[MMF] Cheating, Squared

My first attempt. 100% true (the dialogue isn’t always word for word, I’m not rainman) and I have plenty of stories like this, so if theres demand, I’ll be happy to share more of my experiences with everyone. IAlso stats if anyone cares, 6’5” broad shouldered Viking blood type frat dude. I do also do most of my writing for standup, but girls have always told me my dirty talk was exceptional, and I lurk here allot, so here it goes. I’m not really a photographer or videographer but again if theres demand, maybe I could start doing that, though writing will always be my preferred medium. Please forgive typos.

So sometime around last year I transferred to a college in the Boston area, and thats when all of this started. I was living in a 6 person suite, and its a pretty academically rigorous school, so most of the kids living there were not what you would call “social butterflies”. I did luck out on one roommate though, we ended up bonding one night at the beginning of the year laughing about the odd behavior of some of our other roommates. He (the cool roommate, Zach) was a very athletic, well built guy, the kind of guy you want to be your friend if you’re trying to break into a new school socially.
Over the course of the next semester we went out a good number of times, but I had a girlfriend that I’d met in the interim period between switching schools, and she hated me going out with him. She thought he was “bad news” and would always text me worriedly all night long when I would go out partying with him. I tried to placate her by telling her he had a girlfriend also (he did), but she had met him a few times and knew the type of guy he was, and how a little thing like being in a committed relationship probably wouldn’t stop him. That was the dynamic for the first semester, friends who’d go out a few times a month, but not much more than that, he wasn’t really intellectually stimulating enough to be the sort of guy you would hang out with sober.

Next semester we found out we had a pretty intense science course together. It was a lot of work, and he needed a lot of help (it was a course on human disease, and halfway into the semester he still didn’t know the difference between viruses and bacteria), so we would sometimes study together. We ended up doing very little studying since he was perpetually on Tinder trying to get laid with his (admittedly impressive) muscle selfies, in spite of the girlfriend.
On a random weeknight about halfway through the semester, he tells me he has a girl from our class coming over…
“What…? Which one?” I asked kind of in disbelief. There were some properly fine serostitutes (sorority girls of a free sprinted nature) in our class, but I had never seen him really do anything except talk to me, stare into space, or swipe left/right on Tinder all class long. “Brittany, she usually sits like 2 rows behind us, long brown hair, big tits, nice ass, wears soccer team sweatpants or yoga pants.” I had no idea who he was talking about, that description fit a solid number of girls, and I did know him to be an embellisher of female attractiveness when he wanted to impress me. “Okay but how did you meet her?” I asked him. “I just hit her up on Facebook.” “What? Did you talk to her first?” “Nah man, just hit her up.” I relaxed, my masculine competitive drive went back into its resting state. “Dude you can’t just do that, thats fucking creepy. You don’t just rando hit girls up on Facebook, thats some shit *&%$( one of our creepier roommates) would do. “Bro results are all that matter. Can you argue with my results?”

This was a typical excuse he used when I would call him out for doing creepy shit on Tinder or otherwise. Despite that, I had come to learn in my time since transferring that he had banged about half the campus, even if he had a bit of a reputation for being kinda sketchy.

She showed up about an hour later to what had become our weekly study sessions, and I instantly remembered her. She actually wasn’t one of the sorority girls I had been expecting, but she did fit his original description pretty much to the letter. She was about 5’7” (I honestly don’t know), she had a nice set of 34DD boobs, accentuated by a small peace sign necklace that draped down between them. Her chest was covered by a just-barely-visible baby blue bra, which in turn was covered by a low cut black tank, with some midriff visible (flat stomach). She had one of those small yet somehow protruding bubble butts, the kind that when covered by loose college sweatpants rides up into the crack so you get a great view in spite of the bagginess. Her hair was brown-blonde and she had green sparkling eyes, and a decent set of lips.

