[MF] Turning some good Christian girls bad [long]

I apologize up front for the long lead-up to the good stuff. The background, I think, helps illuminate why these events were so memorable. Dialogue is “reimagined” for story telling purposes as this was some time ago (20+ years). Also, some cheating is involved so if you don’t like that, stop here.

Back when I was an undergrad, I ended up at school somewhere I didn’t quite fit in: the students were generally very religious (I was/am not) and from small towns (I was not).

My junior year, I’m sharing an apartment with two guys: one is a sophomore and the other is a senior who graduated and moved out halfway through the year. As for the sophomore, he was as described: religious and from a small town. A few of the kids from his town ended up at the same university. This story starts with Maggie (well call her).

Maggie was about 5’7”, thin, borderline b/c cups, and also very religious. Also, my roommate was in love with her. Like, he would have married her on the spot. She wasn’t interested. However, she flirts with me. She has a boyfriend so I think this isn’t going anywhere, plus, she’s saving herself for marriage. The only thing she ever did was she gave her boyfriend a blowjob (they had been making out and were both all worked up), but her boyfriend freaked out after (he was saving himself for marriage too) and they had to make sure they never lost control like that again. One night she tells me that she really liked doing it and she was disappointed he never did anything afterwards. He’s actually even too scared to even make out intensely. Our flirting amped up after that.

In the spring, she comes over one Friday night with a friend to hang out. I’d say I’m friends with the two of them as well as they came over a lot. Her boyfriend left town for the weekend and she was looking for something to do. I had some alcohol and my roommate decides to drink for the first time and he got shitfaced. He passed out. He’s in bed and Maggie is hanging out still. She leaning on the counter in the way into the kitchen. I’m walking behind her to get into the kitchen to get some water. I put my hand on her hip and say excuse me as I try to pass behind her. Well, I apparently wasn’t excused as she pushed her hips back so her ass is against my crotch. I put my hand on her other hip and hold her there.

“Are we doing this?” I ask.
“No intercourse, but, yes. Please?”

She starts to move her ass against me and I move a hand up and start rubbing her tits and I start kissing her neck. We move on to full on making out and I take her over to the couch. I get her top off and bra and I suck and play with her tits more. My hand slides into her shorts and panties and I find her pussy. She’s wet and my fingers go to work. While I’m fingering her and rubbing her clit, we continue to make out and I play with her tits. She’s getting closer and closer to cumming.

What do I see out of the corner of my eye? Her friend, we’ll call her Dana. Dana, like Maggie, was very religious, from a very small rural town, was saving herself for marriage, and had a boyfriend (also saving himself for marriage). She was about 5’1”, reddish hair, a cute face, she wasn’t thin but she wasn’t thick or anything, and a set of big, DD tits that sat high and proud on her chest.

I totally forgot about her. She went to nap when my roommate was getting drunk as she was very uncomfortable around alcohol. She woke up and I have no idea how long she’s been watching. Not long after I notice her, Maggie cums.

As Maggie recovers I pull out my cock and when she’s ready, she gets on her knees on the floor and starts to suck me. She wasn’t very good, this was only the second time she ever it did. At this point I have my back to Dana but I can see her reflection in the TV. I tell Maggie what to do, etc., and Dana never leaves. She watches the whole time. At one point she absent mindedly rubs her tits.

Maggie gets the job done and I ask where she wants me to cum. She isn’t sure so, being the gentleman that I am, I pull out and cum on her tits. She looked a little surprised but not mad. I announce that I’m getting a towel to wipe her off so that Dana can sneak back into the darkness.

She cleans up and gets dressed and says she better go. I give her a deep kiss and she goes to “wake up” Dana and leave.

About 3 days later, my phone rings. It’s Dana. We exchanged pleasantries.

“I saw you and Maggie the other night”

“I know. I saw you peeking.”

“She was cheating on [whatever his name was].”

“I guess she was. It’s not my problem. That was Maggie’s decision.”

“She was saving herself until you did that.”

“ I didn’t fuck her. She’s still a Virgin. Again, she could have said no and stopped it. She didn’t. She wanted to.”

“I have to tell [whatever his name was].”

“Ok. You do that. Does Maggie know you know?”

“No.”

