Playing Cowboys and Indians – [mff]

I love reading the stories here and figured it was time to share a one of my own from my younger days. Things aren’t as crazy nowadays at 34 but every now and again I think of these times and jerk off once…or twice.

So this story happened some time around my sophomore or junior year of undergrad. My friends and I usually threw parties Thursday – Sunday because hey why not, right? When we were feeling particularly motivated we would come up with a theme and this night we lazily tossed out the idea of cowboys and Indians. Clever, I know.

So we throw a cowboy and Indian party. Most of the people show up with a cowboy hat, a feather or some other minimal costume that vaguely relates to the theme. We tap the keg and the beer starts flowing and eventually a beer pong tournament breaks out. My buddy Dave and I were absolutely lethal at beer pong and quickly started running the table. Eventually we’ve soundly beat everyone and everyone is complaining that it’s not fun.

I look and Dave and suggest we up the ante. Who wants to play us and the loser has to do a striptease/lap dance. Right away our friends Lauren and Rachel say they’re in. Lauren is a tall red head, about 5’8” with a runners body. She’s got some very perky B cups that I may have sucked in the past and was hoping I might see again if we won. Rachel is a shorter, petite brunette with blonde highlights. She’s got a smaller chest but she’s drop dead gorgeous.

With the challengers in we get to it. It actually ends up being a pretty close game despite Lauren and Rachel being terrible at beer pong. We end up eventually winning by 1 cup – which by then was super hard to hit because my cock was getting harder and harder as we got closer and closer to victory. The girls whined and said we cheated but ultimately said a deal is a deal so they’d each give us a lap dance.

Now Dave had a girlfriend at the time and right as Lauren and Rachel grabbed our hands to escort us into Lauren’s room one of my friends reminded Dave that this was probably crossing a line. He thought good and hard about this and ultimately said he shouldn’t go through with it. I didn’t fight him on it because even though he was out I sure as fuck wasn’t.

I wave goodbye and follow Lauren and Rachel into Lauren’s room. Lauren closes the door and locks it and immediately my cock goes from half mast to full hardo in no time at all. Fuck yes. Lauren then grabs Rachel and walks towards me. They giggle and share an innocent quick kiss before grabbing me by the top of my jeans and throwing me onto Lauren’s bed.

Both the girls sit on my lap, each straddling one of my legs and slowly the start to kiss each other. First it was just a peck here and there but soon it turned into a full blown makeout session. Lauren was moving her hands over Rachel’s tits and pinching her nipples through her costume. Each time Lauren would let go of her Rachel would moan and look deep into my eyes. Then it hit me – shit they might actually fuck each other!

As they kissed they were grinding against my legs and moving their hands around my belt. Each time they did this one of them would casually brush their hand against the outline of my dick and shoot me a flirty look. After a few more minutes of this I was worried I was going to cum in my jeans – both Lauren and Rachel looked so hot as they kissed. Suddenly Rachel pulled away from Lauren and looked at me with the sexiest fucking eyes I have ever seen then turned back towards Lauren and started to pull Lauren’s shirt up and over her head. Lauren, saying it wasn’t fair that she was the only one without a shirt and grabbed Rachel’s shirt and pulled it off. As Rachel’s shirt came off I saw that she wasn’t wearing a bra. Her small, beautiful and perfectly round tits were now in full view – I couldn’t believe it. She has these perfect small pink nipples and she immediately grabbed them and leaned over close to my neck. She pinched and twisted her nipples subtly and moaned into my ear, “mmmmmm!”

Rachel then put her hand right on my dick and started rubbing up and down. Playtime was over, it seemed. Lauren, not wanting to be left out took off her bra and threw it aside, showing off her perky tits. Lauren pushed her milky breasts together and leaned over and started sucking on Rachel’s nipples! I couldn’t fucking believe this. Lauren was sucking on Rachel’s tits while Rachel was running her hand up and down my cock and licking my ear! I was in absolute heaven and thought this couldn’t get any better!

Rachel is rubbing my cock when she whispers into my ear, “I want to fuck you so bad right now,” as she circles my ear with her tongue and lightly bites it. I almost came right then and there but somehow managed to have the presence of mind to remain focused. I think I mumble something like I’d love to. The words aren’t out of my mouth before Rachel is undoing my belt and tugging on my pants. Lauren, who was still sucking on Rachel’s nipple, slides over and off of me so that Rachel can actually pull my pants off. As soon as Lauren is off my leg my dick is out and ready to party.

Rachel wastes no time and starts licking the shaft of my dick, slowly running her tongue from the tip of my head to my balls and back again. Each time she makes her way back to my head she circles the tip with her tongue and takes a bit more into her mouth until she’s eventually deep throating me. Its pure bliss. I grab her head and begin to throat fuck her right in front of Lauren, who by now has striped down to her panties and is rubbing her pussy as she watches Rachel gag on my dick. I can’t believe this is happening!

