To be clear this is a true story happened some years ago the summer after I graduated HS. Names have been changed.
Ok so when we left off I had gotten half of a hand job and given Sarah her first orgasm ever via the sneaky fingers. After the paddle boat session Sarah left pretty fast but told me to expect a text tomorrow then she gave me a long kiss and rubbed my still semi-hard dick through my swim trunks. The party progressed and high schoolers did what all high schoolers do when mixed with copious amounts of alcohol. Shit got real and several inebriated girls got naked and ran around. Several girl guy pairs made it back to the lake house where no doubt hymens were by maimed. I had a chance to get with this sexy hot girl that I had fucked before but I decided not to. Nothing that happened at the lake house stayed at the lake house. I did not want Sarah to know I had fucked some girl right after she told me she wanted me be her first. Nope huh uh no way. I wanted that virgin pussy and I wasn’t gonna fuck this up. Party ended with me getting completely smashed and laughing at some girl in the bathroom that had gotten wasted thrown up all over the bathroom and was laying with her shorts around he ankles. Pretty funny shit then I passed out.