Longtime lurker here, but I felt like I had to post this recent experience for me. First, a little about me and the ladies. I’m 25, 6ft, dark hair, nothing too special, but my charm definitely helps me hit out of my league. Sheila is 27, shy, and reminds me of Cersei Lannister in terms of hair and build. Layla is 24, your typical basic girl, blonde hair, great ass, etc but LOVES to be dominated.
Now on to the story. I met Sheila rock climbing, we hit it off, and decided to meet up for drinks one night instead of climbing. One thing led to another and we were back at my place doing giving each other oral. I was raised Christian so I always held off on PIV before marriage (also felt like I wasn’t ready to be a dad either and this prevented that). I told myself though, if I had the chance to have a threesome it would have been a clear enough message from God that I was meant to go for it. Sheila and I kept this up from time to time until she called me one day practically in tears. She apologized and told me we had to stop because felt like she was a lesbian. Aside from the fantastic blowjobs, I really cared for Sheila and knew how difficult it was for her to tell me all this. We talked about what it meant for our friends-with-benefits relationship and ways I could encourage her through her self-discovery. She said it was probably best that we stop hooking up while she figured things out. I agreed, but we decided to keep climbing with each other (it’s hard to find a good climbing partner!).