[MM] I, a straight guy, got propositioned by my friend, also a ‘straight’ guy. (Real)

I’m a straight male, who has never had any sexual feelings for men, urges, or experiences with another guy. Anything, I mean, even been hit on, until recently. My friend, of about a year now, was hanging out at my house. It was just the two of us nothing weird at all, just a totally normal day that we would hang out on. Playing 2K and Madden, typical stuff we do, when, seemingly out of left field he drops a bombshell question on me. Let me say too, that, he identifies as straight as well. He asks, as straight up as it can get, “Hey, man, listen, I know we’re both straight, but, I really like you, and, I really think you’re a good looking guy, so, I just wanna ask, would it be cool with you if I sucked your cock? You don’t have to reciprocate or anything, just, something about you, man, you really turn me on…” I’m genuinely shocked. Like, this is out of nowhere from him. If he’s been dropping hints, I haven’t noticed them and, to reiterate, I am completely blown away by his question. So, naturally, I try to answer as casually and relaxed as possible and very politely and respectfully decline his offer and tell him no, citing the fact that I am straight and that we’re good friends, I don’t wanna make anything weird, or anything. Also noting that I’m very flattered by this and can’t thank him enough for his kind words. He understood completely and asks if I’ll drop this and never mention it again, and also asks if I’ll never tell anyone about this. I, of course tell him he has nothing to worry about, I would never betray his confidence and that this will never leave this room.

So, I called him two days later. I was nervous, a little sweaty, not exactly sure how to go about this. He answered, “Hey, what’s up?”, as if nothing had happened and we kinda just talked about some bullshit for a little bit, just typical us, when, I just went for it. “Hey, man, listen…” I began, “I’ve, uh, been kinda thinking about the other day, and what happened…” I paused. “Actually, I’ve been thinking about what didn’t happen…” I stopped again, waiting to see if I would get a reply. He says, “Go on, I’m listening.” to which I replied, “Well, man, I wanna know if you’d be down to talk about that, here at my house, because, honestly, I haven’t been able to stop thinking about it. I think I’m interested, bro…” I stopped, again, waiting for a reply. He responds, “Listen, I meant what I said. The offer still stands, man, I do like you a lot.” Admittedly, I got goosebumps from that, which made me know all of you are totally right, this is something I need to explore and stuff. So, we set up the day and time he can come over, so we can talk about it and stuff.

So, let me set the scene here. It wasn’t late, but it was definitely dark out, when my friend showed up, right in time. Naturally, when he knocked, I got a little nervous, this was gonna be something super new for me and I assumed him. I opened the door, “Hey, man.” I said, casually, feigning calmness. We exchanged our usual banter after he came in and talked for a while, before we both sat on the couch and started to discuss it.

“So, listen, I wanna say, before this even starts, that, I’m not really interested in going down on you, if that’s okay. It’s just something that doesn’t appeal to me and–” I couldn’t finish before he interrupted me, “Dude, that’s totally fine, I’m not even interested in that, I like pleasing and I wanna please you.” This, of course was a huge relief to me as I responded, “Oh, okay, cool, man, that’s great!” He started this time, saying, “So, actually, I kinda need to come clean, before we do this, just to make sure you’re cool with it…” I responded, “Go on.” He starts again, “So, I’m actually Bi, I just tell most people I’m straight to avoid a lot of bull.” I totally understood this and vocalized, I feel for him and I’m glad he felt comfortable not only telling me, but even coming on to me. “I’ve actually been with two guys, but they were really just hook ups, so, that’s why this is special, because I like you and know you, well.” I was flattered, “Thank you, bro. I like you too. I’m totally fine with you being bi and having been with other guys, it gives you experience!” I laughed a little, attempting to break some of the slight tension. “Well, now that everything seems to be pretty clear, should we start?” I asked, looking into his eyes. “Yeah, man, you wanna kiss a little, first?” he asked, somewhat casual in his response.

I nodded, “Sure…” and then leaned in and kissed him, first lightly, before a little deeper and then a little deeper, before we began to make out. As this kissing went on, my hands, and his, began to wander. Initially starting on his torso, I found my way around to his ass and began to grope it. It felt good, firm, but not too firm, I reared my hand back and slapped it, lightly, through his jeans. My friend seemed to like that as he gasped, slightly, his hand reaching it’s way down to my clothed cock. He began to grope it, semi stroking it through my pants, muttering, “Fuck…” under his breath. “All good?” I asked. “Yeah, just, you’re way bigger than the other guys I’ve been with.” he said with a chuckle.

Okay, so, I’m only gonna say this once, because, I would hate to be “that guy” that talks about the size of his dick the whole time, I’m definitely not the type to brag or anything like that. I have an abnormally large dick, there I said it, that’s the only time, I will say it, however, he said it another time too.

After our short exchange of kissing and talking through the kissing, he places his knees on the cushion of the couch next to mine, head near my lap and hands working to undo my belt and slide my pants off, lifting my hips to assist him. “You can close your eyes and imagine a girl, if you want…” he said, starting to tug at my briefs when I replied, “No, I wanna do this knowing it’s you. That’s the only way I’ll know if it’s really for me.” He chuckled, tugging my briefs all the way off and looking at me, before looking at my almost fully hard cock, “I knew I liked you for a reason.”

