Lindsay and Leah in the pool (another theatre kid adventure) [M18] [F18] [F18]

This is my second post and it’s even longer than the first but hopefully you all will enjoy it as much as the first. If you want to read that post here is the link: https://redd.it/4bq4dz

A recurring theme in these posts is that these stories all involve friends from my high school theatre clique. This particular story takes place the summer after graduation.

In the town where I grew up, every teenager aged seventeen to twenty (boy or girl) is on one mission: the quest for alcohol. My parents weren’t around a lot when I was that age so my house became a regular party spot where we could drink and not get caught. We also had a lot of alcohol in my house accumulated from parties my older brother threw. I was sitting on a gold mine.

In the summer after graduation there seemed to be something going on somewhere every night. I had a pool at my house so I threw pool parties all the time. One particular Saturday, I was hanging out with Christy, James, and Jess. We were drinking, eating pizza, and chilling out by the pool. It was a fun time but James had some church thing going on the next day so he had to call it an early night. Christy was James’ girlfriend so she had to leave with him and Jess rode with them so by 9:30pm I was by myself with nothing to do. I started cleaning up the empty bottles around the pool when I felt my phone vibrate in my pocket. It was Lindsay…

Lindsay was in theatre crew. For those of you who don’t know what that is; if the theatre kids could be considered the cool or popular kids, the theatre crew kids were the freaks and geeks working behind the scenes. You would think theatre is nerdy enough and that everyone would socialize under the same tent, but in general the cast kids didn’t hang out with the crew kids very much. I took pride in socializing with everyone and Lindsay and I would always flirt backstage during performances. Something about the darkness in the wings of the theatre turns everyone on.

I opened my phone and there was a text from Lindsay.

“Hey, what’s up?” she asked.

“Nothing much, just hanging out at the house. You?” I responded.

“Driving around with my friend Leah, looking for a place to drink,” she texted back.

The night was saved but I didn’t want to sound too eager. I tried to play it cool.

“I had some people over earlier but they already went home,” I responded, “You can still come over if you want but I’m the only one here.”

“Sweet! We’ll be there in 10 minutes,” she sent back almost immediately.

I took a swig of rum and waited.

I was sitting on the deck of my family’s above ground pool. The pool deck butted up against the back yard fence on the right side of the house. I was looking out over the front yard and down the stretch of road that led to my house, anxiously waiting to see the headlights of Lindsays car appear from around the corner. A couple of false alarm cars came through before her little green Dodge Neon turned the corner and pulled up to the house. I waved and motioned for them to come around through the backyard gate. Moments later they were walking up the wooden steps to the pool deck.

Lindsay was wearing flip flops, really short, hip-hugging denim shorts, and a green spaghetti strap tank top. Lindsay was about 5’2” with straight, shoulder length brunette hair, really big tits and a cute little belly. She had a cute freckled face and I always thought she was really fucking hot. She seemed to fly under other guy’s radar, maybe because of the weird people she hung out with.

Leah, on the other hand, I had never met before. She was wearing jeans and a black spaghetti strap tank top that had the midriff cut off displaying a little belly button ring. She was tall and slender with long, dirty blonde hair, and what looked like perky little tits. She was kind of hippy-ish, and not as bubbly or girly as Lindsay. Still, she seemed like a cool chick.

We made our introductions and got comfortable in the deck chairs by the pool. Lindsay and Leah were passing a flask back and forth and I was mixing whatever liquor I had with pepsi. It got dark out and the mosquitos were biting so I lit some bug repellent tiki torches that lined the pool. We shot the shit for another half hour but the tiki’s weren’t doing the trick and the mosquitos were getting annoying.

Lindsay suggested we get in the pool to avoid the mosquitos. Unfortunately my pool was positioned in such a way that it didn’t get a ton of direct sunlight so it was notoriously cold.

I said, “It’s probably really cold. We can go inside if you want.”

“Oh come on, please,” Lindsay pleaded.

“Did you even bring a bathing suit?” I asked.

“I’ll just get in with my bra,” she shrugged.

That sentence hit my brain like a bolt of lightning. I felt my pulse start to race and I could feel I was becoming aroused.

“If that’s what you want, don’t let me stop you!” I laughed, nervously.

Lindsay walked over to the ladder that lowered into the pool water and dipped her toe in.

“Fuck! That’s cold!” she said in a whispered shout.

“I told you!” I said, defensively.

