Cumming inside a fertile pussy, invited or not, is my fetish. I also enjoy girls who swallow. What I don’t like is cumming outside, but I sometimes deposit the second half of my load just outside, so the creampie is “expected” and less likely to freak the girl out. However, when I was a novice, unless the girl had BC, I either used condoms or pulled out. The first time I creamed an unprotected girl was unintentional: a busted condom. But this is the story of the first time I creamed an unprotected girl bareback. We were parked near a beach and making out in the front seat of my sport car (no back seat to speak of). I had already got her panties off and I was fingering her. She was wet and she was stroking my dick, but when I pushed her head down to suck me off, she resisted and said, “Do you have a blanket? Let’s go outside.” We did that, I laid her on her back, dropped my pants and I had to decide whether to use a condom or not, so I asked, “Do you have anything against children?” meaning, I thought, “Do you have protection?” She said, “Yes!” I said, “OK,” and proceeded to enter her without a condom. She was very wet and not very tight so it went in smoothly but then she just lay there while I was pumping, which was a little disappointing. Nonetheless, her pussy was warm and still pleasant and I proceeded to cream her soon thereafter. I am not very vocal and apparently she did not realize I was cumming, especially considering that I continued to pump while ejaculating. After a few more strokes, I pulled out and she might have thought I came outside. Then I asked, “What type of BC are you using?” She said, “None.” I said, “But you said you have something against children!” She responded, “Yes, I do. I don’t want children yet.” At that moment, I was actually worried she might get pregnant, but I was not going to tell her I came inside. Instead, I said, “It’s good that I did not cum inside you but perhaps it will be better if you douche because of the precum.” She nodded and I took her home to do that. I never called her again and never heard from her either, so probably she did not conceive. Upon reflection later, however, the thought that I might have knocked her up turned me on and was a milestone on my pursuit of natural insemination opportunities.