Inadvertently having a one-night stand with a professional athlete [FM]

PREFACING this by saying unfortunately I cannot include a lot of the details that makes this story hilarious to me, for the sake of privacy. I will say that the participating party is an active player in one of the big four North American sports leagues (NFL, NBA, NHL, MBA). I know a lot of girls bag pro athletes regularly for clout, so this story isn’t meant to be impressive, just funny. I am pretty private about who I fuck and will not be giving that information out to anyone. This happened years ago and we never spoke after that night.

My junior year of college was like a Renaissance period of one-night stands for me. I lived for having sex with someone I’d never have to talk to again. Okay, so they might potentially end up in my next semester English class (lesson learned) but they also might be a 35 year old in a downtown highrise. I was exploring my craft.

My friend dragged me to her boyfriend’s frat one night, which I was pretty neutral toward. I could usually get away with minimal “party” time and maximal drinking free alcohol and smoking free weed while watching tv time. I also didn’t have a soul to impress, so I would throw on a t-shirt and legging and never bother with make-up.

somehow i [F] ended up being used by two older couples [group]

I’ve been wanting to tell this story but always found it a little overwhelming to recall the whole thing.

Anyway, I always had friends older than me growing up, and when I was in college sometimes I’d just need to escape to the city and see some older, more sane, friends. These particular friends had been dating since they were in high school, did long distance going to college and now were living together in a city apartment while they raise their cats and plants (like essentially my dream). April has been my friend since I was in middle school and was pretty close with Marcus too. She was more outgoing, really friendly while he was more reserved and kind of nervous. But they’re both cute and both have a lot of sex.

April told me when they moved to the city they started going to these swinger parties and invited me as their guest to one. I had had my share of “accidental” threesomes and one orgy so I was like, very excited to have planned group sex.

the time a frat boy had me begging him to fuck my ass [MF]

Joe was like, a very stereotypical frat guy. I had met him at some party in college and we started hooking up pretty regularly. We had mutual friends and we both weren’t looking for anything other than a friends with benefits kinda deal. He wasn’t the brightest crayon in the box, nor did he have any interests other than sports, business school, and being a frat star, but it was really good no strings attached sex.

After fucking a few times, we started talking about what we were into and what we liked. He said he really liked anal, which surprised me at the time but looking back, duh. I probably told him I liked to be choked and called a whore or something.

Anyway, I’d only had bad anal experiences at this point. But he never pushed it or asked for it after he told me that, didn’t even come close to my butthole. Honestly, I was a little offended. Like did he not want to put it in my butt? Was my asshole ugly? But mostly it just piqued my growing curiousity.