[MF] Fucking in the church balcony with no regrets

You may remember me and the guy who [I gave a birthday blowjob to](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/fqq3dz/mf_his_18th_birthday_present/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf). After this story concluded I started sucking James off fairly regularly, and after a few times he decided to return the favor to me. The first time he saw me completely naked I think he nearly passed out. He’s kind of a dork but I love him so much. As for me I can’t get enough of his naked body. He’s only average in terms of looks, but he makes me so incredibly horny, and he’s all mine.

This is the story of the first time James and I had real sex, prior to this it’d been oral and petting and other fun stuff. Please note we were really irresponsible because we didn’t use protection or birth control so a small human totally coulda happened, but I still have no regrets.

We were voluntold to run lights and sound for a stupid thing at his church at which I am theoretically a member, though I only go on Christmas and Easter. This was a year ago before this pandemic thing happened. I mean the Black Death couldn’t stop me from worshipping James’ cock, but with no virus it meant church continued on as normal.

[MF] His 18th birthday present.

[MF][oral][first time]

When I was 24 I was super close with my dorky, sheltered, somewhat naive younger step cousin. Relax, we are related by marriage only, my uncle is his stepdad, we share no ancestors. His name is James. He’s an average looking guy, short brown hair, a handsome face with doe-like eyes as blue as the sky. I’m a tomboyish girl with short black hair, freckles, and a pug nose that I hate.

James and I loved each other, as friends and as family. We saw in each other kindred souls. Ever since we met we always ran off to screw around together whenever we could. Strictly platonic of course. Until now.

The day after his eighteenth birthday he was at our house for a family get together, one of the agenda items of which was singing him happy birthday and all that. I was still living at home finishing college.