“Leah, are you coming in?” Lindsay asked.

Leah replied, “You first. I’ll think about it if you don’t freeze to death.”

Lindsay stuck her tongue out at Leah as she undid her belt and shimmied her denim shorts down her thighs. Then she proceeded to pull her tank top up and over her head and tossed it aside. Her body was incredible. I had to readjust how I was sitting as my erection was now visible and I didn’t want Leah to see. Her tits were really bouncy and perfectly presented in a black polka dot bra. I was trying not to stare but I couldn’t help myself.

Lindsay cautiously descended the ladder into the pool, taking time on each step to let her body adjust to the temperature of the water. Finally she stepped off the ladder onto the floor of the pool. She stood on her tiptoes trying to keep as much of her torso out of the water as possible.

“Just go under. It’ll be better!” Leah suggested.

“Oh my god! So cold!” Lindsay huffed.

Lindsay held her nose, clenched her eyes closed tight, and dropped under the water. She came back up a moment later.

“WOO!,” Lindsay shouted, “It’s ok. It’s really not that bad.

Lindsay turned and swam away toward the back of the pool.

Then she shouted, “Come on, Leah. Get in!”

“Fine,” Leah sighed.

Leah took off her clothes, not shy at all. She had the sexiest little stomach. It was perfectly flat and she had really sexy hips too. She was wearing a little red thong underneath. Her butt cheeks were perfectly smooth, round and pale white. She ran up to the edge and did a cannonball into the pool, splashing water everywhere. She came back up and immediately splashed Lindsay in the face.

They both played around in the water for a minute and then swam back up to the edge of the deck where I was sitting.

“Are you going to get in or what?” Lindsay asked, “It’s really not that bad. I promise.”

Now one thing I learned from my friend Anthony (mentioned in my previous story) is not to be afraid to say whatever crazy thing that comes into your head. Nine times out of ten girls will just brush you off as being silly, but every now and then you might get lucky.

“Well if I am getting in, I am getting in naked!” I declared.

“Yeah right!” Lindsay scoffed.

“I seriously doubt it,” Leah added.

“You think I won’t?” I asked.

“Go for it. I’ll believe it when I see it,” Lindsay replied.

“Fine. Here I go.” I announced.

I stood up with my heart racing. I couldn’t back out now. Lindsay and Leah didn’t react as I had expected. They were daring me to go through with it. I took off my shirt and kicked off my shoes in one singularly awkward motion. Then I undid my belt and pulled down my jeans. Lindsay and Leah had gone back to swimming around. They didn’t seem to be paying attention. I don’t think they believed I would do it. I honestly didn’t think I would do it either.

I walked over to the ladder, still wearing my boxer briefs. I descended into the water in much the same way that Lindsay had.

“Just go under!” Leah called from the opposite end of the pool.

I jumped from the bottom step of the ladder and went straight under. After a moment I came back up just enough that the water line was at my neck. When they saw me climb in I was still wearing my underwear. Maybe it was the alcohol or maybe it was pure adrenaline but I felt a wave of fuck-it vibes come over me.

I was careful to keep my head right where it was so Lindsay and Leah couldn’t tell what I was doing. I reached down and grabbed the waistband of my boxer briefs and slid them down my legs and off my body entirely. Careful not to make too much noise, I drifted over to the deck and laid my soaking wet underwear over the side. I had never swam naked before. I didn’t realize just how much different the water would feel on my genitals when there was no fabric to shield them.

I made my way to the other end of the pool where Lindsay and Leah were floating on foam pool noodles. There was a flood light mounted into the wall of the pool on that end that shined under the water. I approached slowly with a mischievous look on my face and they could tell something was up.

“Hey guys,” I said, casually.

“What’s that face mean?” Lindsay asked, suspiciously.

“Nothing,” I shrugged, nonchalantly.

“Wait,” Leah interrupted, “Are you naked?!”

“No…” I replied, guiltily.

Lindsay looked down. She could probably faintly see my dick at this point.

“Holy shit! You are fucking naked!” Lindsay said in a rushed and whispered shout.

“I told you if I was going in, I was going in naked,” I said as if I had no choice in the matter.

“You are fucking crazy,” Leah added.

“It’s actually kind of nice. It feels very free,” I said, “You should join me.”

I swam past them to the wall of the pool, turned around, and rested with my arms splayed across the edge like Scarface in the hot tub. I figured I might as well own it.