She was very easy going, a good mix between a stoner girl and student athlete, and it wasn’t long after the initial awkwardness of her being some chick he had hit up on fbook faded, and we were laughing/studying the way we usually did. After us low-key hitting on her for a while, he got up and went to his room. She got a text, got up and went to into his room also. Minutes later I heard that sweet collegiate sound of a cheap single bed banging against a painted cinderblock wall, and nodded silently in acknowledgement to myself. I stayed in the common room where we had been studying for an hour or so watching the TV, until the door finally swung open and the two of them stepped out.
He walked her out of our dorm, passing by a group of guys on the way out. Before to the door to our room closed on of the group popped his head in, “Was that Brittney?” he asked me. I was a little bit confused, I didn’t know the guy and he’d just come into my room. “Yeah, why?” I asked. “Whats Zach doing with Brittany?” I didn’t get what the issue was, but another guy from the group out of view spoke up “Thats Danny’s girlfriend isn’t it?” The first guy turned without saying another word and let the door shut. A few minutes later Zach came back and I asked him about the guys. “Soccer guys,” He said. “They are on the team with her boyfriend.” I paused for a few seconds to let my brain react……….. ”Niiiiiccee” I said. He smiled the biggest fucking grin I’d ever seen him smile in our short friendship, and showed me some of the texts he’d sent her to give me context.

Things went on pretty much the same for a few weeks. She added me on Facebook and we would chat from time to time, I’d tease her about Zach and she would “lolol”. The best part was getting to see all the romantic posts on Facebook she had with her and her bf, how much she loved him, cringe worthy posts of them traveling together with lots of PDA thrown in etc. Zach would pass me the phone sometimes and I’d text her on his behalf when he didn’t know how to respond. We studied together a few more times, I’d flirt with her a bit, and she would come over dressed sluttier and sluttier, then she and Zach would go fuck and that would be the night.

One study session near the end of the year, Zach decided he wanted to go to dinner, but Brittany didn’t feel like walking all the way to the pizza place at the end of campus so she stayed with me. We didn’t get a whole lot of studying done, it was mostly for Zach’s benefit anyway, but we did end up talking a fair amount. I slyly worked my way from teasing her about having sex with Zach to just talking to her about sex in general. It wasn’t anything to crazy, but I started directly complimenting her on her “attributes” just so she knew I thought she was sexy and wasn’t just some beta sidekick Zach kept around. But I played it safe, I didn’t want him to feel threatened or anything. We also talked about what we liked in bed, and she was intrigued by some of the answers I gave, that I really liked going down on girls and was exceptionally good at it, and that I liked to compete for dominance in bed. I then moved back to teasing her again about Zach, trying to get her to tell me what he was like, how good he was. She was to shy to go there for very long and would mostly laugh it off or avoid the question as a joke. I let her know how competitive we were. When Zach got back she invited us both to a soccer team party that was going on the next night. In my opinion it was an extremely bold move, the team had already been asking around, and now she wanted to bring two big good looking guys to his teams party?
Anyway that Friday night we got pretty drunk playing drinking games watching Shark Tank (its a 30 channel college tv what do you want from me?).

Zach was always trying to get me drunk enough to pull girls with him in spite of my gf, and tonight was no exception. We went to the party around 10, and it was already nearly dead. Luckily there was tons of free beer lying around, and my fraternity days had left the instinctual compulsion to consume any and all leftovers. The party sucked, but when we left Zach and I were properly fucked up, as was Brittany. We all made our way back to our dorms common room, but it was only 11:30. Zach refused to give up on the night, and I had to admit with the alcohol coursing through my veins, most notably the ones in my dick, I really was not feeling ready to get late pizza and fall asleep watching Netflix. Zach said we should try more drinking games, and I didn’t disagree, so he got up and ran to his room.
He came back with a full deck of your standard bicycle cards, and after a pretty lame drinking version of the game “war”, casually suggested we play strip poker. Brittany looked uneasy, especially with two of us there, and the fact that we were still in the public common room. I was also a little put off, but he started chanting something along the lines of “buzzkill” over and over obnoxiously loud, so we agreed. Of course the one problem was both Zach and Brittany had no idea to play any form of poker, and I was too fucked up to teach the rules. So we played strip war. It was kind of lame, 50/50 chance doesn’t exactly allow for the type of runs you need to get someone fully naked. But eventually we started to change the definitions of what counted as clothes until both Zach and I were down to our boxers in the common room. It took a little longer to get her shirt finally off, but off it came. So there we were, her in-between us, jeans and a bra, both of us in only our boxers.

