New Years Cheating Creampie Quickie [29M/31F]

It was New Years Eve 2015, my friends invited me to a house party, I had not been to one since my college days. They told me everyone was going to be doing Ecstasy, which I thought was interesting. I normally don’t do drugs these days but this was a special occasion and I figured why not.

A little background on me, recently I’ve come to understand that I’m a fairly handsome guy and women give me opportunities that I was previously oblivious to. Also, I’ve recently started to make a pretty good income, which has made me aware of my “position” in the dating game. But I digress.

It’s about 10 PM and I’m feeling the Ecstasy. I’m just wandering around the big house, looking for a place to sit down and relax away from all the noise. I open a door to a room and there are a bunch of people in there just laying on the bed, bean bag chairs, just feeling good, talking, touching. Everyone is fully clothed. They invited me into the bed. There were 5 of us. A girl to the far left, guy next to her, Me, a girl to my right, and a guy next to her. As I laid there I noticed the girl to the far my left was just staring at me, hard. I stared back and gave her a wink. She started talking to me, making small talk, after a few minutes I said I wanted to be against the wall so I moved positions next to the girl I was talking to. She was cute, not a bombshell but definitely turned me on. 5’1, 140, slightly chubby, really cute innocent face, big nerdy librarian glasses, chin length dirty blonde hair and a sexy voice.

As soon as I laid down next to her she pushed her ass back into my groin. I pushed back and put my hand on her hip. I started touching her, my fingers finding the inside of her waistband, trying to get her hot and bothered while talking to her about her life. When I would try to grab she would push my hand away. But then she’d pull my hand back to the spot a second later. I didn’t know what to make of this; at first I thought she didn’t want to be touched but she kept doing it so I got the feeling she likes the idea of pushing a man away but actually wants him to continue. Turns out the guy laying next to her is her boyfriend. Maybe she didn’t want to let me go too far around her bf. I got the vibe that they are swingers though. After a little bit everyone decides to leave the room and it’s not my house or room, so I follow suit. Nothing happened.

After we all left the room, sometime later I am walking around the house. The girl (Amelia) and I were walking down a hallway passing each other when we both stopped to talk. We didn’t talk. We just smiled at looked at each other. Her look said it all.

We were right in front of a bathroom door so I took her hand and led her inside and locked the door. As soon as we were locked in the bathroom we started kissing hard. I started kissing her neck as I grabbed 2 hand fulls of her nice plump ass. She let out a little moan and pushed her pussy against my already hard cock. I felt up her body and quickly pulled her pants and underwear down to her calves and bent her over the bathroom counter. I pulled down my pants and boxers and as I pulled out my cock to slide it in she looked at me and said, “just don’t cum inside me”. “Sure”, I said.

I licked 2 fingers to lube and open her up, but she had all the wetness we would need. I fingered her for a moment, letting her moan and get eager for the impending fuck she was about to get. After about 30 seconds, I slid my fingers out and positioned my cock at her entrance from behind and pushed inside. She let out a loud “mmmmugggh” sound as I slid in. This made me nervous as we were at a party and her boyfriend was there too.

As I bottomed out in her pussy she turned around and gave me a sultry look and smiled as if to say “I’m glad your cock is inside me”. I started fucking her hard. She had her first orgasm within a minute and another one a few minutes later. The whole time letting out little moans of, “mmm” “mmm” “mmm” and “yeah yeah yeah yeah”. I was so horny from the rush of it all I came after like 5 minutes.

When I was going to cum I said, “I want to cum inside you”.

Without looking at me, I could just see her eyes closed in the mirror, she was in ecstasy, she said, “just do it”, in a low voice.

I exploded inside her. It didn’t feel like the usual ropes of jizz, it felt like 2 big bursts of cum, she wiggled her ass on my cummy cock as my thrusts slowed down. As I pulled out of her she put her hand under her pussy to catch the cum that was leaking out and went to sit on the toilet to push out the rest of my load. As she sat on the toilet getting the cum out she pulled me in with my cock and cleaned the remaining cum and pussy juice off me in her mouth. She did such a good job I could tell I was ready to get hard again. She gave my cock a little kiss at the end and with the head of my cock on her lips gave me a great big smile that said she wanted to do this again. We left the bathroom and luckily everyone was none the wiser.

The next day I got a friend request from her on Facebook. She’s been swallowing my loads about once a week since then. Creampies are my fetish but she’s not on birth control and she has a boyfriend so it’s not the best idea; when I’m ready to cum she jumps off my cock, snakes around, and sucks the nut out and swallows like it’s the best thing she’s ever tasted.

Comments and PMs welcome. Love to hear from my fellow redditors. Different stories with different girls to follow if you guys want to hear about them.

TL;DR: Being handsome is actually all its cracked up to be, haha. Quite a change for a guy who was on the Math Team in high school

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/450spz/new_years_cheating_creampie_quickie_29m31f