[MFF] The best threesome we’ve ever had in our lives (long)

My partner and I have had our share of threesomes, a few foursomes and even a bit of an orgy in our lives. She’s bisexual and through our long relationship, we’ve become open to polyamoury in general – even though we would probably more describe ourselves as monogam-ish. She’s had a long-term girlfriend while we’ve been together and that actually was a very comfortable arrangement for us. We’re not much of the ‘kiss and tell’ sort but I felt compelled to share our experience (with permission) just a few days ago of “the best threesome we’ve ever had in our lives”.

I will caution that the writing I normally do is far more technical/business in nature so my tense might be inconsistent – thanks for your understanding!

It started maybe innocently enough, perhaps months ago. My partner, Jenna, has been taking these classes. In one of them, she was partnered with our other heroine, Riley. Immediately, Jenna was thinking Riley was flirting with her but wasn’t quite sure. Jenna is often the one making moves and has had her fair share of ‘barsexuals’ or other just flirty/friendly girls.

A week or so goes by and they’re partnered again, this time Riley seemed a bit more distance so Jenna figured that at the very least, she wasn’t interested anymore. While we live in a very liberal city, Jenna is still cautious to try to read a person more, whereas I still figure her ‘gaydar’ doesn’t exist and that she should just be more direct. It certainly isn’t the first time she’s been wrong about these things but sometimes she’s more of a guy in reading signals too.

In anycase, she dropped it and sees her again from time to time in class but no more than friendly flirtations. That is, until there’s a get together after class and a bunch of them head to the bar for a drink. Jenna and Riley sat next to each other when Jenna said playfully, “you know, I wish I hit on you when we first met,” finishing with a wink. Riley’s face actually lit up and said “I wish you did too!”.

Well, for the rest of the evening, the two were engrossed in each other, perhaps to the chagrin of anyone else trying to pull them into a conversation. As the evening wore on and Jenna suggested she was worried about turning into a pumpkin, she told Riley that she should walk her to the metro. Yeah, that wasn’t where they went as Cinderella still had time on her hands.

They found their way to some secluded urban park in the city. From there, it was a complete make out session. Since I was not there, I can’t give you the blow-by-blow (or rather suck-by- suck?) but they later told me they basically each found out how sensitive the other’s nipples were, and lamented that neither of them wore skirts.

Eventually, Jenna really did have to run but they mutually expressed their eagerness to meet up again.

Now, we’ve had this before… we tend to live in a very flakey city too so all we could really do is hope. Fortunately, a few days later, they met up for some study session or so and hung out for the night. I’ll skip the date details but from what I hear, drinks turned into climbing a tree, a lot of good conversation, and a lot of funny looks when making out on the metro and in elevators. It sounded like such a cute date – I was even starting to feel a bit jealous! Really though, I was just really happy that they had a great time together.

Jenna gives me some casual updates throughout the night and to start cleaning for company. I, on the other hand, was casually warning her about the incoming storm – while they were certainly getting wet, didn’t really want them soaked (or more electrocuted since they told me about their tree climbing). Eventually, they made their way home, where I picked them up from our local metro stop. First time meeting Riley with some simple pleasantries. She certainly lived up to Jenna’s descriptions – petite, long wavy-haired brunette, hazel eyes with a seductive look and a sultry voice.

If you’ve made it this far, I suppose I should reward you with their descriptions at this point. I didn’t know it yet but Riley was perhaps a B-cup topped by really sensitive pink nipples, a nice tight ass and a super plump, camel-toe pussy, with a beautiful pink entrance. My partner is average height for a woman, with an athletic/curvy build, blonde hair, with a nice ass and large tits, especially for her frame. For the inevitable profile divers, you might be able to get a sense of her from our profile photo.

They tell me a bit about their date, including the details of their audiences. They also saw a spectacular meteor, to which we had the cliche back and forth of ‘what did you wish for’, ‘it won’t come true if I tell you” yaddy-yadda, but I did get an insight into her personality when she then reframed it to exploit it by wishing for something you don’t want to happen and then tell someone – to which I was literally thinking the same thing at the same time.