He scooted over and her arms and her side touched the side of my abs. I was surprised how warm she felt on my flushed skin, I hadn’t felt another girl other than my gfs in months and I pressed back against her to try to get the most of the feeling. We played a few more hands which she lost, and she was down to her panties and bra. We played one more hand, and it was we who lost this time. I knew this was the point of no return, but something told me to go for it so I stood up and pulled off my boxers, and sat back down on the couch. Zach did the same. At this point I could feel her warm skin pressed against me from ankle all the way up to my shoulder. I couldn’t really wait for the stupid cards, so I reached over and with a single twist undid her bra. She yelped a little in surprise, moving to hold it in place, but admitted she was at least a little impressed with the ease of the trick. Zach quickly moved her hand away and took it off her, but she was to shy to go any further in the common room, so we moved to Zach’s room.

Zach pushed her down on the bed, and started grabbing her tits while jerking off. I sat down next to her on the bed and started looking around for a drink, it was a very hot spring night and we were all already sweating. He was still having some trouble getting hard by the time I had found and finished a drink, but my cock was aching and pounding between my legs to the drumbeat of my heart. I was loosing patients with him, but they started making out so I sat back for a little bit longer, and did some adderall off her thigh. After the blue powder disappeared up my nose, I had had it with his erectile disfunction, and jokingly “tagged myself in while you take a breather buddy”.

He got up and went to the bathroom, presumably to psych himself back into it and have a little lockerroom chat with his poorly performing member. I didn’t wait for her to start second guessing the situation with him gone, I pushed her flat on the bed as soon as he had left the room. I pinned her shoulders against the bed and ran the tip of my tongue up her neck, ending at her earlobe, which I gave a little nibble/tug. She yelped in the cutest way imaginable, and reached out gripping the erect cock hanging between my legs. I flicked her ear with my tongue like a little clit and whispered to her, asking again for the answer I’d tried to get out of her so many times “who’s bigger?”… “you are” she whispered back. I kissed her ear again, “What about your boyfriends?” I whispered. At that she just started laughing and nodding, and she gripped my balls with her other free hand. “I’ve never felt anyone throb like that before, I could tell your pulse” she laughed as she slowly stroked it. “All you” I whispered back to her.

I kissed my way down her body, til I got to the panties she was still wearing. She moved her hands to slide them down but I quickly pinned them to her sides. I leaned down and told her I was going to show her just how good I was at going down. I ran my tongue over the crease in the fabric where her pussy was, and it quickly dampened with the spit from my tongue. I ran the wet, slightly rough panties up and down over her pussy slowly, with long, deep, licks. She groaned and her back arched slightly, her taste started to seep through which encouraged me only to go slower. I ran my tongue under the top and side lips of her underwear, making sure to miss her pussy by just milimeters, teasing her with the wall of cotton still between us, licking the inside of her thighs and sucking around her navel. I pushed my tongue inside of her, still covered in the now soaking fabric, then moved up for more long flat licks of the wet fabric over her clit. Her hips bucked and she again tried to wiggle her way out of her panties, but I didn’t let her. I sucked on her pussy through the soaking panties, getting as much of her taste as I could before pulling up and giving her a long, deep kiss, swapping her taste from my tongue onto hers.

