After a break up, I was exploring all my dating options including browsing Craigslist occasionally. Without any luck at parties, I spent a little more time on the site, but the lack of real women lead me to search in the mw4m section. One day I came across a couple with a few photos of a gorgeous girl. She had a tight body, smaller perky breasts and green eyes. I don’t remember if they included a photo of him or not. I sent them an email with my stats and what I was into while I jacked out to her photos. They responded and said they were interested so after a few initial emails of feeling each other out, we decided to meet up that weekend.
I drove over to their apartment and was met by him downstairs. He was about my height, wearing gym shorts with a little bit of a stubble (I’m 5’10 and a swimmer). We had a beer or two together to make sure we were both normal and set ground rules. It was straight forward and we made quickly made rapport with one another.
After the beers, we made our way upstairs to their bedroom where she was already on the bed. We made our introductions but she didn’t say much. He started kissing her and she begin to touch both of us. In no time, we lost all of our clothes. She was between us and had both of our cocks in her hands gently stroking us while I was touching her leg and breasts. I usually get hard quickly but for some reason I wasn’t getting hard which was weird since I had this beautiful girl stroking me. I glanced down to see what she was doing and I couldn’t happen to notice his cock. While I’m happy with my size, he had an inch or two on me plus his was thick with large balls. It was the first time seeing another man’s cock up close and I couldn’t help but feel attracted to it. I also think it had some effect on me retaining a hard-on.
At this point, she got down on her knees and start sucking us off. He and I were next to each other watching her go to work. My cock still wasn’t hard despite her efforts while his was throbbing. I was staring at his cock and I think she noticed, because she took her mouth off my cock and slowly licked up his cock. He also saw that my cock wasn’t hard and he told me not worry about it and relax. He then said he has a trick to get hard and took my cock in his hands. He gripped it at its base with one hand and stroked it with the other. While it felt good, it wasn’t working. She was watching us and then said to me ‘isn’t his cock so big? Why don’t you help me out with it?’ She guided my hand to his cock and I started masturbating him while he was still touching me. It felt hard but soft and warm, and much thicker than mine.
I’m not sure how it happened, but he ended up taking my cock in his mouth. After a few moments, he stopped and they began to convince me into sucking his cock. He said it was the first time sucking cock for him too while she was saying how hot it would be to see me suck my first cock. She told me that I had been staring at it the entire time. I don’t think I could say no to her as she licked her lips as I moved towards his cock. It filled my mouth and I could only take a few inches of it. While we started in a sideways 69 position after a while I noticed that only I was the only one doing the sucking while they were watching me. She was masturbating whispering things to him (probably to put his hand my head, which he did). He also starting grabbing and slapping my ass. I don’t know how I got into this position (on my hands and knees sucking a cock, having my ass groped, all in-front of a woman I wanted to fuck) having gone over there to fuck her but it just felt like a natural progression.
I think at this point, she lost sexual interest in me after watching me suck her boyfriend and being handled like a woman. Maybe at the beginning of the night she had plans to take two cocks but now she had something different in mind. He got up after a while and went to another room, so I crawled over to her and she told me to lick her. As I was eating her out, I was on my hands and knees with my ass in the air. I heard him come back into the room and do something behind me. I felt him come up behind me and then felt something on my asshole. I couldn’t turn around as she had her hands on my head to keep me focused on her. I felt some pressure on my hole and after some resistance and a little pain, his cock slide into me. While it was uncomfortable at first, I relaxed and began to feel ‘full’. He began slowly pumping and building a rhythm. I think I was moaning unintentionally because she begin to comment things like ‘oh I think he likes it’ and ‘do you like taking a man’s cock?’ She was touching herself in front of me and was getting off degrading me about how I didn’t get hard by her. I didn’t hear everything she said but she went along the lines that I wouldn’t ever satisfy a woman again and I was cock-lover now.
Mostly it was all a blur and I lost track of time. After he pulled out, we were on the bed and I was lying between them. He was commenting on how sexy my ass was and slapping it. She told me it was alright that I wasn’t straight anymore and she was glad she could help. I think I mustered something along the lines that I was straight but she said after watching me suck her man’s cock and willingly giving my ass up to another man she knew I wasn’t straight. Plus I couldn’t get hard despite a hot woman sucking my cock. While he was cool about it all, I felt that she definitely looked at me differently at the end of the night.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/a74n1j/threesome_mmf_takes_an_unexpected_turn
Very lucky guy! Definitely a fantasy of mine at the moment.
Did you ever get a rematch?