Two’s company… three’s amazing! (My first threesome with my high school crush) [MMF]

-So last time I said there was one more story involving me and Nat, thus far, that is worth telling. Well now there are two; so here is part one. Enjoy.-

Me and Nat had been seeing each other since July. We’d had a lot of fun together and tried a lot of stuff out with each other. (See my last post for details of that) We we’re still enjoying each other’s company but had kind of run out of things to try. That didn’t mean we were bored of each other it, we just both really like that feeling of trying something new and kinky with each other. That butterfly feeling in your stomach.
I hadn’t seen Nat for around three days when she popped up with her little suggestion. Normally she’s very chatty over text etc. I’ve learned to know that if she’s quiet then she’s usually up to something. And sure enough; she was.
I got a message from her late one night after hearing nothing for almost a day and a half.
“Hey so I was thinking… you ever thought of having a threesome?”
Nat has a way of just coming out with incredibly erotic things. I told her like most things it had always been a fantasy but I’d never seriously considered doing it. Nat then proceeded to describe, in lurid detail, how she’d always dreamed of getting fucked by two guys.
“So?!” She said “How about it?”
I’m fairly secure in my sexuality but the idea of being with another guy while with Nat made me nervous. First and foremost I felt like I’d probably be competing with this guy. What if he was fitter, hotter, bigger than me? I was a little apprehensive to say the least but Nat, as ever, persuaded me. She did so by saying that I could have an equal say in who we’d bring into the threesome.
We were both adamant that the third person be someone we didn’t know incase the whole thing turned out to be an awkward mess. Nat and I spent the next two weeks interviewing candidates over Reddit, tinder etc. And finally settled on someone.
Harry (we’ll call him) was our age, roughly the same physique as me (tall and slim fit), he was smaller if a bit thicker than me; Nat joked that she’d be getting both length and girth just not from one guy. He also had long, nearly shoulder length, curly dirty blonde hair. We spent several days chatting to him, checking he was clean, safe etc. and then set the date.