I leaned back onto my knees and grabbed her by her hips, and rolled her tiny body over in a single motion, and propped her up on her knees, face down into the pillow, her ass in the air. I grabbed her nice full little ass cheeks and spread them, pushing my face down between them. I ran my tongue again up and down her mound, gripping her ass tightly apart. I moved up a little and lightly tickled the rim of her asshole with the wet cotton, then pushed it in and traced the circles around it. She seemed unsure of this at first, but I took my time slowly eating her ass more and more through her panties, and bringing my thumb up to rub her clit through them as I did so. “I’ve never done that” she said with an award laugh, “What this?” I asked, finally pulling her panties down and thrusting the tip of my tongue inside her ass. She moaned a long “Fuuuuuuuuuck” in the most unintentionally sexy way possible. I pulled her panties down to her knees, revealing her bare pink ass, and ran my teeth over it before biting it and giving it a nice slap. She was literally dripping down onto the bed as I ran my tongue back and forth over her pink little asshole, like allot of girls I’d been with, I could tell this was a fantasy that she had not yet fulfilled.

Seeing how wet she was really turned me on, and as I flipped over onto my back, a large glob of translucent pre-cum drooped out onto my abs. She tried to look under herself awkwardly at me, but her tits were in the way. I gripped her hips and pulled her back down onto me, her ass resting on my chest. I felt her wet little cunt squish against my chest as she sat up on top of me, and my dick throbbed in pleasure. I looked up at her and told her in a quiet voice “I want you to fuck my face, I want you to grind yourself all over me till I’m dripping in your cum.” She said nothing, I had teased her long enough, she hoisted herself onto of me an started to grind her wet pussy against my lips. I took her hand, placed it in my hair, and closed it. She quickly caught on, and gripped it tight. I sucked her pussy as hard as I could till I felt her clit swell up twice its size, then started slowly playing with it on my tongue. I would stop every now and again and she would buck her hips and pull my hair in a signal to continue. “You’re not fucking my face” I said to her after a minute or two. “Let me show you” I said. I grabbed her ass and pushed it forward, her pussy lips split and slid down either side of my nose. I rubbed her cunt all up and down my face, my brow, my chin, over my eyes, till I was completely soaking in her cum. She got the message, and started thrusting herself all up and down the length of my face, riding it by my hair like a mount. She started really getting into it, moaning and pushing her lips down against me as hard as she could. I started jerking my cock as she did it, which really turned her on, so I made sure to jack it extra hard so she could feel my face vibrating under her.

I put my hand up to her face and had her suck my finger. I took it nice and wet, and snuck it up her ass. I hooked it an pulled her back down to my mouth and started licking her swollen clit as fast as I could (pretty fast). I fingered her ass slowly (it needed gentler treatment) while licking her quickly and looked up at her. I pushed my finger deeper into her ass and changed the light fingering into a deep thrusting, eating her pussy as hard as I possibly could. I felt her clit swell up even larger, her cum flowing down onto my tongue, and her thighs began to tremble.

She tried to move away but I held her firmly on my face. I reached up and grabbed her hair at the nape of her neck, and forced her to look down into my eyes. I looked right at her and her hips started to buck uncontrollably. Her whole body shook and I felt her ass contact around my finger so violently it was forced out. She gritted her teeth and fell forward on her hands, hips still bucking hard. She collapsed beside me. “What the fuck dude?” she said. “Holy fucking shit” I smiled, slightly proud of my work. She was still covering her face and laying beside me almost a minute later, so I got up to look for condoms. “I’m gunna need…like a minute.” She said arm still over her face. At that minute Zach walked back in, hard as a diamond.

He looked down at her collapsed flushed form. “Damn dude what did you do to her.” He laughed, partly joking, partly unsure. I Laughed. “Well was he as good at that as he made himself out to be?” He asked, again sounding just slightly threatened. “Uhmmm yeah…….he wasn’t lying” She said. He had laughed again, and offered her his dick. She sat up and started blowing him infant of me. No homo i’ll admit it was kinda hot to watch. Up until now we had been in the room alone, this was the first time either of us was doing anything with her in the room at the same time. I was a little bummed that after being so insanely turned on I hadn’t gotten anything back from her yet, but to be honest it was also a relief. The room must have been a hundred degrees at this point, and I collapsed onto the floor panting while she sucked him off. If you’re eating pussy properly, you should be out of breath after, but I was pretty much on the brink of death. All three of our bodies were completely glistening with sweat in the dim light that was coming through the window, but I was by far the slipperiest of the three. I laid on the ground, legs spread eagle, fan between my legs cooling me off.

