Threesome [MMF] Takes an Unexpected Turn

After a break up, I was exploring all my dating options including browsing Craigslist occasionally. Without any luck at parties, I spent a little more time on the site, but the lack of real women lead me to search in the mw4m section. One day I came across a couple with a few photos of a gorgeous girl. She had a tight body, smaller perky breasts and green eyes. I don’t remember if they included a photo of him or not. I sent them an email with my stats and what I was into while I jacked out to her photos. They responded and said they were interested so after a few initial emails of feeling each other out, we decided to meet up that weekend.

I drove over to their apartment and was met by him downstairs. He was about my height, wearing gym shorts with a little bit of a stubble (I’m 5’10 and a swimmer). We had a beer or two together to make sure we were both normal and set ground rules. It was straight forward and we made quickly made rapport with one another.