Sex with a girl while her religious friend watched [MF]

I’ve recently gotten some requests to repost this story. I posted it from this account about a year ago, but it seems to have disappeared. I think it was due to a grammatical edit I tried to make recently and change of tagging requirements in the title since the original posting date. Anyways, here it is:

***Like I’ve said in previous posts. I figured it would be fun to go back to my promiscuous (man-whore) days and recall some of the stories from back then. I’m generally considered a good-looking guy (used to model, 6’3”, dark hair, blue eyes, swimmers build, workout regularly), so that enabled me to have quite a fun sex life. These stories are 100% true and not embellished in any way. I think that a straight honest story even if not as exciting at times is a bigger turn on, so that is what I will continue to try to give.***

I had known Katie for a few months. We originally met at a party of some mutual friends, but didn’t connect that night. I was actually there with another girl, but that was short-lived. Social media served as the conduit through which we connected, which led to us hanging out and hooking up for a time. Katie was 20 years old and about 5’6″ with blonde hair, green eyes, and she kind of reminded me of Rachel McAdams. She was in shape and had C cup tits with a ridiculous ass.

We would typically hang out about once a week, but occasionally more. Our time together typically consisted of her coming to my place or me going to hers for late night hookups, but there were times the nights were more substantial. She would come over early sometimes to drink and watch movies. It was all very laid back and there was no pressure for any larger sort of commitment.
One night about 3 months into us hooking up she asked if I could have a guy at my place for her friend to hangout with. I asked her who the girl was and she said it was her friend Lilly. She described Lilly as cute, but not a knockout. She also provided the disclaimer that Lilly was pretty religious, so I should make sure the guy knows not to expect anything. I asked why she had to bring her and she told me that the two of them had been friends for a long time and Lilly had recently gone through a tough break-up. She wanted to be there for her and hangout with her as much as possible. I really wasn’t too happy about Lilly coming over. I hate trying to set people up and I definitely didn’t want to try to set one of my friends up and then have to tell him he definitely wouldn’t get any action. Makes it kind of hard to get the guy too excited about the whole thing.

I managed to get my friend Kyle to come over and sacrifice his night. Kyle was kind of a freak, but I told him he really had to tone it down with this girl. I really wanted to get someone less aggressive, but he was the only guy I could convince to come over on such short notice. I think in the back of his mind he still thought he was going to score with this girl.

The girls came over and we got introductions out of the way. Lilly was about what Katie had described. She was cute, but not a knockout. She was about 5’4” slim, medium length reddish-brown hair, B cup tits, average ass, sort of plain looking, very girl next door. She looked sort of like a much plainer and average Amy Adams. When the girls weren’t looking Kyle laid his palm flat and shook it back and forth so as to signal that Lilly was “Ok.” I nodded in agreement and smiled. We all decided to have some drinks, well everyone except for Lilly. She said that she didn’t really drink. Katie wasn’t lying when she said there would be no action had with Lilly. We all talked and had a good time. Lilly was quiet, but she was very sweet and kind of funny when she did speak. I grew to like her and didn’t mind her hanging out. Originally I thought she might totally kill the fun, but I realized that was shortsighted of me.

Later in the night Katie and I snuck away to my bedroom to have sex. That left Lilly and Kyle alone, which could have been dicey, but I felt confident Lilly could handle the situation. After Katie and I finished up, she and Lilly left. I asked Kyle how it went and he gave the thumbs down. He was drunk and passed out a few minutes later on my couch. Katie told me the next day that Kyle tried to put some moves on Lilly and she wasn’t having it. Apparently they kissed a couple of times, which surprised me, but that was the extent of it.

Lilly came over to my place with Katie a few more times, but told me she was cool with just hanging with us without Kyle. I guess she didn’t want to continue to fight him off. We always had a good time and would just bullshit and watch movies. Katie and I would always hook up towards the end of the night and Lilly would just chill and watch TV in the living area while we were in the bedroom. She was less and less shy each time we would hangout, which was a good thing because she was pretty cool.

One night I sent a text to Katie kind of late in the night and asked if she could come over. I had been out with some people and was hoping to hookup with her. She told me that she was already kind of in for the night and that her and Lilly are just chilling. She said I could come over there if I wanted. I typically didn’t like going to Katie’s place, because she still lived with her mom so it could be awkward at times. However, I wasn’t interested in turning her down. I told her it was fine and that I would head over.

I got there and her and Lilly had just started a movie. Lilly and Katie were both lying on their stomachs with their heads at the end of the bed facing the TV. I kicked off my shoes and decided to sit down at the head of the bed with my back against the headboard. They were both wearing athletic shorts, so I didn’t mind the view, especially the view of Katie’s ass. We sat there watching the movie and I kept dozing off. Katie would kick me to wake me up. After having to kick me a few times she slid up beside me and told me she was going to have to keep a closer eye on me. We continued watching the movie, but now anytime I looked sleepy Katie would lightly kiss my neck or tease me by lightly running her hand over my crotch. I couldn’t tell exactly, but I don’t think Lilly noticed any of this.