She was doing a great job, cumming as hard as she had must have worked up an appetite in her, because she was going all out slurping his cock. Credit to him that he didn’t nut her mouth right there, many lesser men would have, but he stuck with it, grabbing her hair, and calling her a bitch as she licked his balls. But the heat also started to get to him, and his boner started loosing steam. My guess is he didn’t want to loose it before fucking her, he pulled a condom from under the bed, slid it over his shaft, and put it in her. She was still pretty sensitive at first, but then she warmed to it. For my own part I had finally cooled down a bit, and I came over and sat on the bed next to him.

She tried to suck me off while he fucked her, but thats an art that takes practice, and the bj was so sub par I eventually just let her enjoy the dick she was getting. She moaned a little, but he still kept having to pull out and jerk himself back up to full strength while fucking her. I decided to try and help by distracting them both. I set up the fan so it was blowing on him, and I lifted her so she was upright and sandwiched between us. I held her aloft by her throat while he fucked her and started kissing her. This really turned him on and he started fucking her properly for the first time. I pulled her arms around me for support and started really making out with her. Sucking her tongue into my mouth, bitting at her bottom lip, and choking her so that she felt my strength, but could still breath.

I felt her tits squish against my chest with each of his thrusts and reached my hand down to play with her clit. I gripped her tight and pulled her by her throat till her ear brushed against my lips. “You love it don’t you you filthy little whore.” She said nothing. “You’re here getting fucked by two guys you barely know while your sweet little bf is back in his room wondering where you are” She fought this idea at first, and pulled away a little so I looked back at Zach “Fuck this fucking bitch harder” he obliged, gripping her sides and upping his tempo. “You love it, cheating on your loving little bitch of boyfriend with us.” “Ye—yess” She eaked out between thrust. “You’re a filthy little slut, and I want you to embrace it and cum for him like one” “Ye—ee—ssss” I told her to look at me, she opened her eyes. “I want you to kiss me the way you kiss your boyfriend, I want to feel it as romantically and as truly as you would with him, at the same time another guy has his cock deep inside you.” She leaned forward and kissed me softly at first, then open her mouth wider and gave me all of the tongue she could. It felt like when I kissed my own gf after a very romantic intimate moment, all while Zach’s balls were slapping up against her. I knew she had finally betrayed herself to me fully, not just physically, but emotionally. Out of nowhere Zach let out a long groan and came into the condom. “No! not yet!” she let out meekly. He stood up, and left the room again.

I stood up and poured us both a strong shot of vodka, I knew even after everything, she would be nervous to take me as well. As I drank to my surprise she dropped to her knees and started blowing me. For the first time my dick was inside her, and whatever stiffness I had lost in the interim since eating her pussy immodestly gushed back into my dick. She was eager to repay me for going down on her, and was nice and loud slurping on it down bellow me. She sucked my balls and jerked me off, looking up at me from under my cock. Not being able to wait any longer, I threw her back onto the floor and spread her legs. I pushed myself onto her but she stopped me. “Condom?” she asked. I sat back up and looked away. “I’m not really into that, those are lifestyles from the school, we can just do oral if its a problem though, I respect it whichever you deicide.” She thought for a second then said “Okay just don’t cum inside me”. Okay I said, struggling to find my rhythm again after the interruption. But looking down at her tight little body and 34dd it didn’t take long, I wrapped my hand around the back of her neck and the other under the small of her back, spit on her pussy, and plunged my eager cock inside her.