So we all sat down to just shoot the breeze for a bit. I always give the girls their room as I don’t have expectations that just cause a girl is over to fuck Jenna, that I would fuck her too. Basically, our main rule is that we have an open relationship but the other partner has to meet the potential before getting really frisky.

A bit of flirting goes by, with a highlight being when I drop a complement to Riley’s voice and she responded that she’s had friends who suggest she should work as phone sex provider, before giving a sexy rendition of boring office on-goings (think straight out of office space) to make fun of perhaps not being able to keep a straight face with some people’s fetishes. I was starting to like this girl – clever, spontaneous and a sense of humour.

It wasn’t long after that we were sharing some more personal stuff with Jenna and Riley making out in front of me. Now, I always feel a bit weird when this starts inasmuch as I want to give them some privacy to best express themselves but don’t want them (her) to feel awkward that I’m being displaced from my home. It usually results in one of two things: I find a realistic way to excuse myself or I voyeuristically enjoy the show. I usually play the room and her experience as we’ve had both bashful newbies and beautiful sluts with us.

Now in this case, Riley was certainly more of the latter. Jenna started to bring out the dom in her, asking if she’s ever been spanked with a leather glove. Saying no, she grabbed a pair which were strategically behind her on the couch, pulled Riley’s pants off and bent her over the arm-rest. At this point, I was lounging in my arm-chair with a great view of of Riley’s ass. Boy did she have a nice, firm, tight and plump ass.

I’m going to try to switch to present tense as I think it better captures the energy.

Jenna starts to alternate spanks and caresses, checking in with Riley for safe words, how she’s doing, etc. She apparently just likes red/yellow/green. Eventually, some floggers start to come out while I joke with her that Jenna has been known to leave bruises so she best be prepared. I would later find out that Riley, despite being quite pale, has quite the high pain tolerance and just doesn’t bruise.

Their play party gets progressively dirtier; lips and fingers explore new territories. Jenna looks back at me from time to time with intense grins. They start to shed more clothes, with Riley still bent over the arm-rest. Jenna looks at me and says, “Ben… I think you should take your cock out.” Still letting the girls set the pace, I state, “only of Riley is okay with it.” Jenna asks Riley and receives an enthusiastic nod. Out it comes I guess!

Jenna and Riley continue to go at it, when Jenna tells Riley, “turn around and look at how hard we’re making Ben”. She looks over her shoulder, bites her lip and lets a moan squeak past her lips as Jenna plays with her pussy. A few more minutes pass and they both stand up and kiss again, and shed the last of their clothing – tops come off, followed by bras and finally panties drop past their knees. With the brightness of our curtain behind them, I’m treated to a beautiful silhouette of these goddesses as they kiss and suck on each others breasts. I’m less into the BDSM so this was actually getting me going quite a bit more.

Jenna sits down on the armrest, grabs Riley to sit on her lap, spooned by Jenna and displaying Riley’s tight, beautiful body to me. It was the first time I got a really good look at this wonderful nymph in her full glory, including those cute bee-sting tits and super plump pussy. I, of course, kept stroking along while we each exchange looks, biting and licking our lips.

Jenna really gives it to Riley, kisses and bites her neck and shoulders, pulls her head back by her hair back to swap spit, caresses and pinches her nipples and finally fingers her hard. It wasn’t long after that Riley had her first orgasm. It’s always beautiful watching Jenna work and making a girl quiver in her hands.

In the afterglow, Jenna suggests we move to the bedroom, which receives an enthusiastic nod from Riley. We all saunter over, Jenna leading the way with Riley dragged behind. Well, since this is reality, I had to excuse myself to grab some water and relieve some pressure on my bladder. I would hear later that this gave Jenna a good chance to ask Riley how comfortable she felt with playing with me too. I’m fortunate that that was also met with enthusiasm.

I return to the room to find Jenna on top of Riley, exchanging bites and kisses. I’m still comically overdressed at this point which didn’t go unnoticed when they ask me in unison to get undressed. Who am I to argue. As I still didn’t know what Riley’s boundaries are, I start to casually touch both of them. Jenna moves down Riley’s body, and states, “Ben, Riley’s nipples are so sensitive – watch!” before she flicks her tongue across her left nipple. Riley gives out the cutest whimpering yelp. I feel like this was a good enough invitation to see how she feels having both her nipples played so I casually moved to her right nipple to grace it with my fingers and then my tongue. Her reaction was on the positive side.

