A little backstory – we met Faye through my girlfriend's work. She was the one who introduced us to open relationships, which we happily adopted, but then she broke up with her boyfriend. Faye moved away for a bit, but every so often would come back and have crazy sex with my girlfriend and I. We would also each fuck Faye individually in our own special ways. When Faye moved back to town, she stayed with us for two weeks. That is when this short story takes place.
I was lying back on the bed in our living room, to which the front door opens, knowing that there was a chance Faye would walk in. I think she was on a date or something with this virgin-y sort of guy. She would usually go fuck him, and then come home to us for her real satisfaction. On this particular night, I had my Fleshlight going, and I was jerking it to some kinky BDSM porn with Veronica Avluv. I was completely naked (except for the Fleshlight on my cock).