Winner! [FM] [young adults] [college hookup] [friends become lovers] [request fill]

Hi all!

I wanted to share a recent request fill I did for a member of this sub. I wrote this over the course of a couple days, trying to focus on the first time encounter between two college kids who finally ignite the kindling between them. Enjoy!

Winner!

A story by Khloe Grey

———————————————

“Down and back. Breast stroke. Winner gets..” James’ voice trailed off as his mind raced at the possibilities for a prize. Looking at his smaller counterpart, he knew it was impossible for her to win this, and this was an opportunity to capitalize on his feelings for Lexi. So why did the words fail him?

“Winner gets what?” Lexi quipped back, still peeling her black skinny jeans away from her slender legs. Her white cotton panties were practically glowing in the dimly lit pool area as she pulled her blonde hair up into a tight ponytail. “Winner gets to not take care of Mike tonight?”

As if on cue a loud dry heave could be heard from a cracked window on the third floor, the telltale sign that Mike had been flirting with the bottle of vodka that had been passed around the living room hours ago. They both looked at each other and shared a quick laugh as they eased themselves into the heated pool water, adjusting to the change in temperature and moisture. Lexi felt her nipples stiffen, pressing against the white fabric of her B cup bra, and nonchalantly threw an arm over her chest, hiding them from any potential gaze from James.

Try as he might, James was having his own issues, as it seemed his eager member was trying to stand at attention after watching the young lady shed her party outfit and shimmy into the sapphire blue water. He dare not touch it with a hand, lest the problem got worse, so he chose to turn his waist away from Lexi, hiding it for the moment. His heart threatened to jump out of his chest as her emerald green eyes looked up at him, waiting for him to set the challenge rules.

“Winner gets a kiss,” he said quickly, his pulse thumping in his ears as he tried to ignore her reaction, opting to feign stretching in anticipation for the competition. The seconds passed by like hours as he waited for a response.

“A kiss?” Lexi said pensively, furrowing her brow. She noticed James wouldn’t meet her gaze, and with a small frown did some stretching of her own. She could decline, pick something obscure. But she saw this as a bluff. There was no way he’d follow through. And besides, she couldn’t possibly lose to this gangly giant. All the same, she thought about her prize as he ruffled his dark brown hair, his slender shoulders falling into the water, his strong jaw inches from the waterline.

“Fine. Winner gets a kiss. Shake on it,” she said quickly, extending a hand that was met with his.

Both took their positions on the wall, Lexi sure to leave enough space for his long arms. “I’ll call it,” she commanded, bracing her strong legs against the rough concrete edge of the pool. “3.. 2.. 1.. Go!” she shouted, pushing off hard against the wall, paddling underwater for all she was worth. Breaking the surface, she propelled her chest from the water, kicking hard with her feet, her arms outstretched before slamming back into the water. Harder and harder she pushed, finding her rhythm, trying to ignore James’ own splashes beside her.

She hit the wall, and just before making the turn took a peek at her competitor. 6 meters past the turn was James, his slender shoulders quickly and expertly entering and exiting the water, the practiced rhythm of someone who’d done this before.

‘Fuck,’ Lexi thought to herself, barely keeping her head above water as she pushed to catch up, quickly realizing this race was already over. Nevertheless, she pushed herself to exhaustion, making it as close as possible.

“Winner!” she heard him call out, and with a face of annoyance she finished the last few meters, her hands connecting with the wall as she laid her arms across the finish line, her head falling against them. Her soaked ponytail flowed over her shoulder, her chest heaving with pants as she tried to catch her breath. To her left sat James, a haughty grin on his face as his abs flexed and contracted, his own breathing trying to normalize.

But Lexi found her eyes drawn southward. James’ boxers were soaked, and were just as white as her own underwear. They clung tightly to his skin, creating the perfect outline that showcased what was hidden underneath. Her green eyes peered at it curiously, biting her lip softly, imagining what lay just below that thin fabric of clothing, and all the things it could do to her.

