This is a situation I never thought I would see myself in I guess. We’ve been dating for a little over a year and a half and for the first 6ish months I did not know about the other girl, but she knew about me the whole time. They have been together for about 4 years and met in college. I met him on Tinder.
He told me (it wasn’t me finding out) and I was pretty upset, obviously, and I told him I needed some time to think about all of this. When he told me, he had phrased it in a way that he wanted to continue the relationship, but with me and his other girlfriend (her name is Natalie and my name is Katie if that makes it easier) both knowing about each other and receiving equal attention.
We took a break for a few weeks, and even though it was super weird situation, I still found myself missing him. Honestly I guess I didn’t consider it cheating as much since he told me instead of me finding out if that makes sense. I called him and we had a long talk and I decided to give it a try.