**Read First:** If you haven’t already read my other post, I’d suggest glancing at it as the story includes some background on me and Nicole, as well as the first “cuckolding” experience that she did to me. This story will be so much better with the context of the other story. [Other post link.](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/oiazfl/how_i_developed_a_cuckold_fetish_with_my_ex_mf/)
Nicole’s birthday was coming up and I wanted to get her something sexual. I thought about lingerie but ended up making the decision to ship her a butt plug from Amazon. You’ve probably seen those gem butt plugs before, that’s what I bought for her in a medium size. When we were together, she never liked having her ass played with and we certainly never got to try anal.
She texted me when she opened the package laughing about the “gag” gift I had sent her. I tried to play it off like it was a joke and she should like it since it was her favorite color (pink). She laughed and said she’d have to pick out matching panties when she wears it.