I reach over and grab Lauren’s pussy soaked fingers and give them a taste – she taste’s so damn good. Rachel looks up and with her eyes tells me she wants a taste as well. I replace Lauren’s fingers with mine and gently start mousing over Lauren’s clit, sinking two fingers into her pussy. I then pull Rachel’s mouth off my dick and let her taste Lauren’s juice. She starts sucking on my fingers like she was just sucking on my dick! Holy fuck, she’s totally into Lauren!!!

This becomes too much for Rachel. Rachel stands up, says its time for her to be fucked, grabs me by the dick and walks over to Lauren’s vanity where she promptly bends over and spreads her legs. She’s incredibly wet and begging me to fuck her but I decide I want to tease her a bit first. I ask Lauren if I should fuck Rachel. Lauren says I should so I take my dick and lightly move it around Rachel’s pussy, inching closer and closer to pushing into her. Well Rachel doesn’t want to wait and reaches around and pushes me inside her. Hot damn she’s tight, and her lips grip me instantly.

Rachel screams for me to fuck her. She wants it hard and fast so who am I to deny her. I speed up my tempo and start fucking her like this is our last night on earth. Lauren is still rubbing her pussy watching me rail Rachel and moaning as she moves her hips towards us. This is about all I can take. Rachel is begging for me to cum in her at this point and I try to hold back as long as I can but between her amazing pussy and Lauren masturbating next to us I know I don’t have long.

Suddenly something comes over me and I pull out of Rachel. I move towards Lauren and without a word I move her hand, pull her panties to the side, and start fucking Lauren. Lauren cums all over my dick as soon as I’m inside her. Her legs squeeze my hips and she pulls me close to her. She’s cumming all over me as I kiss her breasts and try to keep pumping. She shudders and I slide out of her and begin to turn around but Rachel is now right behind me and stroking me from behind. With her hands she pushes me back inside Lauren and starts rubbing Lauren’s pussy as she is pushing my dick in and out of her. Lauren starts to seize up again and feels like she’s cumming again!

I’m starting to get woozy from the pure ecstasy I am feeling and let both the girls know I’m gonna lose it. Rachel begs for my cum. She spins me around, drops to her knees and starts cleaning Lauren’s juices off me! That’s all I can take. I grab Rachel’s head, tell her I’m cumming and push my cock into her throat as far as I can. Rachel gags on my dick but is ready. I announce to Rachel (and probably everyone outside the thin ass door) that I’m cumming and thrust into her mouth over and over. I shoot hot ropes straight down her throat that Rachel happily takes. She is swallowing every last drop – I can’t feel my toes! When I’m spent and finally pull out of Rachel’s mouth she stands up, walks over to Lauren, and kisses her with my cum still in her mouth. They begin to make out with my cum between the two of them, each rubbing each other’s pussies before Rachel moans so loud and squirts between Lauren’s fingers. “Holy shit!!!!” Rachel screams as she pushes Lauren’s fingers deeper inside and grinds against her.

After this we all collapse on Lauren’s bed and start to re-assess the whole thing. Holy shit, we just had a semi-threesome! I had no idea Lauren and Rachel we’re into each other – what a way to find out! We lie there naked for a few more moments before we remember there is still a raging cowboy and Indian party outside. How long were we in here fucking? We all start laughing and begin to get dressed.

We’re mostly fully clothed again and we’re getting ready to rejoin the chaos outside but before we do I have a request of Lauren and Rachel. I’ve always fantasized about two girls blowing me at the same time. I figure I have to shoot my shot and so I ask if they could drop to their knees and blow me real quick. I don’t need to finish I tell them, I just want to the visual and to feel free what’s it’s like to have gorgeous girls blow me at the same time. They laugh and say why not, we all practically fucked anyway.

So they get back on their knees, pull out my dick once more, and start kissing and licking my dick all over! Guys, it’s as good as you think it is. I’m hard again and I’m already ready to cum. I start to stammer oh shit I think I’m gonna cum again. Lauren and Rachel speed up and take turns popping me in and out of their mouths, stroking me as they do. I give them one final warning, scream oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck before I cum. Lauren and Rachel are literally milking the cum right out of me. I’m weak, the room is spinning, this is surely heaven.

The girls lick up every last drop, compose themselves, kiss once more before getting up, and walk over to the door. I’m still trying to figure out what year it is with my pants around my ankles when Lauren opens the door to rejoin the party. There’s a commotion – everyone knows what we were doing. The room reeks of sex. Rachel follows Lauren and I’m finally able to start getting dressed.

I still can’t believe that just happened. I make way back to the party and let Dave know he really missed out. Dave is floored – he can’t believe I just fucked Lauren and Rachel.

There’s more to the story from that evening but I’ve rambled on long enough. If there’s interest i can post a follow up. I’m glad I could share one of my hottest memories with everyone, now if you’ll excuse me, I suddenly need to jerk off again.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/aunrb8/playing_cowboys_and_indians_mff