“It wasn’t even close,” James called out, catching Lexi’s eyes on his lap, shifting nervously. “I feel like I should be paid double,” he finished with a nervous laugh, looking down at the athletic body of one of his closest female friends. He’d always been attracted to her, for years even, but it had just never worked out. She was always with one guy or another, or they’d found themselves at a party surrounded by friends. But here, underneath the waning moonlight they were alone, their faces lit by the 60watt bulbs underneath the blue water. He watched her smile, his heart fluttering as she swam to position herself between his legs, her collarbones just under the surface of the pool.

There was a hunger in Lexi’s eyes as she pulled herself between his legs, a yearning in her smile. She knew what she wanted from the minute she watched him slide out of his jeans, from the second his waist entered the water. She’d thought about him so many nights in her dorm room, her eyes fixed on the ceiling while she imagined a moment like this.

“Double huh?” she said in a low voice, placing her hands on his knees, pulling herself out of the water to eye level with him. Her white bra clung tightly to her wet skin, the hard nubs of her nipples poking out, catching the young man’s eye. “Then double it is.”

Lexi leaned in to him, nuzzling his nose softly before taking his lips with hers. His gentle scruff tickled her silky soft lips, and she found she began to lose herself in the moment, her lips meeting his again and again, the soft smacking of their kisses filling the space between them. James’ hands found her hips, relieving some of the strain on her arms, and she smiled into his mouth when she felt his fingers grip her waist.

She whimpered softly as his finger danced along the line of her panties, the soaking wet fabric pulled gently away from her skin before being released with a soft ‘slap!’ and she giggled into his next kiss, biting his lip softly. James’ hand ran up her back, finding the strap on her bra, and she found her body fighting her mind, her breasts yearning to be set free while her sobriety told her someone could be watching.

“Hey,” she said softly, pulling away an inch. “Someone might see,” she murmured, pointing to the windows.

James grunted in exasperation, his large erection pressing painfully against his wet boxers. He wanted her. He’d wanted her for so long. Her lips tasted like heaven, and her skin was soft as silk under his finger tips. He longed for her touch, her kiss. He was drunk on her, and he would do anything right now to have more.

“Shed,” he growled with a smile, nodding towards the pool house that stood next to the hot tub at the other end.

With a smile Lexi hopped out of the pool, taking his hand and skipping across the concrete. James watched as her tight little ass bounced and jiggled, all the while imagining what it would feel like as it moved under his hands. They reached the door of the shed, and after a quick peek back at the house, dipped inside.

The shed was small, nearly the size of a jail cell, with one window on the side wall opposite the door. The moonlight shone through the glass, lighting the dirty floor and the insatiable couple that stood on it. Their lips met again, James’ hands finding Lexi’s waist quickly, pulling her into him with a grunt. Her arms reached up to wrap around his neck, pulling his face into hers roughly, biting his lip again. She could feel the heat rising in her groin, a warm wetness of desire and lust that couldn’t be ignored.

Lexi turned the two of them, and with a giggle shoved James down onto a pile of blow up mattresses. He landed with a plop and a surprised laugh, the smile fading from his face as he looked up at her.

“Off,” she giggled, motioning to his boxers, which he shimmied out of quicker than a hiccup, revealing his long, stiff member. Lexi’s eyes found it, biting her lip softly. She was going to enjoy this.

“Well come on,” James said to her, putting a hand around his shaft and giving it a few quick strokes, his heart fluttering in his chest.

He watched as her tone changed. No longer was she the competitive, sporty girl he’d sparred with since freshman year. No longer was she the sort of quirky artistic girl who’d decided to paint portraits rather than major in advertising. Right now, in this moment, she was Aphrodite. She was lust, she was sex, she was sinful desire.

He watched as her eyes turned to fire, stooping down to relieve herself of her panties, watching them fall to the floor with a wet plop. Her eyes met his as her hands slipped behind her back, her shoulders lifting for just a second before James saw the straps of her bra loosen, falling past her elbows. He watched her white bra fall impossibly slow to the floor, her bare breasts now glowing in the moonlight in front of him. They were shaped like perfect pillows, mounds of flesh that gracefully protruded from her chest, hanging softly in place. Atop each was a rock hard nipple, sticking out for all it was worth.

“Well..?” she said slowly, walking closer to him as he laid on the makeshift inflatable sofa.

“You’re.. oh my God. Lexi you’re gorgeous.”