Lindsay was holding a pool noodle under the water. For those of you who had depressing childhoods, a pool noodle is basically a six foot long, foam straw. They are good for two things; hitting people and blowing water through them as a makeshift hose. Lindsay thought she would take me down a peg. She brought the noodle to her mouth and blew a strong huff of air shooting water out of the other side and hitting me in the face.

I couldn’t let this aggression go unanswered. I started wildly splashing both of them. I’m bigger and stronger than them both combined and they couldn’t keep up with the force of my splashing prowess. They both lunged, grabbed my arms, and pulled me back to the wall.

“Ok, ok, I’ll stop,” I conceded, “But the next person who splashes me has to get naked. House rules.”

“Fine. Whatever. Just stop splashing!” Leah agreed.

The terms were set and as we sat in the water drinking and talking, that agreement was in the forefront of my mind.

We eventually finished the flask that Lindsay and Leah had brought. Lindsay suggested I go and get the bottle of rum that was on the deck at the opposite end of the pool.

“No way. I’m finally completely used to the water. If I get out now the shrinkage may be irreversible,” I said, refusing to budge.

“Fine, I’ll get it you big baby,” Lindsay gave in.

She left Leah and I in awkward silence. I was just sitting there naked with this girl I barely knew. A few seconds later Lindsay returned and the moment I had been waiting for finally came. Lindsay momentarily forgot the terms that had been set forth and did a cannonball back into the pool, right next to me and Leah, splashing water all over us. When she came back up I took it upon myself to remind her.

“Lindsay, you splashed me!” I declared, “You know what that means.”

“Oh fuck! I forgot,” she realized, “Oh come on. Do I have to?!”

“Those were the rules,” Leah said, matter-of-factly.

“Ugh. Fine!” said Lindsay in acceptance as she reached down to slide off her panties, “That’s so cold on my vagina!”

It was really happening. I don’t think they noticed but my dick was fully erect under the water. I was finally going to get to see Lindsays big tits. Or so I thought…

To my disappointment, Lindsay unclasped her bra and pulled it off but she stayed low so her boobs were obscured by the water. On top of that she had her arm draped over them so I couldn’t really see anything.

“Really?” I asked incredulously, “What’s with the arm?”

“I’m embarrassed!” Lindsay replied.

“Why? Your boobs are awesome!” I assured her.

“I totally wish I had your boobs, Lindsay” Leah added.

Lindsay brushed us off and we went back to just talking.

We were sitting together in about four square feet of space in the back corner of the pool. Leah was on my left resting her back against the left wall. Lindsay was snuggled up next to me on my right, her arms wrapped around my right arm for warmth. We were talking about school and how weird it was going to be not hanging around the theatre department anymore. Leah didn’t know I was in theatre.

“Did you do crew with Lindsay?” Leah asked.

“No, I was in the cast,” I clarified.

“So you were up on stage in makeup, singing and dancing?” Leah asked, half giggling.

“Absolutely,” I declared, proudly.

With a snort of laughter Leah said, “You are nerdier than I thought!”

“You just wish you were cool enough to be in theatre with us!” I said, snarkily.

“Whatever!” Leah scoffed and gently splashed me.

There it was. The splash heard ‘round the world! Lindsay and I locked eyes because we both knew what just happened. Then we both turned and looked at Leah.

“Oh shit…” Leah said in a defeated manner, “I guess I gotta get naked, too.”

Leah wasn’t shy like Lindsay. She slipped her panties off under the water then stood up with her upper body out of the water. She didn’t take her bra off the same way Lindsay did, either. She pulled the straps off of her shoulders. Then she pulled her arms up and out from under the straps. Then without hesitation she grab the front part of her bra where the straps met the cups and pulled it down revealing her perfect, perky little tits. Leahs nipples were as hard as they could possibly be and pointing straight up to the sky. She pulled the bra around her torso until the clasp was in front of her. She undid the clasp and discarded her bra.

Seeing Leahs tits made my dick really hard again. So hard, in fact, I felt something touch the head of my cock. I looked down and realized I had accidentally poked Lindsays elbow with my hard-on. Lindsay noticed too and I was mortified.

“I think someone likes your boobs, Leah,” Lindsay said, nodding toward my dick.

“Oh really?” Leah asked, flattered but also knowing I would be embarrassed at being called out.

“I can’t help it! It has a mind of it’s own!” I said in my own defense.

