First experience with a complete stranger [m/f]

I’d like to preface this story by thanking many previous contributors to this sub. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed reading about your real-life experiences. Also, just an FYI to those writing fiction here – it’s pretty obvious. The following is absolutely true with as many details as I can clearly remember. Throwaway username for obvious reasons if you read the story.

I never intended to hook up with a complete stranger. Sure, it had been a passing fantasy of mine, but I never thought I would act on it or even have the opportunity to do so. First, a little background on me.

I grew up in a very conservative, religious setting. I was taught to save myself for marriage and, believe it or not, did so without much trouble. My peers and schoolmates (I attended a very small, religious, private school), both guys and girls, were taught the same as I was. I’m not saying there was never any sexual tension, but the fear of someone finding out and the related shame it would have caused me and my family was enough to keep me on the straight and narrow. My sole sexual experiences when I got married at 20 was through some limited porn and one time feeling up an older woman’s boobs (not my girlfriend) while watching a movie. Once I was married, of course, my wife and I had a great time learning with each other and gaining experience. I can’t really compare our sex life to anything because I’ve never had an ongoing sexual relationship with anyone else and I still have never had PIV sex with anyone else. Nevertheless, our sex life was/is very satisfactory and, we both have healthy sex drives.