By the end of the movie Katie and I were making out. I know Lilly noticed. She even glanced back a couple of times, but she would just turn back and continued to watch TV. Once the movie was over she just continued to flip channels. Things were getting more intense and I wasn’t sure exactly what to do. Lilly did not seem like the type that would be into getting freaky like this, so I figured I would just follow Katie’s lead. Katie lifted my shirt and began kissing my stomach. I caught Lilly peeking again. She didn’t seem to be looking in disgust or anything. It was more of a look of curiosity. I figured Katie was just fucking with her to try to make her uncomfortable and this would stop in a minute.

Katie continued to kiss and lick up and down my stomach and chest. Katie then took off her shirt revealing the bra she had on underneath. I reached inside the cup of her bra and caressed her nipples. Katie then began rubbing my crotch and after a few moments unbuckled my belt buckle. My cock was raging hard. The situation was intense and not knowing what Lilly’s reaction would be in any moment was making it more exciting and turning me on. I unsnapped Katie’s bra and began sucking on her nipples. Lilly’s head was turned completely to the side now in a full on gaze. She looked back at the TV after a few moments and continued to flip channels, but made no move to get up and leave the room. Katie didn’t seem interested in stopping either. She reached down and pulled my underwear and pants down revealing my raging hard cock. She took it in her hand and began to stroke it. Lilly gave a quick glance right at this moment and looked back at the TV continuing to frantically flip channels.

As many signals as Lilly was giving that she wasn’t going to leave the room she was also not giving any signals that she was going to join either. She seemed content to just observe. Katie took my cock in her mouth and began to slowly suck up and down. Lilly heard the sounds of Katie’s wet lips and tongue going up and down on my cock. Lilly turned and locked in a long gaze again. Katie slid off her shorts and panties and straddled my cock. I grabbed onto her hips and guided her down onto me. There was no turning back now. Lilly seemed to be all in on watching me and Katie fuck. Katie rode me quickly slamming up and down on my cock. I guided her down and thrust back up into her as she slammed down each time in perfect rhythm. Lilly wasn’t looking away anymore. She had turned over on her back and was watching each thrust. After a while I flipped Katie over onto her back and slid my cock in her pussy. I started slow, but worked up to a feverish pace. I began pounding her hard and she let out moans and shook as she began to orgasm.

At this point Lilly had her legs clinched tight together with her hand between them on her crotch lightly rubbing her pussy from outside her shorts with her fingers. I glanced at Lilly as I was sliding in and out of Katie and gave her a look as if to ask if she wanted to join. She said in a light whisper as she rubbed herself, “I can’t.” I knew it was unlikely, but I wanted to give it a shot.
I flipped Katie over onto all fours. I grabbed onto her beautiful ass and slid my cock back in her from behind. I angled her to where Lilly had a good view and we were only a couple of feet away from her. I slid slowly in and out of Katie grabbing and spreading her ass cheeks apart. Then Lilly muttered something and moaned before sliding her shorts just slightly to the side and plunging two fingers into her pussy. She began frantically sliding them in and out as she watched my cock slide in and out of Katie. I picked up the pace and began pounding Katie’s pussy from behind. Her ass shook and jiggled with each thrust. She was letting out stifled moans as she tried to cover them with her pillow. Lilly was watching intently and continued to furiously fuck herself with her fingers. I had the slightest view of her pussy lips from where I was at, but it was tough to see much. The whole thing was too much and I felt my orgasm coming on. I pulled out of Katie and started shooting cum on her left ass cheek. Lilly was just to my left and her eyes were fixated on me. In a split second decision I felt like Lilly wanted it, so I turned towards her and shot my last couple of streams of cum on her neck and across her mouth. Luckily it seemed I guessed right and she began fingering herself even harder than before and rubbing across her clit. Her whole body was shaking and she tensed up and quickly orgasmed. Katie was just lying there on the bed catching her breath. Lilly licked her lips tasting a few drops of my cum.

I went and got a towel for both of them. We cleaned up and Lilly headed into the bathroom. She stayed in there for a while. I think she was a little embarrassed and didn’t want to come out until after I left. I only stayed about five more minutes and told Katie bye. Katie confirmed later what I thought and said Lilly was embarrassed, but that she couldn’t stop talking about it that night. She said she acted embarrassed, but kept asking Katie questions about it and bringing it up. She told her she would kill her if she ever told anyone about it.

Katie and I hooked up for about two more months after that. I saw Lilly a few more times in that timeframe, but she always acted like what happened that night didn’t happen. I never wanted to make her feel weird, so I made a point to never bring it up either.

***Also, if you are a female and live near me you should send me a message. Might be a longshot, but would be cool/interesting to have sex with someone that enjoys my stories and then becomes a story haha***

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5hlxvs/sex_with_a_girl_while_her_religious_friend