Our next threesome was only a couple months after the first. This time a young woman responded to one of our Craigslist ads. We’ll call her Claire and she was much prettier in her photos than the first girl. She was around our age and had been with women before, unlike the first girl. We made plans for her to come over one evening and, feeling a bit more prepared, waited for that evening to arrive.
Claire showed up and sat outside with us while we smoked. We all got to know each other a bit and we really clicked with Claire. Turns out we were all regulars at the same hole-in-the-wall pub. Small fucking world!
We moved inside and I offered Claire a drink. Claire and I went in the kitchen so I could make Cheri a drink as well. I let Claire go in front and turned back around to a wide smile and a thumbs up from Cheri, who was clearly much happier with this one. Claire and I chatted in the kitchen a few minutes while we made drinks. She was bent over the counter and, feeling much braver than last time, I reached down and gave her ass a squeeze. She arched her back and let out a little moan while I groped her ass.