“It’s ok. I like it,” Leah assured me.

That’s when Lindsays cell phone started ringing. She swam to the side wall next to us and lifted herself out of the water. I got a really nice look at her pale white ass. She stood up and again draped an arm over her boobs so we couldn’t see. She quickly scurried along the side deck of the pool but the phone stopped ringing by the time she got there. She checked her voicemail and said it wasn’t anything important. She walked back along the side deck to where Leah and I were, her right arm covering her boobs, her left arm reaching down and covering her pussy. She got to the edge where we were and realized she couldn’t climb back down into the water from where she was without lowering her arms and revealing all of her private parts.

“Oh come on. You can’t still be that shy,” I said.

“I am!” Lindsay groaned back.

“Well how do you plan on getting back in?!” I asked.

Lindsay considered her situation for a moment and then made her decision.

“You better not splash me,” I warned.

She kept herself covered and jumped into the pool splashing me and Leah.

Lindsay came back up with a gasp.

“Sorry!” Lindsay said.

“You splashed me!” I replied.

“Big deal! I’m already naked,” Lindsay responded.

“Yeah, but we still haven’t seen your boobs,” Leah added.

Lindsay, feeling cheated, pleaded her case, “Oh come on! I’ve been naked this whole time!”

I responded, “You knowingly splashed us. You knew there would be consequences. You either have to stand up and show your boobs or you have to put my penis in your mouth for ten seconds because that is now the official punishment for splashing me from here on out.”

Lindsay was taken aback by my ultimatum but then she shrugged in acceptance.

“Fine. Whatever,” Lindsay scoffed.

Lindsay stood up with her arm covering her boobs at first. Then she threw her arms out to the side.

“Happy?!” Lindsay asked.

“Very,” I said with a smile.

Lindsay had broken the ice of her shyness and she liked the way it felt. She stood proudly with her incredible D-cup tits exposed in the night air. Her nipples were just slightly darker than the rest of her skin and they were stiff like little pencil erasers. Lindsays tits were so perfect they didn’t ever look real. They defied gravity because even though they were huge, they were every bit as perky as Leahs.

“Jesus. Fucking. Christ, Lindsay,” Leah said, incredulously.

“What?!” Lindsay asked, defensively.

“Your tits are fucking gorgeous!” Leah said with awe and a hint of jealousy.

“Oh shut up!” Lindsay scoffed.

“Seriously. I’m straight and I still want to play with those!” Leah said, laughing.

“Me too!” I added.

Embarrassed at my ogling of her boobs, Lindsay absent mindedly splashed water at me.

“Lindsay! You splashed again!” Leah scolded.

“Oh shit. I’m sorry,” Lindsay followed, sheepishly

“It’s ok but you know the rules,” I stated.

“Really? I have to put your dick in my mouth for 10 seconds because I splashed you?!” she asked, hoping for a reprieve.

“That’s the punishment for splashing!” I held strong.

Lindsay just stared at me in judgement.

“I mean you did splash me literally right after I said that was the rule.” I continued, keeping hope alive that she might actually do it.

Lindsay turned to Leah and said, “Not a word to anyone!”

I didn’t immediately allow myself to believe what that clearly meant but then Lindsay waded over and positioned herself right in front of me. Holy shit, this was going to happen.

Lindsay looked at Leah again and said, “You keep track of time. I don’t trust this little perv.”

Then she slowly lowered herself in the water pausing for a moment to look back up at me. Then she took a deep breath and went under.

The sensation was hard to describe. My body was cold all over but then there was the warmth of Lindsays mouth on my hard dick. The contrast was striking. She didn’t suck me or bob her head on my dick. Sticking strictly to the rules, she simply took my rock hard cock into her mouth and held it there.

Leah moved in next to me on my left. She was as struck by the unfolding events as I was. I don’t think she thought for a second Lindsay would go through with it, Lindsay being the more conservative of the two.

“Is she really doing it?” Leah asked of me.

“Yes,” I said with a shiver.

Leah replied, “Holy crap! Ok. Ok. 1… 2… 3… 4…”

I didn’t want her to stop!

Leah continued, “5… 6… 7… 8… 9… 10…”

To my inevitable dismay, Leah reached the end of her ten count and said, “Time!” in a voice loud enough for Lindsay to hear under water.

Lindsay came back up with a proud grin on her cute, freckled face.

