Loosing [M]y virginity to a girl [F]rom church

I’ve been a lurker for quite a while on r/gonewildstories and I’ve had quite a lot of time on my hands the last few weeks ~~as I’m sure plenty of you have as well~~ so I’ve been reading a lot of stories from you all lately, and I think it’s about time I share some of mine! If you’re just here for *the good part* and don’t care about the backstory, look for the ******* above a paragraph, that’s the beginning.

Unfortunately there are a few bits of this particular story I don’t remember the details of, since it happened a while ago, so bear with me through those moments, but hopefully it’s an enjoyable read. For a bit of background, like I mentioned in the title, this story takes place between myself (19 at the time) and a girl (Kylie, who was 18) I used to go to church with. I lived with my parents at the time, and she lived with hers a few blocks away. We had hung out a few times before, usually in groups with other friends, and I thought she was super hot but she never really expressed interest in me in that way until…