Unfortunately there isn't much for setting the scene to this story. We had time home alone and it had been so long since we had any sort of intimate fun that we immediately snuck off to the bedroom after her parents left. In hindsight I could tell she was more excited than usual, but at the time I didn't think anything of it.
When I walked into her room, she immediately pulled out a surprise for me. Two satin blindfolds in typical male/female colors, pink and blue. "I was thinking we could try being blindfolded for once." she said. Immediately I was on board with the idea and naturally asked, "who goes first?" She came over and wrapped her arms around me and asked me what my preference was. Out loud I weighed the decision; If I were blindfolded, I would love the anticipation of wondering what she'd do next or where her hands were going next and being surprised by the spontaneous sensations. If she put the blindfold on, I could have full control of the situation by not giving her any sort of hints as to what I was gonna do, and be able to see her awkwardly reaching out and reacting to something that may not even be happening. It was a tough decision to make on the spot.