She let out an “umph” as i felt her cunt stretch to take my girth, she was so wet and warm, I almost didn’t want to move. But her hands immediately ran up and gripped my ass and pulled me deeper into her. She wrapped her legs around mine and lifter herself up till I could feel my cock stretching her cervix and she yelped. Her nails dug into my back and I felt my cock throb with my increasing heart beat “1….2…3….4…5..6..7..8” inside of her. I dug my teeth into her neck and sucked, thrusting myself forward on the dirty dorm room floor into her. I thrust again, then again, then again, till I had a deep rhythm penetrating far into her. She let her head fall back and moaned with my balls thumping loudly against her, ass cheaks clapping against my body. I propped myself up in pushup position and began really slamming her into the floor, her tits bouncing back and forth so hard the looked like the would her chin. I got so turned on seeing my bare cock slam up inside this filthy little slut who had cheated with not one but two men in the same night. “Play with yourself for me.” I told her. She reached down and started rubbing her clit, 30 second later she came and seized off my dick.
“I didn’t tell you to cum yet” I said angrily, I gripped her throat and slapped her lightly in the face. She said nothing and I guided her into the soft bed.

“If you cum I want you to cum like this.” I mounted her from behind, hand still on her throat, the other for balance. I fucked her doggy as rough as I could, her ass clapping against my body, we were both moaning loudly enough for the whole dorm to hear. Her pussy felt amazing and it only made my appetite for slamming her harder grow. My large balls crashed up against her swollen clit as I choked her harder than ever, both of us grunting like animals. Zack came back in and offered her his dick, but she only meekly attempt to reach out for it before giving up. He sat in the desk chair and stroked himself as he watched us. I lifted one leg up over her so I was doing the “take a knee position” and this reached far deeper into her. Watching her get fucked this way and listening to us grunt together was a little to much for Zach, and he got up and put on shorts and went to the lounge where we heard the tv switch on.

I leaned down to whisper in her ear, “See, he can’t even handle a girl like you” She yelped as I let the next thrust penetrate a bit deeper. “He thought he was the one teaching youthings” I whispered. “But I know better, you’re way beyond him, you’re not some cute little lamb who’s been caught by the big bad wolf.” I reached under and grabbed her tits pulling my shaft up inside her. “You’re the wolf. He’s just a baby, just like your wimp boyfriend.” She started moaning louder. “You’re a filthy little slut. He just wants some pussy, but you’re actually getting off to the fact that you’re cheating aren’t you” “Yesss” She finally answered. “Not only that, you love the fact that you’re so fucking hot you’re taking the two of us from our girlfriends” “YESSS” she said much more loudly than anything else I’d heard from her “YESSS YESS YESS” I picked her ass up and slammed her face into the pillow she was yelling into it now. I crushed her pussy as hard as I’ve ever slammed a girl and reached around and rubbed her clit. The shy quiet version of her was now completely gone and both of us were moaning and grunting at full volume. I felt my cock begin to tingle even more and swell up to its full size, pulsating and veiny ready to blow at any moment. I gripped her roughly by the throat and pulled her up against me as I fucked her close to climax.

Into her ear I finally confessed “I think about you when I fuck my girlfriend.” She turned immediately and kissed me “Thats so FUCKING hot!” She kissed me again. “I’m gunna cum, fucking cum in me James!” she yelled. “You’re mine” I said. A muffled “Yes” scream came through the pillow. I pushed her down and slammed her tiny cunt till my cock swelled up and felt it would burst, holding till I heard her screaming my name and her hips were bucking, then fell into her, wrapped my arms around her as tight as I could and pumped my load deep inside her.

After we made out for like 20 minutes, long passionate stuff until the sex hormones wore off and we remembered where and who we were. Zach came in twice the second time he stayed and it was awkward enough we had to stop. He then got into a huge fight with her and she got mad since the whole thing was his idea, but he said he couldn’t be with her again after seeing her like that. It was pretty unfair, and he just locked her out. She was crying so I took her and we walked to McDonalds and then she calmed down. Then we showered together and fucked fell asleep till 2 the next day. After that she pretty much went back to her bf, but she comes over every now and again to see me not him. :D
Hope you liked!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/8sxtud/mmf_cheating_squared