We tease and play with her body for a few more minutes. She and Jenna tell me more things that Riley likes – biting, spanking, etc… if it isn’t apparent already, she likes it rough. Jenna moves down to her pussy to work on her next O. I continue to suck her tits, kiss her neck, bite her shoulder – just trying to overload her senses. Jenna says, “God, she tastes so good,” to which I reply, “You gonna let me taste too?”, which was responded with, “Not yet – I want you to taste her cum,” as she goes back down on her clit while her fingers work her pussy.

Riley cums hard. Jenna pulls her fingers out of Riley, saying, “Babe, taste,” before she puts her fingers out for me to suck off her juices. I could hardly disagree. At this point, I had actually not kissed Riley – it’s interesting how we have these physical and/or emotional boundaries so figuring them out sometimes results in weird scenarios where I might taste a girl’s cum before I taste her saliva. So I decide to share Riley’s own taste with her via my lips.

Jenna starts working on her pussy again while Riley and I steal more kisses, bites, licks and more. She looks straight into my eyes and states, “I really like things down my throat… fingers… and more”. I reply, “Do you?” with a knowing grin – I wasn’t quite going to give her what she wants just yet so I continue with my foreplay, and trace my fingers along her lips and then into her mouth for her to suck.

Eventually, Riley states she wants to eat Jenna out now so they swap spots. I take the opportunity to play with Jenna like I was playing with Riley but also getting my first grasps of Riley’s amazing ass. Both ask me to give her a few slaps back there to which brings on more conversation about how she indeed likes it rough. Riley gets Jenna close a few times but Jenna pushes her away before she can cum – it was at that point where she shares with Riley that she’s been self-imposing orgasm denial.

Due to some recent events, she decided the next time she’s going to cum was going to be in a threesome. She made that decision about a week ago and had been edging ever since – either when we’re together or when she’s playing with herself. She says to Riley, the next time she cums, she wants to cum so hard she passes out. Riley laughs in approval and I tease her saying, “Well, that sounds like a challenge!”

It was at this point when Jenna looks over to me and says that she feels like I’ve been left out a bit. I gotta tell you, two beautiful girls giving you hungry eyes is the most amazing feeling ever. Riley and I started with a kiss and slowly moved down my body. Jenna states that she wants to ride my face while Riley reaches my cock. Riley gives a few quick pecks before she eases my cock into her mouth while Jenna tries to suffocate me with her pussy. A few blissful minutes pass before Jenna moves to my side and kisses me for a bit, while we watch this beautiful girl work on my cock. She shows us that she’s not kidding when she likes “more down her throat”.

Jenna moves down to alternate between joining Riley on my cock and going behind her to eat her out some more. Jenna asks Riley, “Is your ass clean?” Hey, reality guys – assplay is fun but it’s not often something you can do spontaneously. Thankfully, Riley gives an affirmative mumble and nod (my cock still deep down her throat at this point) and Jenna starts going to town with her tongue in Riley’s ass. I’m pretty sure sometime during this that Riley has another orgasm but a lot of the night honestly starts to blur together.

On my side, she continues to choke herself on my cock. Jenna ask Riley how much she likes it, receiving little pleasurable moans and whimpers. They alternately guide my hands to grab her head, pull her hair etc. I roll my eyes a bit, honestly feeling a bit patronized but start to get into it. Riley is a deepthroat queen. I test how deep and how long she can take my cock, and ask if she’s okay when I pull out. She lightly coughs and just laughs and nods before she suffocates herself again. Eventually, we get to the point where I just grab her head and fuck her throat, pull her head down to my balls, and leave her nothing but gagging and gasping for air on her way back. The girl just looks at me, grins and explains, “Hey, I’m a pretty good swimmer!”. I just shoot back, “Glad I can help with your training”, before I test how much of a deep diver she is.