“Lindsay!” Leah screeched, incredulously, “You SLUT!” Leah continued, teasingly.

“Those were the rules. I had to!” Lindsay defended, feigning offense.

Lindsay swam back to the pool wall I was resting up against, picked up the bottle of rum off the deck and took a quick sip. She settled back, neck deep into the water. She held the rum bottle in front of her, partially submerged.

I suggested we play a game called “Never Have I Ever.” We would each take turns saying something we had never done and if the other two had, they would have to take a drink. Lindsay and Leah were game and I got us started.

“Never have I ever kissed a guy on the lips,” I stated.

It was an easy one that made them both drink.

“Never have I ever kissed a girl!” Lindsay offered in direct response to my previous assertion.

I took a drink. Then surprisingly, Leah took a drink too.

“It was on a dare at my friend Alicia’s birthday party, freshman year,” Leah explained.

“Never have I ever been given a hickey,” Leah continued.

I didn’t drink on this one but Lindsay did.

When it was my turn, I teased, “Never have I ever gone down on a guy in a pool.”

Lindsay glowered at me as she took a drink. We both looked at Leah to see if she would be taking a drink.

“Sorry to disappoint. I haven’t broken the no splash rule yet,” Leah admitted.

When she said the word “yet” I felt a jolt run through my body. Her nonchalant attitude toward the idea of putting my dick in her mouth made me shake with excitement.

“Never have I ever gone streaking,” Lindsay asserted.

Neither Leah nor I drank on that one.

“Never have I ever fingered a girl,” Leah said, clearly directed at me.

I took another drink. Lindsay, unsurprisingly, did not.

“Never have I ever done a triple kiss,” I said.

“What the hell is a triple kiss?” Leah asked.

It was some cheesy thing I saw on MTV where three people put their mouths together at the same time for one big three person kiss.

I explained what it was and said, “We can try one right now but then we’ll all have to drink,”

Lindsay and Leah gave each other a look, seemingly communicating telepathically. They agreed and we all leaned in. It was so awkward and lame. Lindsay immediately started laughing uncontrollably.

“Quit laughing!” Leah feigned offense to Lindsays laughter and absent mindedly splashed water at Lindsay, hitting me in the process.

“Uh oh!” Lindsay said in vindication, “You broke the splash rule! Now you have to do it too. Ten seconds. Let’s go!”

“Oh fucking god damn it! I wasn’t paying attention!” Leah pleaded.

“Doesn’t matter. If I had to do it, so do you!” Lindsay argued.

“Fine! Hand me the rum since I guess I won’t be able to say I’ve never gone down on a guy in a pool before!” Leah said, sarcastically, before taking a drink.

I was quivering uncontrollably with excitement. My dick was really fucking hard. I couldn’t believe this girl I barely knew was about to put my dick in her mouth like it was no big deal.

Leah waded around into position right in front of me and handed the rum back to Lindsay.

“Are you going to count?” Leah asked.

“I got you. Don’t worry,” Lindsay replied.

Leah wrapped her hand around my hard cock and looked me in the eyes.

“Are you ready?” Leah asked.

I stammered, “I’m definitely ready if you are.”

Leah lowered her body down until she was submerged. I felt the warmth of her mouth on my cock contrasting with the cold of the water. Unlike Lindsay, Leah actually started sucking me off. Her head was bobbing up and down on my dick under the water and I shuddered with intense pleasure.

Then suddenly, Lindsay pulled my face toward her and stuck her tongue in my mouth. I couldn’t believe what was happening. Lindsay wasn’t even paying attention to how long Leah had been under water.

A few moments later (I honestly have no idea how long) Leah reemerged from under the water.

“Lindsay!” Leah screeched, “You were supposed to be counting!”

“Sorry, I got distracted,” Lindsay replied, turning away from me.

“Pass me the bottle. Is there any soda left to mix this with?” Leah asked me.

“Yeah there is a two liter bottle of pepsi up on the deck,” I answered.

“Ok. Be right back,” Leah said as she lifted herself up on the pool deck and walked to the other side.

In that moment Lindsay snuggled up close to me and wrapped her hand around my still hard cock.

“Do you like it?” I whispered.

Lindsay bit her lip and smiled, nodding in the affirmative. Then without saying anything, Lindsay extended her right leg and moved into a position straddling me. She took my cock in her hand and guided it into her warm pussy. I couldn’t believe what she was doing. Her friend, who I barely knew, was just twenty feet away.