“You should talk to her first before you do anything.”

“Umm, yeah I will.”

“I know you enjoyed the show.”

She hung up.

The next night, Maggie calls and asks if she can come over. Of course, I say and she comes over. She recaps her conversation with Dana and how it all worked out and Dana understood and will stay quiet. Relief sets in and we start to make out. I finger her and make her cum again. She blows me again and makes me cum.

A week goes by and it’s the weekend. It’s Saturday afternoon Easter weekend so most students went home for the holiday weekend. I didn’t as it was too far. My phone rings. It’s Dana. We exchanged pleasantries.

“I’m not going to say anything.”

“I know, I talked with Maggie. You’re not going home?”

“I don’t have a ride or way to get home so I’m staying this weekend.”

“Sorry. Want to do something? Movie or something? Not a date, I know you have a boyfriend.”

“Ummm, sure.”

We make details and i agree to pick her up at her dorm later.

Later comes and I pick her up and we go to the movie, get something to eat. All very chaste and no flirting. I drop her off at her dorm and go back to my place.

Three hours later, my phone rings. It’s Dana. She can’t sleep and was wondering if she can come over and hang out. Sure I say and that I’ll pick her up.

We’re at my place and I put a movie on and we sit (opposite ends of the couch) and watch it. After a while…

“I’m sorry for sticking my nose in with Maggie.”

“It’s fine, it’s resolved.”

“I watched.”

“I know you did. I saw you out of the corner of my eye and your reflection in the TV screen. You watched for a while.”

“I did.”

“Did you like it?”

pause … “I did.”

“What did Maggie tell you about it?”

pause … “She told me how much better it felt than just … you know … touching yourself.”

“Does your boyfriend touch you?”

“No. Never. I mean, we kiss and one time I kind of rubbed myself against him, but we stopped so that we didn’t get carried away.”

“Did you stop or did he want to stop?”

“Ummm he did but … I guess I did too, sort of …”

“It’s ok if you didn’t want to stop. It felt good I’m sure.”

“It did.”

“Did you touch yourself later?”

pause … “I did…. I was jealous of Maggie. I want someone to touch me like that.”

I inched closer and put my hand on her thigh and started to rub it. “You were? There’s a lot of guys who would love to touch you like that. I would.” I inch closer

pause … “yeah, I was kind of hoping … I mean … it would be a secret, right? You wouldn’t say anything to anyone, right? Not even Maggie.”

I move closer, “No one. It would be our secret.”

She looks at me and bites her lip. “You have to tell me you want it,” I say to her.

“I want it.”

“Want what?”

“For you to touch me … there.”

With that I pull her onto my lap and our lips meet and we kiss. She moves so that she’s straddling me and we start kissing more and more intensely. She’s grinding herself against me feeling my cock.

I eventually lead her to the bedroom and put her in my bed. I unbutton her shorts and, like with Maggie, slide my hand into her panties to find a warm, wet pussy waiting for me. I slide my fingers up and down her slit getting them nice and wet. I find her clit and start to give it attention. We continue to kiss as I rub her. It takes a while before she can really relax when she finally does, the moans really increase and before long her body tenses up and she cums with a loud release of pleasure and cums all over my hand.

I undo my pants and get my cock out. I start to stroke it with my hand that is soaking wet from her to get my cock lubricated. I lay on my back and take her hand and put it on my rock hard cock. I guide her hand showing her what to do.

It’s her first time ever touching a cock and it showed. But she got into a rhythm and she gets the job done. I clean myself off. It’s really late now and she asks if she can just sleep here. I tell her yes and she gets up to go to the spare room. I stop her and tell her to stay in my bed. She does.

We make each other cum again in the morning and I sneak her out and back to her dorm.

We kept getting together for the remaining two years I was at school going further and further. She loved sex and we hooked up every chance we could, keeping it all a secret as she was still the good Christian girl who loved her boyfriend. (And, Yes, I kept meeting up with Maggie too. Not as frequently and things never progressed from the blowjob/fingering stage. And, yes, eventually, my roommate found out about Maggie and I.)

If there’s interest to hear about the continued hook-ups and progression, say so and I’ll write about some of them.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bj6x3j/mf_turning_some_good_christian_girls_bad_long