This is part 2 of this story – https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/3ggr1v/blackmailed_girl_has_sex_with_4_of_us_part_1_mmmmf/
After our encounter at the bar with Tamra and her guy friends, we all were awestruck that this girl was real and we just met her. Tim gloated and we all admitted to him we thought he was full of shit. The conversation alternated between talking about Tamra, how lucky those guys were, what Tim heard they do to her and to what they were probably doing to her right now. The more we drank the more crude we got.
After that night Tamra and the stories came up less and less. We heard Tamra had moved away and that Tim was still working to fuck her and to even set up something so we all could bang her but those comments were few and far between. Just like before, we told him he was full of shit and just dismissed his antics.
Fast forward a year later and Tim starts talking again. He says he thinks he can get Tamra to visit Chicago for us to fuck her. Two of us had girlfriends but we both told Tim we'd be down for a gang bang if he could set it up. I figured Tim was just full of it again and the other guys did too. I pulled up the links to Tamra's porn stuff again and remembered why I liked her so much.