Background: I’m 31 M (James), partner is 28 F (Sam). We’ve been dating for 3 years. I’m from the city and she’s from a small rural town that I hadn’t even heard of until I met her.
She’s always been pretty vanilla but recently got her telling me stories about her with other guys. Turns out she has slept with quite a few men (lots of one night stands) but not many real exciting times. Just drunk one night stands mainly.
Through more probing though, she opened up about this one guy (Mike) who she used to fuck on a regular basis. Mike is 11 years older than Sam. He was a guy from the same town who moved to the city but anytime he was home and she was single, they would hook up.
Sam goes on to tell me that Mike was the best she had ever had (she says before me but could be just saving my feelings lol), he was the first to make her cum during sex and the fact that he was older was a big thrill. She says it’s been a few years since they saw each other but she does creep his Facebook every so often.