriends, wearing nothing (I don’t swing that way, but I’m not a homophobe. He was a good dude, far as I remember)
It starts with seven minutes in heaven-type things, and I find out that apparently I’m a good kisser, and I managed to contain my enthusiasm for Dee’s *incredible* rack, and be gentle. She seemed to like it. She was a little shy despite being a horny little thing (I’ve never seen somebody get as wet as she did after some gentle touching).
Same thing happened with Dee and Dude, and then Ashley and myself. According to Ashley, who I assume has seen plenty of cocks, I’ve got a average length cock, but with above average girth (which according to her is ideal). She tells me this as she goes to her knees during our seven minutes in heaven, telling me in the midst of licks and sucks that she can’t wait to have it inside her. She’s also the first person to deepthroat me, which almost made me fall over to see and feel that. If you’ve had that, you know what I mean… its hard to even describe, I think.
Eventually we just drop the pretenses, and proceed to their bedroom and just start playing. I don’t remember the exact sequence of events in there, so I’m going to relate them as best I recall.
I got the feeling Dee was a little nervous, and we started off with her. One dude on each tit, and Ashley licking her pussy (The only downside to Dee was that she had a hell of a thatch down below. I’m not one to demand grooming one way or another, but it really did make it difficult to pleasure her. I got firsthand experience a little later.) Just hearing her moan was hot, it sounded like she was being overwhelmed. She did get a little nervous when it was my turn to work her little pussy, but I reassured her that I didn’t want to do anything she didn’t want to, and it was important to her that she remain a virgin (if such a thing was possible after you’ve had three people pleasuring you. But that was her choice. So Dee didn’t get proper fucked.) But apparently I was the first person to find her g-spot, and she almost tossed the other two off her tits when she arched her back. God, she was a responsive girl. Made me wish she was willing to let me really get inside her, she came across as somebody who would be great in the sack from the get go.
We rotated around to pleasure Ashley, which rapidly turned into myself and Dude double-teaming his girlfriend. I was fucking her, while she blew him, and Dee played with her tits. She had a great hip action, and it could be said that she was still the one fucking us, not vice versa.
Both myself and Dude ended up having the girls go down on us in pairs. I had to get the fantasy of two girls blowing me at the same time. Dee was eager, but honestly bad at it (not shocking), and Ashley was her normal perverse self. It kind of petered off after I fingerfucked Dee another time, and I got the feeling she got nervous that we might try something.
We had sobered up by this point, and after we all got our clothes back on, I offered to drive Dee back to her place. This was August in the midwest, and we were going down the main drag at like 3 AM. Conversation went, and she admitted that she had gotten close, but hadn’t cum at all. I let that sink in for a moment, and then reach across while I’m driving to slide my hand down her shorts. This was in my old Jeep with the top down in the summer. Probably one of the more erotic images that I’ve seen, with her moaning with her eyes closed and her head thrown back as I worked her.
We arrived at the turn, one way went up to where she was the RA at a dorm, and the other would end up at my place… I asked her if I should keep driving or turn (cheating a little bit, by making sure I rubbed her clit with each question). She half moaned out “You… should turn”. I was disappointed, but I’m not that guy, so I turned in and parked. Walked her to the door, and mentioned that I thought she was a lot of fun, and that we had always had fun even before now, and that maybe we should get dinner.
Her response made my jaw drop, and made me realize that she was not the right girl for me. “I’m sorry, I could never date you. You’re not a Christian”.
Long story short, I’ve always been amazed at the mental gymnastics that some Christian types can go through. Foursome? No problem. Dating an atheist? Absolutely not.
But she was hot, and so was Ashley, and its a memory I’ll never forget.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bf2wri/my_one_crazy_college_foursome_mfmf
That was an awesome story!!