[MF] Submissive girl I met on Craigslist gets her asshole filled with cum for the first time

A few weeks ago, I was browsing through the lovely corner of the internet that is the casual encounters section of Craigslist. I’ve had a handful of successes on Craigslist, the trick is to just sound like a real human and prepare for 99% of the responses to be either robots or people who are clearly lying about who they are.

I came across this one post that said she was looking to be used, and it didn’t follow any of the clear spam bot formulas. I sent her a brief description of myself, a picture, and a link to the part 1 of my last story as an example to show her what my definition of “using her” was. She responded back to me, and we ended up going back and forth for a while about things she was interested in trying. We traded numbers, and started chatting a bit more explicitly.

I came inside a much younger girl I met on Craigslist, part 2 [MF]

Part 1 here: https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/5zy3j7/i_came_inside_a_much_younger_girl_i_met_on/

Since I left off with my cum dripping out of this girl 12 years younger than me (we exchanged clean STD tests, and I know that’s still stupid), you can imagine that this part of the story doesn’t take long to get heated. All the build up and release of part one is a hard act to follow, but this is what happened next.

We collapse on the bed, my cum is still dripping out of her pussy and all over the plug that’s still in her ass. She rubs it into and around her freshly fucked pussy and says something like “holy fucking shit… I haven’t been fucked like that since… I was like 18.” Which I quickly realize was only three years ago, but the tone of her voice made it feel like a great compliment.

I forget what we start taking about, some kind of idle chit chat about the last guy she was with, I don’t remember exactly. But at some point I ask her to tell me, in detail, about the filthiest sex she ever had. She is just about to start taking when I say, “but tell me while you’re sucking my cock”. I need to find the video that gave me this idea, because it’s fucking incredible, and it was every bit as hot in real life.

I came inside a much younger girl I met on Craigslist [MF]

I know what you’re thinking right off the bat, it probably wasn’t the best idea, but I’ll just tell the whole story and then you can decide if I was an idiot or not.

I’ve had a few successes on Craigslist before, so I’ll browse it from time to time just to see what’s out there. I think I sent out maybe 10 messages that night, and the one I got a response to I honestly thought was spam at first. I don’t remember it exactly, but it was only a couple of sentences and said something like “Let’s start 2017 on a high note. Oh, and I don’t have a gag reflex :)”. Her ad said she was 24 and was tall, not a huge amount of info. I was 33 at the time.

Usually anything that short and overt has to be spam, but I have a throwaway email I use for this, so who cares, I figure. Within maybe 2 minutes of sending it, I get another message saying “here’s my number, text me before someone reports my ad as spam and it gets taken down”. This still sounds like what a spammer would say, but I’m pretty suggestible at this point, so I figure “fuck it, why not”. I send her a text, and she answers immediately. We chat a bit, which is further than I suspect a spammer would take things, and I ask her to send me some pictures, and she does.