<Sex starts here>

We agreed to meet in bar before heading back to Nat’s place. I arrived first ordered a drink and nervously sat waiting. Harry arrived soon afterwards. He was wearing a plain white t-shirt, skinny black ripped jeans and a black leather jacket. He introduced himself in person, got a drink and then we sat politely conversing about our jobs, movies, the weather; anything but what was about to happen. I could tell that we were both nervous.
Nat arrived some 20 minuets later. She was wearing a tight black dress, very low cut. She saw us both sitting at the table and walked over with a mischievous smile on her face.
She said hello, chatted for a moment and upon seeing we’d both finished our drinks said “Well then. Shall we go?” My self and Harry looked at each other nervously, stood up and walked toward the door with Nat.
It was cold outside and Nat linked arms with me and Harry as we walked the few blocks back to her place.
We said nothing on the way back to Nat’s. It only took ten minuets to reach her front door. She opened it and ran up the stairs shouting back at us to “Just head on into the living room, get yourself a another drink, you know where”.
I went first into the kitchen/ living room and Harry followed. I pored him another drink and we both sat waiting for Nat. I was just about to break the awkward silence when Nat did it for me. She appeared in the doorway wearing a short silk robe and, what I knew to be, one of her favourite sets of lingerie. Both me and Harry sat transfixed on her.
“Well what are you waiting for?” She said with a smile.
“Take your clothes off. Tonight is about me. I want to see how my two men compare.” She continued, smile turning to a giggle.
We both stood and obediently stripped down to our boxers at which point me and Harry glanced at each other again.
“Everything off?” I asked Nat, knowing full well what the answer would be. She just smirked and drummed her fingers impatiently on the doorframe.
Myself and Harry slipped out of our boxers and stood there in front of Nat grinning at the sight of us.
“Wow” She said crossing the room and undoing the silk robe before sliding it off her shoulders to reveal her favourite blue lace lingerie “to handsome guys just for me?”
She stood between us, a hand on both our chests. She slowly reached down and wrapped her fingers around both our cocks.
“Let’s see how you compare.” She said smiling again.
Then she kissed us, on after the other before dropping to her knees. Nat took Harry in her mouth first and kept stroking me as she did before swapping to me, pushing my hardening cock back into her throat. By the time the few seconds it took for us to both get hard had passed Nat was gleefully swapping from cock to cock bobbing her head back and fourth, fondling balls and stroking as she went.
I could see that Harry wasn’t as big as me ( His 6.5 inches to my 7) but he was defiantly thicker. Nat seemed to be enjoying stretching her mouth and throat out.
By now we were both throbbing hard and Nat’s saliva was dripping from both our balls. She stopped sucking and sat staring up at us licking her lips with pleasure. It was so hot I thought I was going to cum there and then.
Nat reached into the pocket of the silk robe, now lying slung over the coffee table, and took out two condoms. (Nat and I don’t normally use condoms when it’s just us but I instantly understood why she was going to when it was me and Harry.) she slowly slid them on to our cocks and stood.
She let go of our cocks and slid her lace panties off as she stood, leaving on her stockings, suspenders and corset. When she reached her feet she removed the bra section of her lingerie. She turned to face Harry.
“I want you to bend me over and fuck me, yeah?” She said placing a hand on his chest.
She turned to face me, away from Harry, and Harry pushed her back down and spread her legs. Nat reached for my cock and began to lick around the head. She took a sharp short breath in as Harry slid into her.
“Oh my god, you’re so wet already” said Harry.
As she began, slowly at first, to rock his hips back and forward Nat began to suck my cock again. But has Harry quickened his pace she pulled off me and panted “Fuck my mouth, fuck me please, fuck my mouth.”
She pushed herself deep onto my cock as Harry’s thighs began slapping into her ass and I grabbed her head and hair with both hands. I started to thrust into Nat’s mouth soon I could hear my cock slipping back and forth and feel my cock head hitting the back of Nat’s throat.
As both mine and Harry’s thrusts became quicker and harder Nat stuck her tongue forward along the bottom of my shaft until it nearly touched my balls, letting me thrust deep down her throat. I could hear Nat whimper and groan as we fucked her from both ends. I could see that Harry was getting close to cumming and Nat must have felt it too because she pulled away from both of us.
“Your turn” she said wrapping her arms around my neck.
She looked over her shoulder, back at Harry and reaching one hand behind her pulled him close behind her. Running a hand through his hair, pushing his lips into her neck she gave him his next instruction.
“I want you to eat my ass.” She whispered to him.
I grabbed one of Nat’s legs, hooking an arm under the back of her knee, slid my cock into her and began to thrust slowly, deliberately grinding my body up against her clit. Harry kissed his way down Nat’s back and started to caress her ass cheeks before shoving his face between them. As Harry’s tongue began to explore Nat’s ass she let out a great sighing moan and threw her head back breathing heavily. It didn’t take long for Nat to cum. She started moving her hips back and forth grinding her clit off me and her ass off Harry’s tongue. She grabbed a handful of Harry’s hair as she came, soaking my crotch in her juices.
Nat almost collapsed and ended up lying back on the sofa. I took the initiative and knelt between her legs, pushed my cock back into her and started thrusting. Harry too, thought on his feet. He stepped onto the sofa, squatted down and slid his cock into Nat’s open, panting mouth. She sucked his cock greedily gripping his balls with a free hand.
Nat came close to cumming again and I couldn’t have lasted much longer she she pulled away from both of us. She sat me down on the sofa beside her and climbed onto my lap to ride me. As she lowered herself onto my cock and began to move herself up and down my cock she turned to Harry.
“I want you to stretch out my ass with your fat cock” she demanded. Harry maneuvered behind Nat and, after coating his cock with lube pushed into Nat’s ass.
As Harry entered her ass Nat pushed herself down onto my cock and let out a breathless cry. The sensation drove her wild. Almost instantly she started to bounce up and down in a slightly circular motion. Both our cocks slid in and out of her increasingly fast.
As our speed increased I could feel myself getting close.
“Cum in me. I want you to both cum in me. Cum in me please!” She said, her voice trembling from riding. That sent Harry over the edge. I felt his thrusts quicken and him start to grunt as he finished in Nat’s ass. Nat clearly felt him cum and started to orgasm. As I’ve previously mentioned Nat is a squirter and she quickly sprayed my crotch as Harry collapsed, exhausted onto the sofa behind her, pulling out of her ass.
Nat raised her hips slightly grabbed my cock and pulled off the condom before lowering herself back onto my cock.
“Give me it. Give me your cum. Fill me.” She whispered into my ear.
She needn’t have asked. My cock hand started to pump cum as soon as she’d slid me back inside her. I thrusted into her deeply and filled her with my cum.
Nat collapsed onto my chest. We all lay there panting and exhausted.

After a few minuets we started to clean up, got dressed and all had another few drinks. Harry left shortly there after. I stayed at Nat’s that night and she told me how much she’d enjoyed playing out her fantasy.
“Next time it’s your turn, though.” She whispered to me as we fell asleep.

-so that’s yet another story about me and Nat. Another is soon to follow. I hope you have enjoyed.-

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/9u90xh/twos_company_threes_amazing_my_first_threesome

8 comments on “Two’s company… three’s amazing! (My first threesome with my high school crush) [MMF]

  1. Great story, I really enjoyed reading it. Your storytelling is on point. Very hot.

    Maybe you could check it again for orthography and expressions (e.g. definitely, not defiantly) again.

Comments are closed.