Lindsay didn’t care. It turned her on. She liked being sneaky. She began writhing her hips, grinding her pussy on my veiny shaft. She moved slowly so not to disturb the water and make too much noise. Her pussy was really tight and wet. I squeezed her big tits and her jaw dropped with pleasure. She started grinding harder and was starring to make more noise so I looked over her shoulder to see if Leah had noticed. Leah was standing naked on the deck and appeared to be checking her phone. I was trying to keep Lindsay from making too much noise.

When I saw Leah bend over to put her phone away I whispered to Lindsay, “She’s coming back.”

Lindsay leaned back and looked over her shoulder, still grinding ever so slightly. She saw as Leah draped her jeans back over the deck chair and decided she better stop before Leah got back. As Lindsay pulled away I felt my hard cock leave the warmth of her pussy. A moment later Leah was back in the pool with us.

Leah started talking to Lindsay about a text message that was on her phone from some guy. They were going back and forth but I wasn’t really able to pay attention. I was so fucking horny and all I could think about was how badly I wanted to cum. I legitimately didn’t even realize that I had started stroking my cock in the water. Lindsay said something to me and I completely missed it. They both noticed how distracted I was. Then Leah noticed.

“Are you rubbing your dick?!” Leah asked, incredulously.

“Oh shit! I’m sorry. I didn’t even realize. I swear!” I said, apologetically.

“You are such a little perv!” Lindsay remarked, teasingly.

“I’m sorry. I’m just really fucking horny right now. I can barely see straight!” I explained.

“Aww, poor baby,” Lindsay said as she touched my shoulder.

They both shifted closer to me.

“Would it make you feel better if we played with it a little bit?” Leah asked.

I was in shock. I started to shiver with nervous excitement.

“Are you being serious right now?!” I asked.

“Just this once and if you tell anyone I will murder you!” Leah replied in no uncertain terms.

“Of course. I would never,” I agreed, unconditionally.

I was frozen. I didn’t know what to do next.

Lindsay said, “Well get up on the deck silly, we don’t have gills!”

Lindsay tapped the deck right behind my head. I turned around, climbed out, and then sat back down on the section of deck that was right behind where I had been in the water. My feet dangled in the water about calf deep. It’s dark and the night air was crisp and cold as it brushed across my wet skin. My hard cock was entirely exposed to anyone who cared to see. Lindsay and Leah stood up, naked and glistening, nipples erect in the cold air. Lindsay moved in closer on my right and Leah on my left. Each of them were running their hands up and down my thighs. Lindsay reached past me and grabbed the bottle of rum that was sitting next to me.

Lindsay took a sip and said, “I can’t believe we are doing this.”

Then she passed the bottle to Leah who took a sip as well.

The two girls paused for a moment, looking at each other and again seeming to communicate telepathically.

Leah raised the bottle and said, “Cheers!”

She then turned the bottle up and poured the equivalent of a cap full of rum on my dick. Then before I had time to realize what was happening, Lindsay lunged in and took the full length of my rock-hard, rum soaked cock into her mouth and down her throat. Leah just watched as Lindsay bobbed her head up and down on my dick.

Lindsays technique was fantastic. She would turn her head in concert with each bob up and down. She aggressively sucked my swollen cock for a few moments then pulled me out of her mouth so she could lick the entire length of my shaft, from base to tip. She was tonguing the swollen purple head of my cock when Leah reached her left hand in and wrapped it around the base of my shaft. She was ready to take her turn.

Leah came up from underneath my cock and pressed her face up against the underside of it with a smile. I was squirming for her to continue what Lindsay had started but she liked teasing me. Leah ran her tongue from the underside of my dick to the head, then flicked the tip with her tongue. She knew she was driving me crazy. Instead of immediately taking the length of my cock in her mouth she kissed the tip and smooshed her lips up against it. Then she took just the tip into her mouth. I could feel her tongue wildly flickering over it inside her mouth. After a moment she decided to stop teasing and plunged my cock deep into her throat. Leah was really loud. She was fervently slobbering on my dick and letting out muffled moans.

As I watched Leahs head rise and fall in my lap, Lindsay inched up closer to my side. She took my right hand and placed it on her left breast and squeezed. She reached her right hand over and placed it on the back of Leahs head as she continued to aggressively suck me off.

“Is she good at that?” Lindsay asked, slyly.

