Post-Prom Threesome [F18/M23/F18]

*Prologue*

This story is a solid ten years old. Its origin is from a girl I met on the now mostly defunct onlyundiesclub, basically a profile-based site where guys and girls posted pictures of themselves in their underwear with contact information. When it wasn’t widely known, it was a fucking goldmine.
Anywho, I met a girl we’ll call Katie from OUC. She was a bit on the heavy side, but with gigantic breasts. We’d hung out once before, some fooling around, mostly boobs and blowjobs. As time went on, we’d mostly chat on messengers and the phone. Kind of shifted to more of a friend thing.

*Story*

Katie calls me one afternoon to see if I’m up to anything. Having just graduated college and, due to lack of employment, moving back home to the suburbs left me with not often being up to much.

Katie: “A bunch of my friends are renting a beach house for after prom. I’m going to drive down there later, want to come?”

Me: “Yes.”

Kind of a no brainer, right?

She picks me up and we drive an hour and a half to her friends beach house.

We get there and it’s predominantly male, but there are a few girls, some of which are fairly attractive. I feel somewhat bad flirting because Katie had driven me down there, but if she wanted to blow me more than hang out with me, we could have done it closer to where we both had lived.

I notice two of the cutest girls there, Leslie and Sue.

Leslie is about 5’4, blonde curly hair, blue eyes, mousey, a little on the chubby side, nice ass, big breasts.
Sue is tall and slim, probably 5’8-ish. She looked vaguely Asian, long dark hair, dark eyes, perky boobs, and a relatively flat ass.

There also were two guys who were clearly interested in and crushing on both Leslie and Sue, so I quickly figured nothing was going to materialize and concentrated on mingling and having a good time.

As the night drew on, I found myself in the living room sitting on the couch talking to a bunch of the new people I met. Little while later, Leslie sits down on my right and Sue sits down on my left. It’s a little chilly, so we pull a large blanket over the three of us.

While I’m not actively engaged in conversation with the two girls (there were a bunch of people in the living room), I decide it’s time to take risks. I put my right hand on Leslie’s leg and my left on Sue’s. We’re under a blanket, so nobody can see anything.

They both seem cool with it.

Leslie and Sue begin engaging in the conversation I’m having with the room and it, of course, turns vaguely sexual.
Everyone is talking about what they like in bed, what they’re good at, all that jazz.

Time to take more risks, slide each hand up the respective girls legs, about mid thigh.

No negative reaction.

Leslie talks about how much she loves when guys go down on her, I remark about how I’m great at eating out. Smarmy grin from Leslie.

More risks! Slide hands to respective upper thigh.

No negative reaction.

Now we’re talking about dicks.

Rhymes with risks kinda, so I slide my hands onto their crotches.

It’s all good, and I am amazed neither of them has any idea what the hell is going on.

We begin to talk about fingering. Sue likes it on the softer side, Leslie likes it rough.

Yeah, it’s time to go in. I slide each hand under their pants and start rubbing their clits, eventually fingering them both.

At this point, they look at each other. They totally realize what is happening now. I prepare to get at least one smack across the face.

Then they both start giggling. Leslie gets up and runs into the bedroom, I trot in after her, Sue follows me. The two dudes who were all about those girls look on, stunned. Katie also seems vaguely disappointed.

As we get into the bedroom, we all strip down. Leslie has pale, pierced nipples. Sue’s tits are perky as fuck. I start making out with Sue while Leslie grabs at my cock.

We jump into bed, Sue laying on the left and Leslie laying on the right. I have a couple fingers inside each of them and they are both moaning softly.

It is at this point that I realize a third girl is trying to sleep on one of the other beds in the room.

I move my head down to Leslie’s pussy and start licking her clit, flicking it with my tongue. Still have a hand inside of Sue. Between moans, Leslie announces that I am as good as I claimed to be earlier. Score!

Sue, moaning, demands her turn. I shift to licking her clit while I finger Leslie. Sue agrees that I am indeed great at this.

We continue going back and forth, each of them stroking my hard cock, me sucking their breasts, licking their pussies, fingering them until they both cum. As I hadn’t cum yet, Leslie asks Sue to blow me. Sue doesn’t want to. Neither does Leslie. Sue suggests we fuck. I oblige.

Leslie rolls over to her side to nap and I climb on top of Sue, sliding my cock inside of her. She is still wet as hell and really, really tight. Only had to thrust for a few minutes until I was ready, then I pulled out and came all over her stomach and beautiful, perky tits.

Threw a towel around my waist and as I was running to get tissues to clean the cum, I noticed that that other girl who was trying to sleep was actually wide awake. I meekly apologized as I walked past her.

*Epilogue*

Katie was definitely disappointed on the drive home, but too upset. We hung out a few more times after that, but never really fooled around again.

Never saw or heard from Sue again. Don’t think she was too good friends with Katie or Leslie.

A few weeks later, Leslie came over and we had sex. Not sure if we hung out much more or had sex again after that.

No idea what happened to the two guys who were courting Leslie and Sue. My prom sucked too. At least I gave them a good “…and you won’t believe the shitty thing that happened” story.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/4c1sot/postprom_threesome_f18m23f18