Two girls in the same night… kinda. A funny story of sex gone wrong, but then right! [MF] [MF] (long)

This story happened a long time ago, but it’s funny enough to share. My writing style tends to get a little long so I’ll mark the beginning of the sexy stuff with dashes across the page.

The story involves four people; Rachel, Lauren, Anthony and myself. Anthony and myself were both early 20s, the girls were both 20. Quick descriptions:

Rachel – average height (5’5”ish), proportionate weight (maybe 130ish) C cups, good curves, blonde hair just a little past shoulder length

Lauren – short (5’2”ish) tiny (maybe 105ish), a cups with a cute little ass and long blonde hair.

Anthony – 6’3” 220, very muscular gym regular, light brown hair

Me – 6’ even 185, not as big as Anthony but I was in great shape at the time (before I evolved into my current dad bod) ??‍♂️

Ok, on the the story.

Anthony and I had just finished up a slow pitch softball game and decided to stop by the bar on the way home and have a few cold ones with some of our teammates. We had won a close game against a team we had never beat and were in celebration mode. We were both in the last year of college and pretty broke, but my boss said he was picking up the tab so we knew it was about to get wild.