“Shut up and fuck me,” she answered with a smile before clambering on top of him, her legs straddling his torso, her slender fingers finding his cock at her groin. She bent down to kiss him, their lips meeting as she guided his shaft to the opening of her perfect little flower, the tip of his member touching her entrance, the warmth flowing through him. He couldn’t help himself, and after a split second raised his hips gently, forcing his mushroom like helmet inside her.

She moaned loudly into his mouth as she lowered herself onto him, feeling him fill her up. His groans told her that he was enjoying this too, and soon they were making the rubber mattresses elicit soft squeaking sounds as she lifted and lowered her hips again and again. His cock slid into her swiftly and deep, finding parts of her she didn’t know were there. It wasn’t long before she was whimpering loudly, and raised her chest to lean back, his cock pressing hard into her g-spot.

“Fuck..!” she breathed, looking down at him. His hands pulled her hips back and forth on his lap, while her own fingers found her swollen clit, rubbing it furiously as she rode herself to orgasm. “Fuck James,” was the last thing that left her mouth before she clapped a hand over it, moaning loudly into her soft skin. Though muffled, James was sure someone could hear her cries of pleasure, and softly smiled to himself as he watched her writhing on his cock. His hips lifted to meet her, and he reached a hand up to cup one of her breasts, finding her nipple and twisting it with vigor.

She screamed into her hand, placing one on his chest and digging her nails in violently, her pussy spasming around his shaft. Lexi moaned loudly as her second orgasm left her, the tingles causing goosebumps to form on her soft, pillowy ass cheeks. James’ hands felt them, and he laid a playful swat against her rump as she paused for a moment, her legs shivering as she doubled over on top of him.

“Fuck I’ve been waiting so long to do this,” Lexi said softly, kissing him again. “Fuck me.”

She looked deep into his eyes, her emerald green irises peering into his soul as she began to ride him again, flexing her tight pussy hard as he slid in and out of her. James’ grunts and groans told her all she needed to know, and 10 strokes later his jaw was tensed tightly, his thighs flexed and pulled taut. She watched as his face contorted, his hips holding their place rather than thrust into her. He was holding out, trying to make it last. Lexi giggled softly before leaning down to meet him nose to nose.

“It’s ok James,” she whispered softly, kissing him as she whimpered. She was on the edge herself. “You can cum in my pussy. You know you want to. You’re the winner,” she added with a smile, just as he let out a loud groan.

“Fuck!” he roared, his hips now frantically plunging his shaft deep inside the beautiful, athletic girl, his cock tingling with each thrust. Their cries mixed, and seconds later he felt it. His hands gripped her ass tightly, his knuckles going white as he felt his member spasm violently before releasing its load. His head fell back as he felt spurt after spurt shoot into her warm pussy, the wetness of their lust mixing together.

Lexi smiled and let out a gentle moan as she felt him twitch inside her, his cum finding its home in her wet sex.

“Yesss..” she breathed as her pace slowed, and soon they sat still, save for panting breaths between them. With a moan Lexi slid off his cock, giggling softly as she watched it flop onto his stomach, and felt his cum run down her thighs.

Spent and red faced, James laid against the blow-up mattresses, his chest heaving as he tried to catch his breath. Before him stood the most beautiful woman he’d met, her slender body bathed in moonlight as her shimmering green eyes looked him over. Painted on her face was a smile, her breaths still bated slightly as she picked up her underwear.

“What?” James said with a smile, sitting upright on the inflatables.

“Nothing,” Lexi said with a giggle pulling her panties back on as she grabbed her bra. “Let me know when the next swim meet is,” she quipped with a wink, bending down to give him a peck on the nose before sashaying out of the shed.

“I’ll be in the living room with that bottle of vodka,” she called out over her shoulder, cackling into the night as she crossed the yard heading back to the house, her ass swaying back and forth hypnotically, James’ eyes drawn to it, wondering when or if he’d see it again.

“Hang on!” he shouted, stumbling his way out of the shed as he pulled his boxers on clumsily, racing back towards the party. “Betcha a kiss I can beat you in flip cup!”

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/bkwwjq/winner_fm_young_adults_college_hookup_friends