[MFM] My (29M) Wife (27F) just had our second threesome, with effectively a stranger

So I’ve been into the idea of my wife having sex with other men for about 4 years (in the Hotwife way, not the Cuckold way). I dwelled on this for about six months before sharing it with my wife, and we talked about it for another 6 before we decided to give it a try the first time (3 years ago). Two nights ago, we dipped our toes back into the water, and this is the story. To make things easier, here are some descriptions up front:

* Me: 5’8″, 180lbs, just over 6″ cut. Brown hair, beard. Not fat, not thin, bit of a dad bod.
* My Wife: 5’10”, 140lbs, wavy light brown hair down to her shoulders, pale, great figure, DD cup.
* New Friend: 6’0″, 190lbs, about 6″ cut (but very thick), light brown short hair, broad shoulders, pretty muscular with a bit of softness around the edges.

 

We made a post on our local R4R subreddit, and were immediately hit with dozens of replies, but quickly narrowed it down and started talking to one guy in particular. He seemed normal, and had a lot of interests in common with us, so we decided to meet up for a drink, and if all went well, we’d make plans for something more fun.