[MFM],[Bi] Our First Threesome

My wife and I have been talking about opening up romantically or otherwise inviting others into our bed for a year or so. In the realm of polyamory, we are a rare and fabled pairing of a Unicorn and a Pegasus.

My wife is tall (5’8″), long brunette hair, trimmed downstairs, B cups, long legs, and an ass that I love. Her carpet matches the drapes. I’m 6’0″, 200lbs, at the beginning stages of a dad-bod. I’m clean shaven (my face, I trim my bush), brown/blonde hair. I’m also rare on Reddit in that I am entirely average downstairs, with a slight upward curve (sorry, no 8.5 inch massive dong here).

We had never been in a legitimate threesome before (she had a petting and make out session with two other women – a story suitable for r/hotpast). After a lot of talking, and fantasizing, we reached a point where we decided to create profiles on OK Cupid. We were looking primarily for friends in the LGBTQ / poly communities, with the potential for more than friendship.

My wife had already been with another woman, and knew she was bi. I had never been with a guy, but was definitely bi-curious. I was open to her talking to either gender.

She found a woman who turned into a flake. Then, she found a guy. There seemed to be some similar interests and hobbies between all three of us, so we arranged a meeting over dinner on a Saturday.

I thought it was a bit of an awkward meeting, but the guy seemed personable enough. There definitely seemed to be the potential for friendship.

He’s about 5’8″, and 160lbs, some tattoos, bald head and a goatee.

Later that next week, I had to be away for work overnight. During, my wife asked if she could get dinner with the new guy. During her dinner, I kept in contact with her through texts. She spent a few hours with him, and got home late. She admitted that she felt an attraction to him, and that this might go into more than just friends. My wife found out that he had been in an open relationship before, and was also bicurious, but had never been with a man either. He’s just as interested in trying man on man action as I am.

The second person my wife talks to on Ok Cupid is showing all the markings of another Pegasus…

We started a messenger conversation with him, where we discussed a whole bunch of various topics, and they all rapidly turned sexual. Mentions of sex between all three of us started happening, in graphic and lurid detail. No pairing was left out – though they mostly focused on the three of us.

We didn’t meet up with him in person again for another week. The sexting had continued. My wife ramped it up by sending some pics suitable for r/gonemild. I may have encouraged that… Before you perverts ask, she doesn’t want them online, and no – I won’t PM them.

The three of us finally decided on meeting up for a midweek dinner almost two weeks after our first meeting. We found a Chinese place, but we got there 30 minutes before closing (I felt bad…). With all the awkwardness of overt sexual tension among introverted acquaintances, and the host standing 10 feet away from the table for the entire meal we had some ok conversation. My wife was blushing a lot – either through some gentle teasing or reminders of the explicit conversation, I don’t know.

Because of the complete awkwardness of the last meeting, we invited him to our place on the following Sunday (Sept 17th). The plan was to hang out, play games, eat dinner. My wife said Netflix and Chill. But no sex and that oral counts as sex, and it definitely wasn’t happening. She’d be ok with some touching. Maybe kissing.

He showed up after running some errands, and we got into welcoming him. We set up a few games and played through them, before I took a two hour break with an errand of my own.

I left them to play a card game (it’s magic – literally). When I finished up with what I was doing, I rejoined them. They were playing footsie under the table.

After finishing up the game, she was feeling really warm. We live in South Texas – it’s ridiculous, even with the AC sometimes. She headed into the bedroom to change into something cooler – a cutoff shirt.

We made decided to go to the couch to catch up on the Marvel shows (we are behind… still on Iron Fist). Prior to starting the show, my wife decided to have a margarita. Tequila makes her really, really horny. She knows it.

She sat in the middle. About ten minutes in, her feet were on his lap, and she was leaning into me. I like to touch – it’s my love language. So, I start rubbing her shoulder. He started rubbing her legs. She gets a bit sensitive and ticklish. The rubbing proceeded to happen for almost a complete episode.

I leaned forward just a bit, and I see her hand deep into his crotch. I start moving my hand to her chest. She wasn’t wearing a bra. In her low cut and sleeveless cutoff. My wife wanted to be fucked.

During this, the petting and rubbing got a lot more intense. His hand and mine eventually found each other. Eventually, I escalate the situation more by pulling his hand onto her right breast.

Kissing starts happening. She’s actively rubbing his cock over his shorts. He’s trying to rub mine through my jeans, as is my wife. She makes the comment that I should get into shorts. So I do. As I get up, I push her more onto him so they are making out.

When I come back, she’s rubbing, and biting him over his shorts… So I start pulling his waistband… She licked her hand and grabbed his bare cock.. then went down on it. It’s a really nice cock… It may have a bit more girth than mine, but we are similarly sized.

I’m behind her, as she’s basically on all fours on the couch with a cock in her mouth. So I start pulling down her pants and undies and start fingering her. She starts moaning on his cock, I pull my fingers out and put them into his mouth as I enter her from behind.

He kicks his shorts off, I take mine off. I start working her pants off as I can, while still thrusting inside of her. I take a break, pull her pants the rest of the way down, and start pushing her up towards him.

As she makes her way up, I take him in my mouth. It’s the first time I’d ever touched another man’s cock in a non-medical way. I liked it. I’m definitely not curious about being bisexual anymore.

With his cock wet from my mouth, she sits and takes him inside of her in a seated cowgirl position… And he starts fucking her.

We swap positions, and he returns the favor of going down on me. And she takes my cock again. The three of us devolve into making out with each other, everyone but my wife receiving oral from everyone…

There was one instance where she was on him cowgirl, and I just sat back, watching his cock work it’s way inside of my wife, with her lips gripping and pulling on his shaft, while her wetness coated him, his balls, down to the couch. It was all so fucking hot.

I stood up, putting my cock near his mouth, where he sucked it for just a moment. He then pushed my wife onto her back on the couch, and entered her missionary – tossing one of her legs over his shoulder. While he was pounding into her in a steady rhythm, I was placing my cock on her lips, then on his where they would both suck in turn.

It gets to the point where I see the clock and the time… I position my wife doggy style with him inside of her, and her sucking my cock. He starts pounding inside of her, gripping her hips the way she likes (I told him what she likes). I tell him to fuck her until he cums. Which he does without warning… pounding deep inside of my wife. She came with him.

I spin her around, putting her on her back. I notice a bit of his cum on her labia, and lick her freshly fucked and cum filled pussy. I then slide inside of her, using his cum as lube. She cums again on the first deep stroke. I tell him I want his cock. He puts it inside of my mouth, where I suck him clean. I pound my wife in missionary until I cum inside of her, giving her the second load of the night. As I cum, I pull my mouth from him, and kiss her deeply.

I’m supposed to go out with him soon, on our own 1on1 date. The three of us are already making sleepover plans..

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/723all/mfmbi_our_first_threesome