“She is really fucking good at that,” I shuddered.

There was an audible smack as Leah pulled my cock out of the suction of her mouth.

“Why, thank you!” Leah said, proudly.

Leah was still stroking my slobber soaked dick as she looked up at me to see my reaction. I took a moment to gather up my courage.

“I have to be honest, I’m really close to fucking cumming,” I said, desperately, “Would one of you be willing to finish me off?”

“DIBS!” Lindsay shouted, abruptly as she raised her hand in the air.

Before Leah or I could react, Lindsay took my cock in her mouth once more. I wasn’t going to last much longer with Lindsay eagerly sucking me off. I was squeezing Leahs little tits with my left hand.

“I’m getting close,” I warned.

Lindsay pulled up for a moment and said, “Tell me when.”

She then went back to sucking my hard cock with overwhelming enthusiasm. She even started making some noise like Leah. The smacking sound of her mouth’s aggressive suction grew louder. Lindsays entire upper body was bouncing up and down. The sound of splashing grew louder as Lindsays big tits smacked into the water with every down stroke.

I couldn’t last any longer. Watching my dick disappear into Lindsays cute little mouth was too much to take. Leah put her hand on the back of Lindsays head in encouragement.

I felt the wave come over me and said, “Oh fuck! Lindsay, I’m about to cum!”

Lindsay pulled my throbbing cock out of her mouth and stood up straight as she continued to stroke me with enthusiasm. I felt waves of pleasure radiate through my body. My cock started spurting ropes of hot cum, and Lindsays continued stroking caused it to fly in every direction. Leah flinched as some landed on her. Then Lindsay pulled forward and pointed my cum spurting dick at her tits. Leah and Lindsay were both giggling at me. When it was over, Lindsays big round tits were covered in my cum. Leah leaned forward and licked my cock clean.

“Oh. My. God.” Lindsay said, “You came all over me,”

Leah turned to Lindsay and started playing with her boobs. She was squeezing and massaging them and, in turn, getting my cum all over her hands.

“Sorry, I just really wanted to play with them,” Leah said.

We kept drinking and got really shit faced. Lindsay and Leah even made out a little bit.

A little while later Lindsay went into the house to use the bathroom and see if there was another bottle of liquor she might like in the liquor cabinet. I was sitting on the edge of the pool near the ladder and I still had a full erection. As soon as Lindsay went in the house, Leah swam up to me.

“Are you seriously still fucking hard?” Leah asked.

“I’m basically a walking erection,” I joked.

Leah laughed. Then she looked at me dead in the eye and splashed me.

“Leah you know the rules. If you splash me you have to put my penis in your mouth.” I reminded her.

Leah splashed me again.

“That’s it. You better put my penis in your mouth!” I said.

Leah put her hands on my thighs and pushed herself up out of the water and put her tongue in my mouth. Then suddenly she pulled away and went down to my hard cock. She took my dick in her mouth and started sucking me again. I think girls around this age have a serious competitive streak and I got the impression that Leah wanted to out do Lindsay. Leah liked to look up and make eye contact with me when my dick was in her mouth. She wanted to see if she could make me cum again before Lindsay came back. She was fervently sliding my dick in and out of her mouth and I could feel my cock hitting her in the back of the throat. She was so aggressive that on a few thrusts she made a slight gagging noise.

“Do you want me to cum again?” I asked.

Leah nodded in the affirmative and let out a muffled, “Mmm Hmm.”

Leah took my dick all the way down her throat. So deep that her nose was touching the lower part of my stomach. The next thing I knew my throbbing cock was spasming hot cum into Leahs mouth and down her throat. Leah held my dick in her throat until the last spurt was done then slowly pulled me out of her mouth and swallowed.

Lindsay came back a few minutes later and Leah and I acted as if nothing happened. I don’t know if Leah ever told Lindsay or not. We ended up crashing on the couches in my basement. Lindsay and Leah woke me up the next morning to say goodbye as they were heading out.

I saw them both a few more times when they would come to parties I was throwing. One party in particular, Leah actually blew me in the backroom of my house while everyone else was upstairs. We were in the computer room and I had an old mini DV camcorder sitting on the computer desk. While Leah was on her knees sucking me, I reached over and picked up the camera and started filming. I thought she would get mad but she didn’t. She let me film the whole thing including me cumming in her mouth.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/4c0e5l/lindsay_and_leah_in_the_pool_another_theatre_kid