Fuck, Jenna gives great head but Riley was something else. I’ve had one other amazing BJ, another tiny girl using enough saliva to run a waterslide but Riley was just as good if not better. That said, we did teach Riley one little trick: when the cock is at the back of your throat, swallow. It will hurt like hell and will really test your gag reflexes but that throat massage is indescribably amazing. And Riley is a quick study.

We swap spots a few more times, with me having my own chance to taste Riley’s pussy from the source, and tongue and suck her beautiful pink starfish before Jenna asks what Riley wants next. She responds, “I want to see Ben fuck you while you eat me out.” Jenna laughs and teases that Riley remembers her past descriptions of her ‘favourite threesome position’ – a pussy in her face with a cock in her pussy. She even states that she loves it because she can just stick her tongue out and my thrusting will do the work for her.

We play a bit of twister and reorganize ourselves on the bed. I grab Jenna’s ass, spread her soaking pussy and grab my cock. I tease her entrance a few times, spread her juices over the head of my cock before I ease myself in.

I fuck Jenna doggy while Riley agrees that she enjoys feeling my thrusts through Jenna. Riley I believe gets her 3rd orgasm of the night but really, we weren’t counting. A few times Jenna gets really close and pulls herself away from me and off my cock, as she reminds us that she’s still denying herself. This happens three times or so before I just suggest to Riley that we should just hold her down and force it out of her. Riley laughs while Jenna coyly states, “I wouldn’t mind that…”. I think she knew exactly what she was doing, of course…

I had something a little different in mind, something that Jenna and I had talked about before in these situations. I tell Riley to get under Jenna and lick her pussy and clit while I continue to fuck her. Riley happily obliges and gets in a 69 with her. I slip my cock into Riley’s mouth, perhaps a little down her throat again, to get it nice and wet again before I ease myself back into Jenna.

I give it to her slow. I give it to her fast. I give it to her deep. I give it to her hard. I hold her head down into Riley’s pussy while I slam my cock into her. I hold her down while she came. Hard. Jenna’s pretty diligent with her kegels and she clamps down harder than I’ve felt in a while. She stops breathing, with only little chokes as her body turns beet red and collapses on top of Riley, while I still tease out as much of her orgasm as possible with her over-sensitive and mewling quim (Jenna appreciates this wording as one of her favourite lines in Avengers).

Jenna doesn’t quite pass out but both Riley and I just laugh and revel in our accomplishment. I gave Jenna a few more quick aftershock thrusts before I pull out and have Riley taste her off my cock. Thoughts came to my mind about how hot it would’ve been to just cum inside of Jenna and have it drip out onto Rileys’ tongue, but I still actually wasn’t that close. Plus, we hadn’t discussed that kind of boundary with Riley yet – consent is good guys.

Jenna collapses in a heap while we both come over and give her some post-coitus cuddles. We chat a bit about her orgasm denial and how she’s feeling. She’s certainly on cloud 9. We joke about how many orgasms Riley had already had and that we have to make sure Jenna gets her fair share. They also tease me that I hadn’t cum yet, to which Jenna tells Riley about sometimes how I get ridiculous stamina. It’s both a blessing and curse, guys, and can certainly even go the other way where I don’t last more than a few minutes.

Jenna starts again on foreplay with Riley, asking, “So do, you want to fuck Ben?”. She looks between the both of us and gives a few quick nods, a grin and a sultry, “Yes”. Jenna grabs a condom while Riley starts to suck me again. I ask her what position she likes but Jenna interjects and says, “Sorry but I want to see him enter you,” while biting her lip. She sits back on the headboard, grabs Riley and pulls her over onto her, back against Jenna and Riley splayed open in front of me.

I said earlier that there’s nothing more sexy than a couple of girls looking at you like a piece of meat. Well, now having the same thing while one of them eggs you on to fuck the other, with the other below you submissively presenting her sex, both with intense looks in their eyes… I guess I was wrong. Lithe legs, seductive gazes, cute tits and gorgeously plump and worked pussy, just waiting to be used.

