This is story #2 and happened about 15 years ago. Still remember it like it was yesterday as this story is bat shit crazy. Now I know we are on the internet but I have to say this is all 100% true.
I was a lead singer of a local band at the time and we played the same dive bar every Sunday night. We ran an open mic night and we would get the usual Sunday crowd to have a good time. We got paid $200 to play and drink all the alcohol we could manage on top of that. Not a bad gig for some younger guys. This night an old friend from High school showed up with some of her friends. We will call her “Jenny” for story purposes. We had sex a few times our senior year but never really dated. She always said that I fucked her so good she couldn’t stay away too long.
My band played our set and I could see her staring at me the whole time. My guitar player knew our history and just gave me the look after the set knowing what might happen. I got everything set for the open mic and told the guys I was going to pop outside really quick.