She answered [m]y craigslist post, she wanted to film herself sucking and [f]ucking my thick cock. Everything about this supermodel-esque girl felt too good to be true; and yet this one time – it was completely true

In honor of Craigslist taking away their personals section, I thought I’d share this story about the one time I got incredibly lucky there! Never before, never again, and I am still in complete disbelief that this actually happened to me. This is from two years ago.

Looking for casual sex partners online is a veritable mine field. Every “adult” dating site feels like a scam designed to suck cash out of your wallets; even if there are legit girls on them they’re vastly outnumbered by men. Anyone that looks like a model probably is… because a model’s pics are being used by a bot / scammer.

And craigslist is even worse. Most ads are completely fake, and my own ad got more responses from men who seem to think my sexuality could be bought, women I wasn’t attracted to, and some promising flakes – some girls who just stopped messaging, and one girl who arranged a meet and then stood me up entirely. And after I had acquired a “stalker” who threatened me, I was ready to just give it up. It’s dangerous, and anyone I’d actually be interested in would probably be able to easily find sex outside of CL.

And yet… one horny day, I decided to post a new ad anyway. What can it hurt? I don’t expect anything. And then I got a message from a girl who said she was interested, and the pictures she had enclosed were absolutely gorgeous. Supermodel gorgeous. I was immediately wary… and almost didn’t pursue at all when she gave me her phone number, I worried that she could be anyone, even the “stalker” so giving my phone number seemed like a bad idea. But… after talking to her a bit I decided what the heck, I’ll go in with my eyes open, but it’s worth taking a chance.

She wanted to make a video – for herself to watch later and then delete – of her body with a big cock. She had never been with anyone my size before. And… she wanted me to shave. She is here for the summer only, interning, and living in a dorm so she couldn’t verify herself on cam. So I arranged to meet in a public place, for safety. Still I didn’t want to trust that this was real, I’d been burned over and over. I almost called it off entirely.

And then I drove out to the place arranged and met her in the morning after we had chatted for a week, and she was exactly as advertised. A gorgeous brunette, with a cute face, slim toned body, perky breasts, firm ass, long legs and cute toes in jean short-shorts, sandals, and a tight white top. I couldn’t believe my eyes – she was more gorgeous in person, and she wanted to go straight to my bedroom. So now that we had met, I finally gave her my address, and we drove back.

She set up a camera, and wanted me to hold a camcorder while she gave me head. And then suggested we both strip – and I still couldn’t believe my eyes. This girl was physically perfect. She had cute little nipples on the tips of her smallish, but perky breasts, and a flat toned stomach, and beautiful shaved pussy, and just perfect flawless pale skin. I could hardly contain my excitement, which fought with my continued disbelief that this was somehow all completely real.

I really wish she had let me take my own pictures, or have a copy of the video, but she said that for her safety she couldn’t risk them getting out there, and I understand. Wish I had them though, because she was amazing!

We made out on my bed, I sucked her tits, then she gave me head while I recorded her. She couldn’t fit the whole thing in her mouth, but she was really good with her hand… and it didn’t take long for me to give her the money shot (she wanted to be sure she pulled back and caught it in her mouth on camera). I think she’ll be pleased with the results.

I didn’t even lose my erection, and before long I grabbed a condom and we were fucking. She had me lay down, so she could straddle me – and with a bit of difficulty she squeezed me inside. I could tell she was struggling a bit, having never had a larger cock, but she was moaning incredibly loudly. She pleasured herself on me, then turned around to face the camera and continued to fuck me, making herself cum. Then she got up and went to her knees, asking me to fuck her doggy style, and I obliged, slamming in against her ass. After a few minutes of this she started moaning “Yes, right there. Keep going. Keep going!” and I continued to thrust and fuck her until she came again.

I positioned her on her back then, and entered once more, and fucked her until she came yet again… and then pushed me back… that she needed a break. I hadn’t cum yet (not since she sucked me off and got her moneyshot), but we could go again.

Things were a bit quiet for awhile as we made a little small talk (It’s different for me to fuck someone before getting to know them, and honestly was a little awkward), and she packed up the camera, but said we could go again. The second time she was a bit sore though, and after having her on her back, and then flipping her over onto her stomach, she eventually needed me to stop. She sucked me for a long time, but sometimes it’s a curse to be so long lasting – I tired her out. But it was all worth it anyway. I hope she enjoys watching the video she made tonight. I feel like a porn star!

I’m still in disbelief that something that really seemed too good to be true actually happened. What an adventure life can be sometimes!

I don’t mind that Craigslist personals is no more. This was that one needle in a haystack, and I never expected to get lucky that way ever again. But it was the memory of a lifetime!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/8bzsjp/she_answered_my_craigslist_post_she_wanted_to