I slip the condom on, and position myself at her entrance. I ease my way into her tight, hot and extremely wet pussy, all while Jenna and Riley exchange kisses and bites. A few slow strokes in and out to get her ready and we are off to the races. I give it to her hard, and try to arch my cock to hit her g-spot. We go at it until Riley is yet again convulsing in orgasm, with my hands wrapped around her neck for some light asphyxiation (protip: squeeze the sides of the neck to ‘restrict’ bloodflow – don’t actually choke).

I slow down a bit to bask in the afterglow. Jenna asks Riley if she liked that, to which she responds with a nod and mutual kisses. I decide to return to Jenna’s “favourite position” and flip Riley over into doggy, and force her head down into Jenna’s pussy. We all joke a bit about how she can now relate to why Jenna likes it with little work to do as I slam into Riley from behind. I was especially eager for this just to see myself slamming into that beautiful ass. I assume she loved it too as she cums hard on me again, helped along with more slaps, bites, hair pulls, chokes, etc.

Jenna also squeaks out another O from this position so I finally felt like they had both been reasonably satisfied. I start to concentrate a little more on getting myself off. I start to feel that telltale build-up in my loins so I ask Riley, “How do you want me to cum?” Riley looks over her shoulder, looks at Jenna, bites her lip and suggests, to my absolute shock, “Can he cum on our faces? I want to lick it off yours.”

I am honestly torn – I am for sure not going to say no, plus I’m happy those around me are happy but I also really want to cum inside of Riley. Begrudgingly, I pull out of her with a slap on her ass, saying, “Sure, but I guess I’ll have to cum inside of you next time.” It wasn’t like I still didn’t have a huge grin on my face.

Alright, now this is the other side of the stamina curse. They both kneel before me while I stroke myself. They make out with each other, suck my cock and lick my balls and tell me how much they want me to cum all over them. Guys – we had been fucking for perhaps an hour or more at this point and I was not exagerrating when I was giving it to them hard. I had Elvis legs. My quads are burning and for some of you, you might know that a good way to lose erections is to flex your quads. Well, they strained to even stand at this point.

They are both super understanding and still continue their own little foreplay. Jenna asks me if I want to fuck her a bit more to get me going a little more. I tell her to stand doggy at the end of the bed as despite standing, it still feels like less strenuous effort than any other position, while it gives me the control to get where I need to arrive. Meanwhile, Riley lays back down in front for Jenna to eat and finger. It’s actually a great call as Riley has perhaps her hardest orgasm of the night – seeing all her muscles tense, flex and pop was just beautiful.

Finally, we make our way back to a standing position with these two beautiful sluts below me. I am getting close but honestly, fatigue continues to distract, sweat streams down my face and I stress as I try to give these two gorgeous creatures what they want and deserve. And it sounds fucking ridiculous but I am thankfully able to explode over their faces. Cum shoots out of my cock with pressure of a fire hose, losing some of it right over their heads. I can barely stand but I try to have the wherewithal to alternate spurts onto each of them, before they both wrap their plush lips around my cock and clean it off. After a good licking, I can only step back to take in these two beautiful goddesses.

Without hesitation Riley starts to lick the cum off Jenna’s face. They lock lips and swap both spit and cum. I’m awestruck with what probably is the dumbest grin I’ve ever had, and state stupid and non-coherent pleasantries of how hot they looked. I get down and give them one final kiss.

Ok, so my last correction – there’s nothing better than to have two hot minxes, beg for your cum and make out after you happily oblige. God. Damn.

In our final afterglow, with laughs, kisses and cuddles, Riley states, “You know, I’ve had my fair share of threesomes and I hope you guys aren’t weirded out… but that was the best threesome I’ve ever had in my life.” Jenna and I look at each other, laugh and agree that it was mutual. We then struggle to even think of porn that had the same intensity.

We spend the rest of the night just shooting the breeze, getting cleaned up, getting to know each other more. If you recall, Riley and I still hadn’t spoken all that much so it was nice to get to know her a bit more. I gotta say, I really liked Riley’s wit and take on life. We also found out that Riley had an unfulfilled fantasy of eating the cum off another girl’s face and we were able to oblige!

We all agreed that we couldn’t wait until we could meet up again.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/cvy39h/mff_the_best_threesome_weve_ever_had_in_our_lives