He then turned his attention to my cock and reached his hand down to hold it up and slap it against his tongue, several times, before enveloping my head in his mouth, popping off and laughing, “How’s that feel?” he asked confidently, still to my side, I looked down/over at him, goosebumps attacking my skin and said, “Incredible…” He liked that as he began stroking my shaft, slowly while sucking on my head, letting his spit flow down, coating his hand and my shaft, pooling at my balls.

His speed increased and as it did, my heart began to race, as my cock hardened. It felt harder than it had ever been as I reached my hand up and lightly slapped his ass, again, “God that feels so fucking good…” I moaned as he chuckled around my cock, sending vibrations through my shaft. He popped off, making an audible noise and said, “You’ve been touching my ass a bit, you like it?” before diving back in, using the same, one hand stroke twist and suck, what he can, method.

“Fuck yes I do.” I replied. “Fat, but not, ‘fat’ and firm, but not hard. I love your ass.” He popped off my cock again, and slid down onto the floor, on his knees between my legs, while I was seated on the couch. “Well, hold back for now, maybe we’ll save that for another day after you’ve had time to see if this is really for you and process this, not when I’m right in the middle of giving you the best head you’ve ever had. Besides, I’m gonna need some time to prep for your cock, this thing is massive.” he chuckled. His words turned me on all the more, as my cock seemingly hardened even more. My cock fully coated in his spit, my mind and body rushing with blood and lust, he then reached his other hand up to two hand stroke me, while he sucked the rest, moving his two hands and head in motion together.

“Oh my fucking god…” I groaned, “God yes, man, just like that…” I moaned, again. He popped off my cock and still stroking with one hand went down to slurp and suck on my balls, popping off those too, saying, “Yeah, bro? You love this shit, huh? Yeah?” This turned me on so much I said something I didn’t think I would ever say, “God yes, baby, fuck yes, don’t stop.” He raised his eyebrow, sucking on my head and popped off, again, “Oh? ‘Baby’, huh? I’m baby now, huh?” he asked. “Shit, man, my bad…” I replied, worried I had offended. “No, I like it, baby, call me that again.” he said, going back in, this time no hands, bobbing up and down.

“Oh God, baby, yes, yes, yes, just like that, fuck.” I moaned. Then, suddenly, he interrupted his own rhythm by pushing his head down as far as he could, gagging/choking on my cock, pulling off, “Oh, fuck!” he said assertively, going back in and popping off, “God! Would it be okay with you if I got these fucking pants off and stroked my cock?” I replied, “Yeah, baby, that’s fine, just don’t stop.” He unzipped his pants and I could tell he was pulling his cock out, while still stroking mine. He switched hands, I’m assuming to use his lubed up hand to stroke his own cock. “Yeah, baby? Don’t want me to stop, huh?” he asked as he began sucking my balls, again, stroking my cock and his. “God no, baby, do not stop.” I groaned. “Fuck, can I-” he paused, going back on my cock, as deep as he could, choking again. “What’s up?” I asked as he seemed to stop asking his question. “Well, it’s just…” he stopped, after popping off my cock, “Can I call you Daddy?” he asked.

This almost sent me over the edge. “Fuck yes you can.” I responded almost immediately. “Oh fuck, thank you so much, Daddy.” he responded, going back on my cock as far as he could. I almost couldn’t take any more. My balls were boiling I wanted to cum, he has been blowing me for a long while now. “Fuck, baby, I need to cum, soon.” I moaned. “God yes, Daddy cum for me.” he responded. He popped off my cock, and asked, “But, first, can I cum on your cock and then suck that clean, before you do?”

This turned me on, all the more. “Of course, baby.” I responded as he stood and began furiously stroking his cock, close to mine and moaned, “Fuck me!” as he blew his load, right onto my shaft and balls, some hitting my lower stomach. “Fuck.” I groaned as he leaned down, and began licking his own cum from my shaft and lower stomach, then began sucking my balls clean. “Fuck, baby, I need to cum.” I told him, standing up to begin stroking my cock. “I wanna make you cum, Daddy, in my mouth.” he said, as he sucked on my head, only, stroking with both hands, my own helping as well. “Fuck… Fuck!” I groaned, loudly as I could feel my balls erupting. My cum began flowing from my cock, coating his tongue as he swallowed after each rope I blew.

“Fuck!” I groaned again, sitting down my cock still in his mouth. He finally popped off and chuckled, “That was incredible.” he said, sliding onto the couch sitting next to me. “No kidding, bro” I chuckled, looking over at him. “So…” he started, “wanna get your ass whooped in some Madden?” he asked, to my bewilderment. “Only if you blow me again, afterward.” I laughed. He chuckled and responded, “Sure thing, bro.” starting up the game and turning on the TV.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/8p4r5y/mm_i_a_straight_guy_got_propositioned_by_my

11 comments

  1. Straight guy here and damn I’m speechless and rock hard at the same time

  2. So you’ve discovered you’re at least bi, if not gay. Which is okay, but straight you are not. Fair play to you. Have a blast. You’ve just opened up your opportunities for getting laid.

  3. Awesome story. It made me rock hard. Wish I had a friend like that ?

  4. I loved the transition from bro to baby ahaha but good on you man, sounds really hot!

Comments are closed.