[mf] She said she didn’t want to have sex on a first date, but ended up begging me to put it in her by the end of the night

I met A for ice cream for our first date. She’s a cute curvy girl, a bit on the thicc side, with green hair and a cute, shy bubbly submissive energy. We instantly bonded over shared geeky interests, and also talked about kinks, and gradually started warming up to each other. I asked if she wanted to come back to my place, and she agreed but said we could play some games but wouldn’t be doing anything sexual today. I agreed to her terms, and she came back to my place.

We started out with several rounds of Mario Kart, sitting side by side on my couch, each stealing glances at the other (she’d blush whenever I noticed her looking at me and act all shy about it. It was cute!) Afterwards, since she is a fan of Magic, I taught her my favorite card game Dominion, and we played a couple rounds of that. After the second round I commented that I really felt a submissive energy from her, and asked her if I could kiss her. She squeaked a yes, and I stood up – and felt awkward hovering over her, so she stood too, and I kissed her. I asked if I could smack her ass, and she said “yes please”, and removed her phone from her back pocket to give me better access. I gave her a few good spanks, and she moaned deliciously. At this point we both agreed there was definitely good chemistry here, but she reiterated that she didn’t want to have sex on a first date, so we decided to put in another videogame, and went back to the sofa and put in Super Smash Bros. Before starting, I reclined my side, and said she could join me – and she came in close and cuddled up to me.

She answered [m]y craigslist post, she wanted to film herself sucking and [f]ucking my thick cock. Everything about this supermodel-esque girl felt too good to be true; and yet this one time – it was completely true

In honor of Craigslist taking away their personals section, I thought I’d share this story about the one time I got incredibly lucky there! Never before, never again, and I am still in complete disbelief that this actually happened to me. This is from two years ago.

Looking for casual sex partners online is a veritable mine field. Every “adult” dating site feels like a scam designed to suck cash out of your wallets; even if there are legit girls on them they’re vastly outnumbered by men. Anyone that looks like a model probably is… because a model’s pics are being used by a bot / scammer.

And craigslist is even worse. Most ads are completely fake, and my own ad got more responses from men who seem to think my sexuality could be bought, women I wasn’t attracted to, and some promising flakes – some girls who just stopped messaging, and one girl who arranged a meet and then stood me up entirely. And after I had acquired a “stalker” who threatened me, I was ready to just give it up. It’s dangerous, and anyone I’d actually be interested in would probably be able to easily find sex outside of CL.